Concept
Special Collateral Rules
Including sufficiency of description (§ 9-108)
Special Collateral Rules
The type method is the drafter’s easiest tool, and § 9-108(e) takes it away for certain assets. Elsewhere in the section, a single word such as inventory or equipment borrows its definition from Article 9 and identifies a whole class of property with no schedule. Subsection (e) lists the kinds of collateral for which a description only by a Code-defined type is insufficient,1 and for those assets the description must say more.
The special rules sit inside the general standard of § 9-108(a), under which a description of personal or real property is sufficient, whether or not it is specific, if it reasonably identifies what is described, except as subsections (c), (d), and (e) provide otherwise.2 Subsection (c) denies sufficiency to phrases such as “all the debtor’s assets” or “all the debtor’s personal property.”3 Subsection (d) supplies safe-harbor wording for investment accounts, which widens what a drafter may write for that asset. Subsection (e) names the assets for which type alone fails, which narrows what a drafter may write for them.
A failed description costs the lender its security interest in whatever the words missed. Attachment requires that the debtor agree to grant the security interest, that value be given, and that the debtor have rights in the collateral.4 Absent an exception, it also requires a record of the security agreement that the debtor has authenticated,5 and the description is the part of that record that points to particular property.
The usual mistake is to see a type word and apply the type method without first asking whether the asset appears on subsection (e)’s list. Ask that question first. The sections below cover investment property, where the Code supplies wording that works; commercial tort claims; and consumer transactions.
Investment Property
Section 9-108(d) gives a debtor three ways to describe collateral held through a financial intermediary. A description of a security entitlement, securities account, or commodity account is sufficient if it describes the collateral by those terms or as investment property, or describes the underlying financial asset or commodity contract.6 Because subsection (d) begins “except as otherwise provided in subsection (e),” it operates as a safe harbor for nonconsumer transactions.
Three routes exist because of how investment assets are held. An investor who owns shares through a brokerage usually has no certificate in a drawer. The shares are credited to a securities account on the brokerage’s books, and what the investor holds, in a precise sense, is a security entitlement: a bundle of rights against the brokerage in whatever the account contains. A commodity account does the same work for commodity contracts. A security agreement can identify that property by the label for the account or entitlement, by the umbrella phrase investment property, or by naming the shares or contracts underneath. Each route lets an outsider consult the brokerage’s records and see what is covered, which is the job every description exists to do.
The standard illustration puts two of the routes on one set of facts. A debtor holds 30 shares of XYZ Corp. in an account with a brokerage, and in a nonconsumer transaction the debtor authenticates a security agreement granting the lender an interest in all of the debtor’s “investment property.” That description is sufficient, because it uses the umbrella term the safe harbor approves. A grant of the debtor’s “rights in shares of XYZ Corp.” is equally sufficient, because it describes the underlying asset instead of the account. Neither description names the brokerage or gives an account number. The two grants differ in reach: the umbrella phrase covers whatever the debtor holds in such accounts, and the XYZ description covers those shares and no more.
The exam variation changes the debtor. When an individual pledges a brokerage account for personal purposes, subsection (d) gives way to subsection (e)(2), which makes a description by type alone of a security entitlement, securities account, or commodity account insufficient in a consumer transaction.7 A bare grant of “investment property” describes the collateral by type alone, so it does not suffice there.
Only the character of the transaction changed, and it changed the answer. Subsection (d) is the nonconsumer safe harbor; subsection (e)(2) is the consumer limit on it, and the consumer section below shows what more a description must say when that limit applies.
Subsection (d) does not revive the phrases that subsection (c) condemns. The descriptions it approves are the account’s own terms, the phrase investment property, and the underlying asset or contract. “All the debtor’s assets” is none of them, so a lender who relies on it has not described the brokerage account, even in a nonconsumer deal.8 A lender who wants the account can name it by an approved description, and a lender who wants the whole portfolio can say investment property.
Commercial Tort Claims
A commercial tort claim heads the list in § 9-108(e): a description only by that type is insufficient.10 The consumer-transaction qualifier attaches only to the second item on the list, which covers consumer goods, security entitlements, securities accounts, and commodity accounts.11 The first item carries no such qualifier, so the limit on commercial tort claims applies in every transaction, commercial or consumer.
The description must identify the claim specifically.12 The model description is short: “the right that the debtor has against X flowing from an action based on interference with debtor’s contractual rights.” It names the adverse party and the kind of wrong, and it recites no facts, no amount, and no court. A bare grant of the debtor’s “commercial tort claims” fails because it names only the type.
The reason shows in a comparison with the classes taught earlier. A word such as inventory names a recurring class, and a reader can hold the Article 9 definition against any item the debtor owns and sort it in or out. A commercial tort claim is a single right to recover for one wrong by one wrongdoer. The label says the debtor holds some right to sue but not which one, so an outsider cannot tell which claim the parties had in mind. Naming the wrong and the party ties the grant to a claim someone can point to.
The sophistication of the parties does not matter, because subsection (e)(1) differs from the rules around it. In a nonconsumer transaction, subsection (d) lets commercial parties describe a securities account by its type or as investment property, and the consumer limit in subsection (e)(2) bites only on consumer deals. Subsection (e)(1) has no such exception, so it binds the banks and corporations that would otherwise draft by type word. The detours fail. An all-assets phrase falls to subsection (c),13 and listing the debtor’s other collateral types by name does not rescue a commercial tort claim added to the list, because that item must be described specifically even when the rest of the debtor’s property is covered by type names.14
Exam answers go wrong in two directions: they assume that sophisticated parties escape the limit, and they demand a detailed account of the claim when a few identifying words suffice.
Consumer Transactions
The second limit in § 9-108(e) applies only in a consumer transaction, where a description only by type of consumer goods, a security entitlement, a securities account, or a commodity account is insufficient.16 The commercial tort claim limit applies in every transaction; this one turns on the character of the deal. It also overrides the general standard, because § 9-108(a) yields to subsection (e), so the reasonable-identification test cannot rescue a bare type word.17
The type word is the problem. A word such as inventory points to a class that a business and its lender can match against stock and records. The words consumer goods, standing alone in an individual’s agreement, reach everything kept for personal, family, or household use, from furniture to jewelry, and the words securities account say only that the debtor has some account somewhere. The Code asks the lender to add something that points to particular property.
The added words can name an institution or an item. For an account, the description would use terms beyond “security entitlement,” such as “the securities in my account at Merrill Lynch.” For consumer goods, the goods presumably must be identified, as in “my 5-carat diamond ring.”18
Whether the rule applies depends on whether the deal is a consumer transaction at all, and an individual debtor is not enough to make it one. Article 9 defines a consumer transaction by two features: the debt must be incurred for personal, family, or household purposes, and the collateral must be held for those purposes. If either feature is missing, subsection (e)(2) does not bar a type description. An individual who borrows to fund a business and grants the lender an interest in all of the borrower’s “consumer goods” has therefore described the collateral sufficiently, because the loan is a business loan and the transaction is not a consumer transaction.
re Cunningham shows the limit at work in retail credit. Capital One asserted a security interest in the debtors’ consumer goods, and the debtors answered that the description referred only to the type of collateral, which does not suffice for consumer goods.19 The creditor could not repair the gap with evidence from outside the agreement. The opinion points to the purposes of the formal requirements for creating a security interest, which include minimizing future disputes over the terms of the agreement and over what property stands as collateral, and it treats the signed-writing requirement as in the nature of a statute of frauds. Letting the creditor adduce parol evidence to alter the agreement’s unambiguous language would undercut those purposes.20 Whether separate records can be read together as a single agreement is a question for the later section on incorporated and composite documents.
A reliable check has three steps. Ask first whether the asset is on subsection (e)’s list. Ask next, if the transaction is a consumer one, whether the description adds anything beyond type. Remember last that a sufficient description is only one attachment requirement: the debtor must also agree to grant the interest, value must be given, and the debtor must have rights in the collateral.21 Read every consumer-goods description skeptically, because a generic description of consumer goods is invalid.22
Side by side, the three rules sort by asset and by kind of transaction:
| Collateral | Nonconsumer transaction | Consumer transaction |
|---|---|---|
| Securities account, security entitlement, commodity account | Sufficient if described by those terms, as investment property, or by the underlying asset or contract | Type alone insufficient; add identifying information such as the institution |
| Consumer goods | Type description not barred by § 9-108(e)(2) | Type alone insufficient; identify the goods |
| Commercial tort claim | Type alone insufficient; identify the claim | Type alone insufficient; identify the claim |