Concept
Four Article 2 Sources
Including security interests arising under Article 2 (§ 9-110)
Four Article 2 Sources
Article 9 ordinarily governs interests that parties create by contract to secure payment or performance of an obligation.1 Section 9-109(a)(5) adds four interests that come from other provisions of the Code instead: those arising under Section 2-401, 2-505, 2-711(3), or 2A-508(5), as provided in Section 9-110.2 Three of these sections sit in Article 2, the sales article, and one in Article 2A, the lease article. Article 9 governs what each of them produces.
The list is closed, so recognize each interest by its section and its trigger. A right that merely resembles one of the four does not enter Article 9 through this door. A seller's rights to stop goods in transit under § 2-705 or to reclaim them under § 2-702(3) arise under sections the list omits, and the later discussion of § 9-110's limits returns to those rights.3
The four fall into two pairs. Sections 2-401 and 2-505 protect a seller that has delivered or shipped goods and has not yet been paid. Sections 2-711(3) and 2A-508(5) protect a buyer or lessee that has refused goods and still holds them.4 In each pair the transaction leaves one party exposed, and the section gives that party a security interest in the goods themselves.
Three questions organize the analysis of each source. Who is the secured party? Who is the debtor? What obligation does the interest secure? The answers reverse between the pairs, so fix the parties before anything else, especially when a fact pattern runs two of these interests together. Section 9-110 then attaches relaxed rules to all four: the interest is enforceable even if § 9-203(b)(3) has not been satisfied, and filing is not required to perfect it.5 Those rules last only until the debtor obtains possession of the goods, so the debtor's identity also fixes when they stop. Later sections develop the relaxed rules; here they appear only as each source requires.
Retention of Title
A seller that delivers goods on credit and reserves title until the price is paid gets less than its clause promises. Section 2-401 limits the effect of any retention or reservation of title in goods shipped or delivered to the buyer to a reservation of a security interest.6 That security interest secures the price, and Article 9 governs it.7
Put the three questions to the arrangement. The seller is the secured party, the buyer is the debtor, and the unpaid price is the obligation secured. A sale in which the seller expressly keeps title until the buyer pays is, in other words, a secured transaction within Article 9, and the seller holds a security interest in the goods for the price.8 Before the Code, such a sale was often called a conditional sale.9 The Code's label controls, and the parties' label does not.
The word title invites a wrong inference on exams. Read it in a fact pattern as a signal that § 2-401 is in play and that the unpaid price is the secured obligation. Do not read it as proof that the seller still owns the goods, because the section exists to deny the clause that effect.
Shipment Under Reservation
A seller can also acquire a security interest through the way it ships. Section 2-505 gives a seller that ships goods under reservation a security interest in them, and § 9-109(a)(5) brings that interest into Article 9.11 Article 2 decides whether a given shipment qualifies as one under reservation, and Article 9 governs the interest once it does.
The three questions resolve as they did for retention of title. The seller is the secured party, the buyer is the debtor, and the price is the obligation secured. What differs is the seller's act. Under § 2-401 the seller delivers the goods and writes a title clause into the contract. Under § 2-505 the seller keeps its hold on the goods through the manner of shipment.
This interest also shows the relaxed rules at work. Until the buyer obtains possession, the seller's interest is enforceable even if § 9-203(b)(3), the ordinary security-agreement requirement, has not been satisfied,12 and filing is not required to perfect it.13 While the goods are out of the buyer's hands, the seller needs no signed agreement from the buyer and no financing statement.
Two errors lose points on this source. Treating every shipment on credit as a shipment under reservation ignores that the shipment must actually qualify under § 2-505. Merging this interest into § 2-401 blurs two separate triggers: a title clause in a sale of delivered goods, and the manner of shipment.
Buyer's Interest in Rejected Goods
The third source, § 2-711(3), reverses the roles, and Article 9 governs the interest it creates through § 9-109(a)(5).15 It is the sales counterpart of the lessee's interest in the next subsection, which states the pattern: a party that has rightfully and effectively rejected goods, or justifiably revoked acceptance of them, and that holds the goods has a security interest in them to secure what the other side owes as a result.16 The buyer's version secures the price the buyer has already paid and its expenses of transportation, care, and custody. Rejection is the buyer's refusal to keep goods the seller tendered, and revocation of acceptance is the buyer's withdrawal of an acceptance already given. Either way the buyer holds goods it does not want while the seller owes it money.
The three questions come out differently here. The buyer is the secured party, the seller is the debtor, and the seller's duty to refund and reimburse is the obligation secured. The reversal follows from who holds the goods: the buyer has them, and the seller owes the money. The interest ties the buyer's claim to goods already in its hands, so the buyer does not depend on the seller's general creditworthiness.
The interest has two conditions. The first is a proper rejection or revocation. Whether the buyer's rejection was rightful and effective, or its revocation justified, is an Article 2 question, and this chapter treats the answer as a premise. The second is that the buyer has possession or control of the goods, which is why the debtor in this setting is a seller that does not hold them.17
A fact pattern can borrow the vocabulary of rejection without supplying the substance. The usual error is to treat any buyer holding goods it wants to return as a secured party.
The seller's lack of possession also explains how § 9-110 applies. Until the seller obtains possession of the goods, the buyer's interest is enforceable even if § 9-203(b)(3) has not been satisfied,18 and filing is not required to perfect it.19 The buyer needs no signed security agreement from the seller and no financing statement. If the seller regains possession, the relaxations end.
When a problem describes a prepaid buyer and nonconforming goods, ask who holds the goods and who owes the money. The holder that is owed a refund is the secured party, and the party that owes the refund is the debtor. Then check whether the facts show a rightful and effective rejection or a justifiable revocation, because without one the interest never arises.
Lessee's Interest in Rejected Goods
The fourth source, § 2A-508(5), gives a lessee the protection that § 2-711(3) gives a buyer, and § 9-109(a)(5) brings the interest into Article 9.21 A lessee that has rightfully and effectively rejected goods, or justifiably and effectively revoked acceptance of goods, delivered under a lease contract governed by Article 2A has a security interest in those goods in its possession or control. The interest secures the debt the lessor will owe for rent already paid, for security deposits made, and for expenses of transportation, care, and custody of the goods.22 This is the one circumstance in which a lessee's possession of leased goods carries a security interest of this kind.23
The three questions resolve as they did for rejected goods in a sale. The lessee is the secured party, the lessor is the debtor, and the lessor's debt for rent, deposits, and custody expenses is the obligation secured. Rent and deposits stand where the prepaid price stood in the sale. The interest ties the lessee's refund to goods already in its hands, and the coverage of care and custody expenses reimburses the lessee for guarding property it never wanted.
The interest depends on its trigger. A lessee that accepted conforming goods and never rejected them or justifiably revoked acceptance holds no interest under § 2A-508(5), however much it wants to end the lease and recover its payments. Whether a rejection was rightful and effective, or a revocation justified, is an Article 2A question, and this chapter treats the answer as a premise. The lessee must also have possession or control of the goods.24
The lessor's lack of possession again triggers § 9-110. Until the lessor obtains possession, the lessee's interest is enforceable even if § 9-203(b)(3) has not been satisfied,25 and filing is not required to perfect it.26 Once the lessor regains possession, the ordinary Article 9 rules govern.
Set the four sources side by side. In the first two, the seller holds the interest and the buyer is the debtor. In the last two, the buyer or lessee holds the interest and the seller or lessor is the debtor. The next section collects the relaxed rules that § 9-110 attaches to all four.