Concept
Why Article 9 Reaches Article 2
Including security interests arising under Article 2 (§ 9-110)
Article 2 Security Interests Under Article 9
Why Article 9 Reaches Article 2
Article 9 governs secured lending, yet it also claims security interests that the law of sales and leases creates. Section 9-109(a) makes the claim in two places, and the difference between them explains the sections that follow.
The first claim is the broad one. Paragraph (1) covers “a transaction, regardless of its form, that creates a security interest in personal property or fixtures by contract.”1 The words “regardless of its form” direct the inquiry to what an arrangement does rather than what the parties call it. If Article 9 otherwise applies, casting the arrangement as a lease or some pre-Code device does not take it outside the Article.2
The second claim is narrower and turns on source. Paragraph (5) reaches “a security interest arising under Section 2-401, 2-505, 2-711(3), or 2A-508(5), as provided in Section 9-110.”3 Each cross-reference points into Article 2 (sales) or Article 2A (leases), and each identifies a security interest that one of those articles produces. Section 2-401 supplies the familiar example: a seller who sells on credit and reserves title holds only a security interest. Paragraph (1) describes an interest created by the debtor’s contract. Paragraph (5) names interests by the Article 2 or 2A provision under which they arise, and that difference is why the scope section gives them a paragraph of their own. The closing phrase, “as provided in Section 9-110,” warns you that the coverage comes with conditions.
Paragraph (6) does similar work for “a security interest arising under Section 4-210 or 5-118,” which brings in interests arising under Articles 4 and 5.4 Keep that group apart in your analysis, because the modifications in § 9-110 are written for the four Article 2 and 2A interests alone.5
Section 9-110 opens by declaring that a security interest arising under those four sections “is subject to this article.” Full Article 9 is therefore the default. The section then adds modifications that last only until the debtor obtains possession of the goods, and the sections below take them one at a time.6
Being subject to Article 9 does not displace Article 2 altogether. Article 2’s warranty provisions still govern disputes about the quality of goods sold subject to a security interest, while Article 9 controls the validity, perfection, and foreclosure of that interest. The line also runs the other way: when a transaction in goods takes the form of a contract to sell or a present sale but is intended to operate only as a secured transaction, § 2-102 says Article 2 “does not apply.”7
Do not stretch the list in paragraph (5). A seller’s right to reclaim goods under § 2-702(3) is, by its own terms, “subject to the rights of a buyer in ordinary course or other good faith purchaser,” and under the stoppage provision, § 2-705, the buyer by hypothesis has never had possession. Neither section appears in paragraph (5), and the discussion of the limits of § 9-110 returns to both.8
An exam question on scope will often set two creditors side by side and ask which one the § 9-110 rules govern. In the first, a seller delivers goods on credit under a contract that keeps title in the seller until the price is paid. Section 2-401 reduces that reservation to a security interest, paragraph (5) brings the interest into Article 9, and § 9-110 governs it.9 In the second, a collecting bank has credited a customer’s account for a deposited check and holds the check for collection. Its interest arises under Article 4 and enters Article 9 through paragraph (6), so Article 9 governs it, but § 9-110 does not.10