Concept
Keeping Purchase-Money Status
Is the consignor's interest a purchase-money security interest?
Keeping Purchase-Money Status
Purchase-money status is tested when the debtor acquires the goods, but a financing relationship rarely stays frozen at that moment. Section 9-103(f) asks whether the status survives the changes that follow. In a transaction other than a consumer-goods transaction, a purchase-money security interest does not lose its status as such, even if the later events the subsection lists occur.1 Those events fall into three groups. In a mixed debt, the financed goods also secure an obligation that financed nothing. With added collateral, goods that were not financed also secure the purchase-money debt. In a restructured debt, the original obligation is renewed, refinanced, consolidated, or otherwise rewritten.
Consider a supplier who sells a debtor a press on credit and takes a security interest in it. Months later the debtor needs working capital, and the supplier lends more money under the same security agreement, with the press securing both debts. Later still, the parties roll the unpaid balance into a new note. A competing creditor argues that the interest stopped being purchase-money the day the cash advance joined the agreement, or the day the note was rewritten. In a business transaction, Section 9-103(f) defeats that argument as to the portion of the debt that financed the press.
The rule exists because business financing seldom stays tidy. Suppliers fold advances into existing agreements, take several items as collateral for one debt, and renegotiate payment schedules. If any of those steps cost the lender its status, a seller who truly put the goods in the debtor's hands would risk the preference every time it extended more credit or restructured a loan. It would then need separate documents and separate collateral for every advance, and the debtor would lose the convenience of dealing with a single financer. The credit that financed the goods did so when it was given, and later paperwork does not rewrite that history.
The subsection preserves the status of the piece that earned it and gives no special priority to any other piece. As the discussion of dual status above explains, one security agreement can support a purchase-money interest and, alongside it, a non-purchase-money interest. The first keeps purchase-money treatment, and the second is an ordinary security interest. The preference rewards credit that put the asset in the debtor's hands, and a later advance for something else did nothing of the kind. Because the two pieces coexist, an undifferentiated payment raises the question of which piece it reduced, which is why the allocation rules matter. The subsection also reaches only business transactions, which is why consumer-goods transactions were treated separately above.
Surviving purchase-money status is a separate question from beating a lien creditor. Section 9-317 answers the second question. It subordinates a security interest to a creditor who becomes a lien creditor before the interest is perfected, and it implies that a secured party who has acted in time to perfect ranks ahead of a later lien creditor.2 Keeping the label settles what kind of interest the creditor holds. It does not excuse the creditor from the steps that protect that interest against other claimants.