Concept
The Consignor Deeming Rule
Is the consignor's interest a purchase-money security interest?
The Consignor Deeming Rule
Section 9-103(d) gives the consignor a status that other creditors must earn: the security interest of a consignor in goods that are the subject of a consignment is a purchase-money security interest in inventory.1 The statute deems the status instead of asking for proof. An ordinary creditor must show an obligation incurred as all or part of the price of the collateral, or value given to enable the debtor to acquire rights in or the use of the collateral and in fact so used.2 A consignor whose deal clears the consignment gate described in the previous section skips that showing. It need not prove that it advanced cash, that the consignee owes a price, or that any money was traced into the goods.
The Code needs a deeming rule because a consignment fits the ordinary definition badly. In a typical consignment, an owner puts goods in a consignee's hands to sell to third parties, takes back what does not sell, and receives the sale price less the consignee's percentage. No money is lent at delivery, and no price is owed for goods that may come back. Yet the consignor looks like an inventory lender: its goods let the consignee stock a sales floor and make sales it could not otherwise make, and the risk of no sale falls on the consignor, not the consignee.3 Article 9 accordingly treats every consignment that its definition does not exclude as a security interest, so the consignor must perfect like any other secured party.4 An unperfected one is subordinate to a lien creditor who levies first.5 Nor does the consignee's lack of full ownership block attachment, because a debtor's limited rights in collateral, short of ownership, are enough for a security interest to attach.6
An ordinary supplier cannot use this shortcut. A court explaining the purchase-money definition has said that it "requires a close nexus between the acquisition of collateral and the secured obligation," so an interest is not purchase-money when the debtor acquires property on unsecured credit and later creates the security interest to secure the price.7
The label inventory follows from what the consignee does with the goods. A consignee receives goods to sell, so it holds them for sale, and goods held for sale are inventory in its hands, which brings the inventory priority rules to bear on the consignor.8 Classification depends on who holds the goods and why: the same television is inventory in an appliance store, equipment in a dentist's office, and a consumer good in the dentist's home.9
Inventory has its own priority track, and the consignor must run it. A purchase-money interest in inventory outranks a conflicting interest in the same inventory only if three conditions are met: the purchase-money interest is perfected when the debtor receives possession, the purchase-money secured party has sent an authenticated notice to the holder of the conflicting interest, and that holder has received the notice within five years before the debtor receives possession.10 Other goods get more room, since a perfected purchase-money interest in noninventory goods has priority if it is perfected when the debtor receives possession or within 20 days afterward.11 The inventory rule names no such grace period. For a consignor, the conditions take concrete form: it must file before the consignee receives possession and must give written notification to any other secured party who has filed. The notice must say that the consignor expects to deliver goods on consignment to the consignee and describe the goods by item or type, and it must be given within five years before the consignee receives the goods.12
Status and priority are separate questions, and the deeming rule answers only the first. On May 1, S takes a security interest in all of Debtor's present and after-acquired inventory and files that day. On June 1, C agrees to consign goods to Debtor and files a financing statement. C delivers the goods on June 5. If C gave S the required notice before delivery, C's security interest has priority over S, even though S filed first.13 A consignor that filed but never notified S has not met the notice condition on which inventory purchase-money priority depends,14 so its deemed status does not carry it past S.
To the Extent of Purchase-Money Collateral
Section 9-103(b)(1) turns the two definitions into a working test for goods: a security interest in goods is a purchase-money security interest to the extent that the goods are purchase-money collateral with respect to that interest.16 The definitions supply the content. Goods or software are purchase-money collateral when they secure a purchase-money obligation incurred with respect to that collateral,17 and an obligation is purchase-money when it was incurred as all or part of the price, or for value given to enable the debtor to acquire rights in or the use of the collateral, if the value is in fact so used.18 A seller that delivers goods on credit fits this test, and so does a lender whose advance pays the seller. The phrase to the extent converts a label into a measurement, so the question on an exam is how much of the secured debt qualifies. The answer is usually a dollar figure.
A single security agreement can therefore hold a purchase-money piece and a piece that is not, and a court sorts the secured dollars into the two groups instead of stamping one label on the whole agreement. The definition reaches all or part of the price, so a down payment does not reduce the seller's status in what it did finance.
The arithmetic turns on one idea: purchase-money status follows value that bought the asset. The Code requires that the value given actually be used by the debtor to acquire rights in the goods,19 and the payroll loan bought nothing. The status of the first debt does not spread to the second, and the words to the extent rule out both all-or-nothing answers. The whole $20,000 is not purchase-money, and the interest does not lose its status entirely because it also secures an unrelated debt.
The split carries into priority. Because the machine is not inventory, the $15,000 portion can take purchase-money priority over an earlier lender's after-acquired property claim if the seller perfected when the manufacturer received the machine or within 20 days afterward.20 The $5,000 portion earns no purchase-money preference. Against a lien creditor, the question for both portions is perfection: an unperfected interest is subordinate to a lien creditor who levies first, and a perfected one generally prevails.21 Later readings on this page take up dual status after mixed debt and the rules for allocating payments between the two portions.
The usual exam error is to answer for the whole security agreement, either by declaring a purchase-money interest in the machine and stopping, or by declaring that the payroll loan destroys purchase-money status and stopping. The answer that earns the points names the purchase-money dollars, names the rest, and gives each its own priority treatment. A caption such as Purchase-Money Loan on the agreement changes nothing, because status follows what the credit actually paid for.
Inventory Cross-Collateralization
Section 9-103(b)(2) gives inventory a second route to purchase-money status, one the general rule does not supply. If the security interest is in inventory that is or was purchase-money collateral, it is also a purchase-money security interest to the extent that it secures a purchase-money obligation incurred with respect to other inventory in which the secured party holds or held a purchase-money security interest.23 In plainer terms, the interest is in inventory and secures value given to enable the debtor to acquire other items of inventory in which the secured party also has a purchase-money security interest.24
The extension is needed because subsection (b)(1) ties each item of goods to the debt incurred for that item. An item is purchase-money collateral only for an obligation incurred with respect to it.25 The trouble starts with a cross-collateral clause, a term under which every item of collateral secures not only its own price but the prices of the other items too. Inventory is bought and sold continually, and payments from sales are applied to particular loans, so an item's own price can be paid off while the item still stands behind the prices of its neighbors.
The two conditions in (b)(2) do different work. The words is or was require that the item itself have been financed with purchase-money credit, so a secured party cannot sweep in goods it never financed, and the past tense covers an item whose own loan is already paid. The words holds or held, together with the requirement of a purchase-money obligation, require that the extra debt be credit for other inventory the same secured party financed, and the past tense there covers items since sold.
Even within inventory, (b)(2) carries only purchase-money debt for other inventory.27 A bank that financed a dealer's stock and then lends $50,000 for payroll, secured by the same stock, has purchase-money status for the prices of the stock it financed and none for the payroll loan, because that loan was incurred with respect to no inventory. The other inventory must also be stock in which the same secured party holds or held a purchase-money security interest, so another creditor's financing of different goods lends no status to this one. Consigned goods do not need the extension at all, because § 9-103(d) deems the consignor's interest purchase-money in inventory directly, so an answer about consigned goods goes to subsection (d) and does not detour through (b)(2).
Software Purchase-Money Interests
Purchase-money security interests exist only in goods or software.29 The line between the two matters, because a program embedded in goods as the Code describes is itself treated as goods, while a program fixed to a disc, CD, DVD, or thumb drive is not.30 Embedded programs ride on the goods analysis, and programs that are not embedded in goods this way are the subject of the software rules below.
Section 9-103(b)(3) adds the last route to purchase-money status for a security interest in goods: the interest is also a purchase-money security interest to the extent it secures a purchase-money obligation incurred with respect to software in which the secured party holds or held a purchase-money security interest.31 The clause is needed because a buyer who acquires a machine and the software that runs it in one financed deal owes one price with two parts, and the software's part was incurred with respect to software, not the machine. Read alone, (b)(1) would make the machine purchase-money collateral only for its own price,32 leaving the software portion without purchase-money status in the machine. Subsection (b)(3) closes that gap from the goods side by letting the machine secure the software price as purchase-money debt.
Subsection (c) runs the idea in the other direction, and it is where the limits sit. A security interest in software is a purchase-money security interest to the extent that it also secures a purchase-money obligation incurred with respect to goods in which the secured party holds or held a purchase-money security interest, if two conditions are met.33 The conditions are cumulative, so both must be satisfied:
- The debtor acquired its interest in the software in an integrated transaction in which it acquired an interest in the goods.34
- The debtor acquired its interest in the software for the principal purpose of using the software in the goods.35
Each condition screens out a different risk. The first looks at how the software reached the debtor, and it excludes software bought in a separate deal at another time. The second looks at what the software is for, and it does the subtler work: software can sit on the same invoice as the goods and still be meant for the debtor's back office. Without both conditions, a financer could attach any software to a financed machine and borrow the machine's status.
The lender is the same in both scenes and the collateral is software in both, so the facts that moved the answer are how and why the software was acquired. In summary form, the secured party must have given value to enable the debtor to acquire the goods and must hold a purchase-money security interest in them, and the software must have been acquired in the same transaction as the goods and for the principal purpose of using it in them.36
Consigned goods rarely need this extension. The consignor's status comes directly from § 9-103(d), which requires no price obligation and no traced advance, so an answer about consigned goods can pass over software unless the goods arrive with a program that is part of the transaction. In that case, ask the two questions in subsection (c) about the program.