Concept
Why Purchase-Money Status Matters
Is the consignor's interest a purchase-money security interest?
Consignor's Purchase-Money Status
Why Purchase-Money Status Matters
Whether a security interest is purchase-money can decide who holds the first claim on a piece of collateral. Among secured parties, priority usually goes to the first to file or perfect. A purchase-money security interest is the standard exception: it usually beats a regular security interest regardless of that rule, so long as the requirements of timely filing and notice are met.1 The issue often arises when the debtor has granted a security interest in present and after-acquired property and then buys new inventory, with the seller taking a purchase-money interest in it. The earlier creditor filed first, yet the purchase-money interest still wins in the new property.2
A short contest shows how much turns on the label. Old Bank holds a security interest in all of X's equipment, present and after-acquired, and filed first. On March 1, X acquires a new machine, New Bank advances new value against it, and both banks are perfected in the machine that day. If New Bank's advance created a purchase-money security interest, New Bank can prevail in the machine by satisfying the timely filing and notice requirements, despite Old Bank's earlier filing.3 If the advance created no purchase-money interest, Old Bank has priority by virtue of its earlier filing, even though both banks perfected simultaneously on March 1.4 New Bank advanced the same dollars in both versions. Only the classification of the advance changes the result.
Section 9-103 draws that classification. A purchase-money obligation is an obligation incurred as all or part of the price of the collateral, or for value given to enable the debtor to acquire rights in or the use of the collateral, if the value is in fact so used.5 Purchase-money collateral is the goods or software that secure a purchase-money obligation incurred with respect to that collateral.6 The words if the value is in fact so used tie the lender's status to what happened to the money. Value that never went toward acquiring or using the collateral does not satisfy the second prong of the definition.
Status is also a matter of degree. A security interest in goods is purchase-money only to the extent the goods are purchase-money collateral with respect to that interest.7 One interest can therefore qualify in part and fail in part.
Inventory carries the most conditions. A purchase-money security interest has priority over a conflicting security interest in the same inventory if three things are true: (i) the purchase-money interest is perfected when the debtor receives possession of the inventory; (ii) the purchase-money secured party has sent an authenticated notice to the holder of the conflicting interest; and (iii) that holder has received the notice within five years before the debtor receives possession.8 Consignments feed directly into this rule, because the consignor's security interest in the consigned goods is deemed to be a purchase-money security interest in inventory.9 A consignor's problem therefore has two halves: whether the interest is purchase-money, and how much of it is.
Perfection timing also decides contests with lien creditors. Section 9-317 subordinates an unperfected secured creditor to a lien creditor and, by negative implication, a perfected secured creditor beats a lien creditor.16 Under § 9-317(a)(2), a security interest is subordinate to one who becomes a lien creditor before the earlier of two events. The first is perfection. The second is the point at which the § 9-203(b)(3) conditions are met (usually a signed security agreement) and a financing statement covering the collateral is filed.17
The third question depends on the first two. A purchase-money claim presupposes a valid security interest in goods or software, so attachment and collateral type are checked before anyone examines the link between the credit and the collateral.
The rest of this chapter builds the answer in the order a problem demands. It starts with the three building blocks of the general definition: the obligation, the collateral that secures it, and the security interest in goods. It then turns to what makes a transaction a consignment under Article 9 and to the consignor deeming rule, including its limit to the extent of purchase-money collateral. Inventory cross-collateralization and software come next, followed by the burden of establishing extent, dual status after mixed debt, the allocation of payments, and consumer-goods transactions. The chapter closes with how a secured party keeps purchase-money status.