Concept
Other Goods Subcategories
Classification of goods (§ 9-102)
Other Goods Subcategories
Four defined terms sort goods by what they are joined to or drawn from, not by how the debtor uses them: fixtures, manufactured homes, accessions, and as-extracted collateral. Section 9-102 defines each one, in subsections (a)(41), (a)(53), (a)(1), and (a)(6)(A), and lists them as subcategories of goods beside the principal classes of consumer goods, inventory, farm products, and equipment.1 The principal classes ask how the debtor uses the goods. The four subcategories ask a different question, so one item can carry a label from each set, and a fixture is always also consumer goods or equipment.2 Counters permanently affixed to the floor of a store are fixtures because of how they are attached, and the store's use of them in its business places them in the equipment class.
Each subcategory marks a point where the goods meet something else that Article 9 must take into account. Fixtures meet real property law: Article 9 generally leaves interests in real property to real estate law, and fixtures are one of the exceptions.3 Accessions are goods physically united with other goods. Manufactured homes are dwellings that the definition of goods names expressly.4 Oil, gas, and other minerals are excluded from goods before extraction, so an interest that takes hold only as they come out of the ground needs a definition of its own.5
This section takes the four in turn and leaves the filing and priority consequences of each label to later readings. The fixture comes first, because its test comes from real property law.
Fixtures
Section 9-102(a)(41) defines fixtures as goods that have become so related to particular real property that an interest in them arises under real property law.6 Two conditions sit in that sentence. The thing must first be goods, which means a movable thing when the security interest attaches, and the definition of goods names fixtures expressly, so attachment to land does not take an item outside the term.7 “Thing movable” is the phrase that separates personal property from real property.8 The thing must also have become so related to a particular parcel of land that real property law recognizes an interest in it. A furnace affixed to a house is the standard example.9
Article 9 does not write its own test for that second condition. It is a comprehensive scheme for security interests in personal property and fixtures,10 but it generally leaves interests in real property to real estate law, with an exception for fixtures,11 and whether property is a fixture is largely left to non-Code state law.12 Real estate law therefore decides whether goods are fixtures. Once they are, property rights in them are governed both by real estate law and by the law of personal property.13 The Code adds a separate fixture filing, a financing statement covering goods that are or are to become fixtures, and a later reading takes up its mechanics.14
Because real property law supplies the test, the answer turns on the facts and on the state. State law usually looks to the parties' intent, but the intent that counts is the objectively discernible one. The factors are how far the goods have become part of the building, how fully they are integrated into it, how hard they are to remove once affixed, and what type of goods they are.15 Informal shortcuts settle little. In a case about a central pivot irrigation system, a court set out two of them. Under one, an item that a single hammer blow could move more than half an inch is not a fixture. Under the other, an item is a fixture unless it can be loosened with a screwdriver and a wrench within an hour. The court endorsed neither and observed that even the “objective” tests fail to give a clear determination.16
Attachment runs along a spectrum, and the fixture label fits only the middle of it. Free-standing refrigerators and stoves never take on any aspect of real property, and carpeting merely tacked to a floor is not a fixture either.17 A furnace affixed to a house, counters permanently affixed to the floor of a store, and a sprinkler system installed in a building are standard fixtures.18 An oven or dishwasher built into kitchen cabinetry, or an air conditioner built into a window, may become one.19
At the far end of the spectrum, goods lose their separate character as personal property. Lumber and bricks are personal property when they are delivered to a building site, but once they are used to construct the building they become part of it. They are then no longer personal property, and they are not fixtures either.20 Article 9 accordingly recognizes no security interest in ordinary building materials incorporated into an improvement on land.21
The same heating unit can carry different labels over time. On a supplier's shelf it is held for sale and so is inventory.22 Goods are not normally affixed to real estate while they are held for sale, so it is difficult to conceive of goods that are both inventory and fixtures. Once installed, the unit may become a fixture, and as personal property under the Code it is then consumer goods or equipment.23 Two errors recur. One treats attachment as the whole test and calls any item that touches a building a fixture, when the definition requires an interest arising under real property law. The other assumes that a fixture has left Article 9 for real estate law, when the Code includes fixtures within goods and both bodies of law apply once goods qualify.
Accessions
Section 9-102(a)(1) defines an accession as goods physically united with other goods in such a manner that the identity of the original goods is not lost.25 Two features do the work. Physical union means that one item is joined to another so that together they form a single object. Preserved identity means that the combined object still contains recognizably separate goods, so a person can say which part is the added item and which part is the thing it was added to. Accession describes how goods connect to other goods, as fixture describes how goods relate to land, and like the fixture label it sits beside the principal class of the goods without replacing it.
A new engine built into a used automobile fits both features. After installation the car runs on the engine, yet the engine is still an engine and the car is still a car, so each remains separately identifiable.26 Wheat poured into a silo with other wheat gives the opposite result. Goods that lose their identity when combined are commingled goods, a different category from accessions, and once the wheat is mixed nothing separate remains to identify.27 Both examples involve goods that have been combined, so combination cannot be the test. The question the definition asks is whether anything separately identifiable survives.
Accessions and fixtures are easy to run together, since both involve one thing being joined to another. The definitions keep them apart. An accession is goods united with other goods, and a fixture is goods related to land, while building materials built into a house are neither.28
Because accessions keep their identity, the secured party financing the part and the one financing the whole can each describe a definite item. Each will need a security agreement that identifies its collateral, and the agreement may do so through a separate attached list containing an unlimited number of items, such as vehicles listed by make, model, and VIN. Security interests have been found invalid where the attorney forgot to attach the list.29 How the two secured parties rank against each other is a question for a later reading.
Manufactured Homes
Section 9-102(a)(53) defines a manufactured home as a structure, transportable in one or more sections, built on a permanent chassis and designed to be used as a dwelling, with or without a permanent foundation, when connected to the required utilities.31 The term includes the plumbing, heating, air-conditioning, and electrical systems contained in the structure. It also carries minimum dimensions: in the traveling mode, eight body feet or more in width or 40 body feet or more in length, or, when erected on site, 320 or more square feet.32
The definition of goods names manufactured homes, so a structure that qualifies is goods without a separate inquiry into whether it is movable when the security interest attaches.33 That method differs from the one used for fixtures, which turns on intent, integration, and difficulty of removal under state law.34 A manufactured home is identified instead by physical features, and each does its own work. The permanent chassis and the transportability in sections mark a structure built elsewhere and moved to its site. The design for use as a dwelling separates a home from other transportable structures. And the words “with or without” a permanent foundation keep the home inside the definition however it is finally set up, because the test looks to how the structure was designed and not to how the owner later installs it.
The line shows up in everyday terms. What are generally called mobile homes are manufactured homes if they are intended to be placed on a pad and used as a permanent home, and recreational vehicles intended to be used only for vacations are not.35 Both units are transportable and both may ride on a chassis, so mobility cannot be what separates them. The separating feature is the dwelling design: the first is built to serve as a home once it is connected to utilities, and the vacation vehicle is built for occasional trips.
The definition has a second route for smaller units. It reaches any structure that meets every requirement except the size requirements, provided the manufacturer voluntarily files the certification required by the United States Secretary of Housing and Urban Development and complies with the standards established under Title 42 of the United States Code.36
Manufactured homes, like fixtures, cut across the principal classes and do not compete with them.37 A home on a dealer's lot waiting for a buyer is inventory, because the dealer holds it for sale.38 The same home bought by a family to live in is consumer goods, because it is bought for use primarily for personal, family, or household purposes.39 Size and cost do not alter that result, since the consumer goods test looks to use and mobile homes remain consumer goods when they are bought for personal use.40 A home that a business holds neither for sale nor for personal use falls to the residual class, equipment.
Article 9 also gives the term a transaction type of its own: it defines a “manufactured-home transaction” as a kind of secured transaction.41 The rules attached to that transaction type belong to a later reading.
The usual exam error is to decide by appearance, treating any trailer or movable unit as a manufactured home without checking for dwelling design, or assuming that a structure people live in can never be goods.
As-Extracted Collateral
Section 9-102(a)(6) defines as-extracted collateral in two forms.43 The first is oil, gas, or other minerals subject to a security interest that is created by a debtor having an interest in the minerals before extraction44 and that attaches to the minerals as extracted.45 The second is an account arising out of the sale at the wellhead or minehead of oil, gas, or other minerals in which the debtor had an interest before extraction.46 Of the four subcategories, this is the one built around timing, because it asks when the debtor's interest arose and when the lender's interest attaches.
The definition makes sense only against what the definition of goods leaves out. Goods do not include oil, gas, or other minerals before extraction.47 Minerals still in the ground therefore fall outside the definition of goods, and Article 9 generally leaves the creation or transfer of interests in real property to real estate law.48 On extraction, however, the minerals become goods and can be collateral under the Article.49 Extraction is the hinge: the event that turns oil or coal from something in the ground into goods is the same event at which a security interest granted earlier attaches and so becomes an interest in as-extracted collateral.
The category answers a timing problem. While the minerals lie in place they are not goods, and a claim on them in that state is a matter of real property law. The as-extracted definition nevertheless reaches an interest that was created before extraction and attaches as the minerals come out of the ground.
Each condition in the first form does its own work. The first ties the collateral to a debtor who held an interest in the minerals while they lay in place, and attachment in any event requires that the debtor have rights in the collateral.50 A debtor that first acquires oil after it has been pumped held no such interest, so the first condition fails. The second condition fixes the moment of attachment at extraction. Before then no goods exist for an Article 9 interest to attach to, so the interest reaches the minerals exactly when they become goods.
The paradigm case is a debtor who owns oil still underground and grants a security interest meant to attach to the oil as it is pumped. Both conditions are met, and the oil is as-extracted collateral.51 A producer in a different position shows where the label stops.
The lender in that scene holds an interest in goods held for sale, and the rules for inventory apply to it.52 The only fact separating Quarry from the debtor with oil still underground is where the oil lay when the interest was created. The identical crude, in the same field, belongs to a different category depending on that single fact.
The second form of the definition follows the minerals through their first sale. A producer that sells oil or gas at the wellhead, or coal at the minehead, delivers the minerals and is left with a right to be paid. That right is an account, and it qualifies as as-extracted collateral when the debtor had an interest in the minerals before extraction.53 Accounts are excluded from goods, so only the first form is a subcategory of goods, and the second is a claim to payment that carries the label because of its origin.54 The definition names the place of the sale, so the account must arise from a sale made at the wellhead or minehead itself.
Two instincts go wrong on this topic. One treats every barrel of oil as goods and so skips the as-extracted category altogether, and the other treats minerals as real property at every stage. The statute answers both by tying the classification to extraction: the question is where the minerals were, and whether the debtor then had an interest in them, when the security interest was created. Oil in the ground that is pledged to attach as it is pumped is as-extracted collateral, and oil already in a tank is ordinary goods.