Concept
When Priority Fails
Does the consignment have purchase-money priority?
When Priority Fails
The purchase-money priority in UCC § 9-324(b) belongs only to the consignor who earns it. A perfected purchase-money security interest in inventory outranks a conflicting interest in the same inventory, but only if the subsection's conditions are met.1 Three of those conditions are steps the consignor must take, and one is a deadline. The consignor must be perfected before the consignee receives the goods.2 It must notify each secured party that filed against the inventory before the consignor did, and that party must receive the notice within the five years before the consignee takes possession. The notice must also identify the inventory and say that the consignor has, or expects to take, a security interest in it.3
Miss any one of these conditions and § 9-324(b) gives the consignor nothing. The contest then falls to the rule that governs secured parties generally: conflicting perfected security interests rank by priority in time of filing or perfection. Priority dates from the earlier of the first filing covering the collateral or the first perfection of the interest, provided there is no later period when the interest is neither filed nor perfected.4 This is the basic rule always applied in competition between secured creditors.5 The consignor does not forfeit its security interest. It is simply treated as holding a non-purchase-money interest.6 In the usual case the consignee's inventory lender filed before the consignment began, so the lender holds the earlier date and wins. A consignor that happened to file ahead of the lender holds the better date and wins under the same rule, without needing § 9-324(b) at all.
The notice condition has a purpose, and the purpose explains why a missing notice is fatal. A prior secured party with a security interest in inventory makes regular examinations, or floor checks, of its collateral. Without notice, that creditor might think all of the inventory at the debtor's premises is its own and count it that way, not knowing that another creditor had financed some of it.7 Notice replaces that assumption with knowledge. When the consignor skips the notice, the lender's assumption remains reasonable, and the first-in-time rule protects the lender who held it.
Three variations on one set of facts show how the conditions work. The lender filed on May 1 against all of the store's present and after-acquired inventory. In the first variation, the consignor files on June 1, sends the lender a proper notification before delivery, and delivers on June 5. Every condition is met, so the consignor outranks the lender despite filing later.8 In the second variation, the facts are identical except that the consignor never notifies the lender. The June 1 filing still satisfies the perfection condition, but the notice condition fails, and the lender's May 1 date controls.9 In the third variation, the consignor delivers on August 5, files on August 10, and had sent proper notice before delivery. The lender wins, because the consignor was not perfected when the consignee received the goods.10 The first two variations differ only in the notice, so the notice alone decides the outcome. The second and third fail different conditions and lose the same way. A timely notice cannot make up for a late filing, and a timely filing cannot make up for a missing notice.
A consignor that never perfects at all loses more than the special priority. An unperfected security interest is subordinate to a perfected one. If both interests are unperfected, the first to attach has priority.11 Filing dates are also not the only way a prior owner can lose goods. Suppose a buyer with voidable title grants a security interest in them. A secured party who qualifies as a good faith purchaser for value takes good title, consistent with its rights as a secured party.12
The same hurdles apply to a lender that finances the purchase instead of supplying the goods. In Example 4, Debtor signed a security agreement giving Lender an interest in widgets for any loan Lender might make for the price. Seller delivered the widgets and billed Debtor, Debtor forwarded the bill, and Lender paid Seller.13 A lender in that position who wants to outrank an earlier inventory filer must likewise be perfected before the debtor receives the goods and must give the earlier filer notice.14