Concept
Limits of Section 9-110
Including security interests arising under Article 2 (§ 9-110)
Limits of Section 9-110
Section 9-110 relaxes Article 9 for four Article 2 and 2A interests and for no others: a security interest arising under Section 2-401, 2-505, 2-711(3), or 2A-508(5).1 Article 2 creates three of these by operation of law when the buyer does not yet have the goods: the seller who retains title, the seller who ships under reservation, and the buyer who holds rejected goods.2 Each of the four gets the same four relaxed rules. The interest is enforceable even if § 9-203(b)(3) has not been satisfied, filing is not required to perfect it, Article 2 or 2A governs the holder's rights after default, and the interest has priority over a conflicting security interest created by the debtor.3
The list is closed, and the closure matters because Article 2 gives an unpaid seller three other powers over goods that feel like security:
- the right to withhold delivery (§§ 2-702(1), 2-703(a), 2A-525);
- the right to stop goods in transit (§§ 2-705, 2A-526); and
- the right to reclaim goods the buyer has already received (§§ 2-507(2), 2-702(2)).4
A student who sees leverage over goods is tempted to call each of these a security interest and reach for § 9-110. The temptation should be resisted. A seller that retains title or ships under reservation holds an interest that Article 9 governs. A seller that tells the carrier to hold the truck holds only a right to stop delivery, and that right is not on the list.
The contest that matters pits one of these seller rights against the buyer's lender. Comment 5 to § 9-110 says that Article 9 does not specifically address the conflict between a security interest created by a buyer or lessee and the seller's rights to withhold, stop, or reclaim. It assigns the conflict to the first sentence of § 2-403(1), under which the buyer's secured party obtains no greater rights in the goods than the buyer had or had power to convey, or to § 2A-307(1), under which creditors of a lessee take subject to the lease contract.5 The 1999 Code gives no clear answer to this priority problem, and the Comment appears to reject case law that had given Article 9 secured parties priority over the unpaid seller's claim to the goods.6 Withholding and stopping follow the Comment closely. Reclamation needs a correction.
Withholding and Stopping Delivery
A seller that refuses to ship to an insolvent buyer, or tells a carrier to hold goods already in transit, holds nothing on § 9-110's list. One court quoted the four rules of § 9-110, observed that the seller's right to stop delivery is not covered by that section, and turned to Comment 5 for the rule that does govern.7 In both situations the buyer's lender demands goods that the seller has not yet released.
The first sentence of § 2-403(1) supplies the answer: the buyer's secured party obtains no greater rights in the goods than the buyer had or had power to convey.8 The Coogan treatise, quoted in the opinion, translates the Comment this way. The buyer's secured creditor is a purchaser, but it gains a security interest only in the interest of the buyer. The buyer is not without rights; it has insufficient rights to give a security interest that will defeat the seller's right to withhold or stop the goods. The secured creditor steps into the buyer's shoes.9 A commentator agrees that the Comment's closing sentence is accurate for stoppage under § 2-705, because there the buyer would never have had possession of the goods.10
Article 9's priority rules cannot decide this contest, because the seller is not a party to the contest those rules govern. They rank one security interest against another, and a seller that merely refuses to ship holds none of the four interests the list names.11 The bank's earlier filing therefore has no seller's security interest to outrank. The only question is how much the buyer could have conveyed.
The cash payment is the bank's way out. Where the seller refuses delivery because of the buyer's insolvency, the secured creditor can terminate the seller's right to withhold by making a cash payment for the goods, just as the buyer may.12 The bank therefore chooses between funding the payment, which brings the goods into its collateral, and leaving the seller's right undisturbed.
A seller that kept an interest under § 2-401 or § 2-505 stands in a different position. Its interest is enforceable even if § 9-203(b)(3) has not been satisfied,13 it needs no filing to perfect,14 and it has priority over a conflicting security interest created by the debtor.15 That seller's contest with the buyer's bank is a contest between two security interests, and § 9-110(4) resolves it, within the possession cutoff discussed above.
When an exam stem combines an insolvent buyer, a bank with an earlier filing, and an unpaid seller, determine first what the seller actually holds. If the seller holds a security interest under § 2-401 or § 2-505, the answer runs through § 9-110. If the seller holds only a right to withhold or stop delivery, Article 9 stays out of the contest, § 2-403(1) controls, and the bank gets the goods only by paying cash.
Reclamation Rights
Reclamation is the seller's right to take back goods the buyer has already received, and §§ 2-507(2) and 2-702(2) supply it. Neither section appears among the four interests that § 9-110 reaches, so a reclaiming seller holds no security interest that Article 9 governs.17 Comment 5 nonetheless lists the right to reclaim with withholding and stopping and sends the conflict with the buyer's lender to § 2-403(1).18 For reclamation under § 2-702 that default does not hold. A commentator reads the Comment's closing sentence, that the buyer's secured creditor would likewise be subject to the seller's stoppage or reclamation rights, as accurate for § 2-705 and probably for § 2-507, but plainly wrong for § 2-702(3).19
The background rule explains why. An unsecured seller of goods on credit is generally no better than a general creditor, even as to the very goods it sold. Section 2-702 is the exception: it authorizes the seller to refuse to deliver on the buyer's insolvency, and in certain cases it lets the seller recover the goods if demand is made within 10 days after the buyer receives them, or over a longer period if the buyer has misrepresented its solvency in writing. The theory is that this seller is more deserving than a conventional creditor, because a buyer who takes goods on credit while insolvent has committed fraud.20
The remedy has a limit that decides most exam problems. Section 2-702(3) subordinates the seller to the rights of bona fide purchasers, a group that includes a secured creditor claiming under its after-acquired-property clause, and courts have recognized the secured creditor as a good-faith purchaser entitled to that protection.21 The same section generally gives the seller superiority over intervening lien creditors of the buyer.22
The standard case shows the result. A seller ships goods to an insolvent buyer that has already granted a perfected security interest to a bank, and the bank's after-acquired-property clause attaches to the goods on delivery. The seller's attempt to reclaim loses, because the bank is a good-faith purchaser under § 2-702(3).23 The bank wins under an Article 2 rule, and Article 9's priority rules play no part in the outcome.
Two wrong routes to that answer start from Article 9. The first says the bank filed earlier and so wins under first-to-file priority. That rule ranks one security interest against another, and the reclaiming seller holds none within the four that § 9-110 reaches.24 The second says the seller prevails under § 9-110(4), which ranks certain Article 2 interests ahead of the debtor's lenders. That paragraph covers a seller that retains title or ships under reservation, not one that reclaims under § 2-702.25 Reclamation also concerns goods the buyer has already received, which is why the demand period runs from the buyer's receipt.26
The two claimants in the bank and judgment-creditor examples are the poles of this subsection. Section 2-702(3) protects purchasers, and the only fact separating the bank from the lien creditor is whether the claimant took its interest in a voluntary transaction for value.27
Bankruptcy adds a deadline of its own. A seller may reclaim goods given to an insolvent buyer within 45 days of the bankruptcy filing, by written demand made within 45 days after the debtor received them; if that period expires after the filing, the deadline cannot extend beyond 20 days after the filing.28 Courts have also disagreed about the consequences when bankruptcy keeps the secured creditor from seizing the collateral.29 The seller's rights against the buyer's trustee in bankruptcy are treated in Chapter 8, § 10.30
When an exam stem pairs an unpaid seller who demands goods back with a lender of the insolvent buyer, ask what each claimant holds. The reclaiming seller holds a reclamation right, not a security interest within the four. A lender whose security interest attached to the goods is a good-faith purchaser and defeats the seller under Article 2, while an intervening lien creditor loses to the seller.