Concept
Conditions for Priority
Does the consignment have purchase-money priority?
Conditions for Priority
The basic rule between secured creditors rewards the one who acts first: priority dates from the earlier of filing or perfection.1 Under that rule alone, a consignor that files after the consignee's inventory lender loses. UCC § 9-324(b) offers a way around it. For the many consignments within Article 9, the consignor's security interest is a purchase-money security interest in inventory,2 and a perfected purchase-money security interest in inventory outranks a conflicting security interest in the same inventory, but only if the requirements that follow the word "if" in § 9-324(b) are met.3
The rule applies because the consignee holds the goods as inventory, stock it will resell to its own customers.4 The same sentence of § 9-324(b) extends the priority, in stated circumstances, to certain chattel paper, instruments, and identifiable cash proceeds, a subject taken up under proceeds below.5 The grant is subject to subsection (c), which limits whom the consignor must notify, and it yields to subsection (g), which the chapter reaches under competing purchase-money interests.
Four requirements must all be met:
- The consignor's security interest must be perfected, normally by a filed financing statement, when the consignee receives possession of the goods.
- The consignor must send the holder of the conflicting security interest a signed notification.
- That holder must receive the notification within five years before the consignee receives possession of the goods.
- The notification must state that the consignor has or expects to acquire a purchase-money security interest in the consignee's inventory, and it must describe the inventory.6
Because the requirements are cumulative, a consignor that satisfies three and misses the fourth has not earned the priority, and each requirement is a separate place to lose it. The purpose of the rule explains why. An earlier inventory lender checks its floor stock and may count every item it finds as its own,7 so the consignor must warn that lender, in proper form and in time, before consigned goods arrive under a competing claim.
The three subsections below take the requirements in turn. The first covers perfection and its timing against the consignee's receipt of the goods. The second covers whom the consignor must notify, including the limit in subsection (c). The third covers the form, content, and timing of the notification. A consignor that clears all four wins the contest over the inventory; one that misses any falls back to the ordinary rule, a result the next section addresses.
Perfection Before Delivery
The first requirement concerns timing: the consignor's interest must be perfected when the consignee receives possession of the goods.8 For a consignor, perfection ordinarily means a financing statement filed against the consignee.9 A financing statement may be filed before the security agreement is signed or the interest attaches, so a cautious consignor can file early and well before shipment.10 The date of the consignee's receipt is the line, and the only question is whether perfection came before it or after it.
The statute allows no grace after that date. A purchase-money interest in goods other than inventory or livestock may be perfected up to 20 days after the debtor receives possession; an interest in inventory may not.11 A consignor that files a day after delivery is therefore as late as one that files a month after. The earlier lender's floor checks explain the strictness: that lender may count everything it finds on the premises as its own, unaware that another creditor financed some of it.12 Perfection at the moment of possession puts the consignor's claim on the record before the goods arrive.
Late perfection defeats the priority even when everything else is flawless.
Notice never substitutes for perfection, and a filing in the wrong place does not perfect. In one illustration, State Bank sent a timely and proper notice to National Bank but filed its financing statement in Washington rather than Idaho, so its security interest attached but remained unperfected.13 A consignor in that position fails the first requirement however careful its notice.
The requirement is measured goods by goods. It asks whether the interest was perfected when the debtor received possession of the inventory in question,14 so a consignor that perfects late forfeits priority only in goods that reached the consignee before it perfected. In those goods the earlier lender, having filed first, prevails under the basic rule.15 Goods that arrive after the consignor has filed and given notice are judged on their own.
Whom the Consignor Must Notify
The consignor does not owe notice to every lender the consignee has ever had. Subsection (c) confines the notice requirements in (b)(2) through (4) to a holder of a conflicting security interest who had filed a financing statement covering the same types of inventory.17 A lender is owed notice, then, only if it filed and only if its filing reaches the kind of goods being consigned. Because the consignor's interest is a purchase-money security interest in inventory, the consignor carries the same notice burden as any other purchase-money secured party in inventory.18
The lender's filing must also be early enough, and the statute fixes the reference date in two ways. When the consignor perfects by filing, the holder must have filed before the date of the consignor's filing.19 When the consignor instead relies on the temporary perfection of § 9-312(f), a route the commentary ties to goods held by a bailee, the holder must have filed before the beginning of the 20-day period.20 The first rule governs the ordinary route, and it hides a trap: the date that counts is the consignor's filing date, not the day the goods arrive. A lender that filed after the consignor but before delivery is a later filer and is owed no notice.
Each limit tracks the reason for the notice. An earlier inventory lender examines its collateral on floor checks and, without notice, might count all the inventory on the premises as its own.21 The lender that filed against the same types of inventory before the consignor is the lender exposed to that mistake. A lender that filed after the consignor falls outside subsection (c) by its terms, because the consignor's filing came first. A lender whose filing covers only other collateral, such as equipment, has no filing covering the same types of inventory.
Steps three and four apply the two requirements of subsection (c): an earlier filing and a covering description.22 The duty runs holder by holder. A consignor that notifies one earlier filer and skips another gains priority over the first only, because the condition calls for a notification to the holder of the conflicting security interest being outranked.23
An exam fact pattern that lists several lenders is testing exactly this sorting. For each lender, ask two questions: did it file before the consignor's filing date, and does its financing statement cover the same types of inventory? Notify only the lenders that pass both.
The consignor must notify the earlier lender but need not win its agreement. The conditions require the consignor to send a notification to the holder,24 and none requires the holder's consent. The notice answers the lender's floor-check problem by telling it that another creditor is financing some of the goods on its premises,25 and the statute asks for nothing more.
Content and Timing of Notice
Three of the four requirements in UCC § 9-324(b) govern the notification itself, and each polices a different way a notice can fail. Under (b)(2) the consignor must send a signed notification to the holder of the conflicting security interest. Under (b)(3) the holder must receive it within five years before the debtor receives possession of the inventory. Under (b)(4) it must state that the sender has or expects to acquire a purchase-money security interest in inventory of the debtor and describe the inventory.27 A consignor stands in the sender's position because its interest is a purchase-money security interest in inventory.28 A notice that passes two of these tests and fails the third leaves the consignor without priority. All three serve one purpose: a lender checking its floor should not mistake the consigned goods for its own collateral.29
The notification must be signed. The 1999 text speaks of an authenticated notification, and the 2022 amendment substitutes "sign" for "authenticate."30 The practical advice to a consignor is to give written notification to any other secured party who has filed.31 A telephone call, however informative, is not a signed notification.
The content requirement has two halves. The notification must state that the sender has or expects to acquire a purchase-money security interest in the debtor's inventory, and it must describe the inventory.32 For a consignor, that means stating that it expects to deliver goods on consignment to the consignee and describing the goods by item or type.33 The phrase "has or expects to acquire" fits the timing: the notice must precede the goods, so it often speaks of an interest not yet acquired. The description matters because of floor checks. A lender that finds goods on its debtor's premises may treat them as its own, and a description lets it recognize goods financed by someone else.34
Timing involves two questions: who must act, and when. Subsection (b)(2) puts the duty to send on the consignor, and (b)(3) separately requires that the holder receive the notification, so mailing a notice satisfies the first duty and does nothing for the second.35 Receipt must fall within the five-year period before the debtor receives possession of the inventory,36 which means before the consignee takes the goods and no more than five years earlier. An exam fact pattern that says the consignor "sent" notice has therefore not said whether the requirement is met. The questions that matter are when the lender received the notice and when the goods arrived.
The five-year window belongs to inventory. For livestock that are farm products, the parallel rule requires the holder to receive the notice within six months before the debtor receives possession.37
The five-year language also helps the consignor. Because the window is measured backward from each delivery, one notice received by the lender covers every delivery that falls within five years after it arrives.38 A notice older than that no longer counts, and the consignor needs a fresh one.
The description requirement still applies to each shipment, so a consignor that adds a new line of goods should confirm that the notice on file describes it before relying on that notice.