Concept
The Title-Neutral Rule
Title to collateral immaterial (§ 9-202)
Title to Collateral Is Immaterial
The Title-Neutral Rule
Section 9-202 tells a court to stop asking who owns the collateral. Except as otherwise provided for consignments and for sales of accounts, chattel paper, payment intangibles, and promissory notes, Article 9's provisions on rights and obligations apply whether title to the collateral is in the secured party or the debtor.1 A judge deciding a dispute between lender and borrower reaches the same Article 9 rule whichever of them the agreement or the parties' labels treat as the titleholder.
Older security law made title the hinge. Pre-Code chattel mortgage laws in some states adopted a 'title theory' of security interests, and Article 9 declines to follow that course. It adopts neither a 'title theory' nor a 'lien theory,' and it does not decide whether title to the collateral sits with the secured party or the debtor.2 What it does say is that rights, obligations, and remedies under the Article do not depend on the location of title.3
The drafters' comment explains the method. The Article makes distinctions, where distinctions are necessary, along functional rather than formal lines, and that approach made possible a radical simplification in the formal requisites for creating a security interest.4 Title is a formal label. A rule keyed to function looks at what the arrangement does for the creditor and not at what the paper calls it, so a drafter who writes title into one side of the contract changes the label and leaves the Article 9 result where it was.
Section 9-207 makes the phrase rights and obligations concrete. It governs a secured party that holds collateral in its possession, and it requires that party to use reasonable care in the custody and preservation of the collateral.5 The duty does not shrink because the agreement names the secured party as titleholder, and it does not grow because the agreement leaves title with the debtor.6 The Article can state the duty once.
The rule has limits, and its own wording marks the first. Section 9-202 speaks to rights and obligations under Article 9, so it does not tell a taxing authority which party owns goods for purposes of a tax on owners. The location of title may matter under other law outside Article 9, and for those purposes the parties are left free to contract as they will.7 Where title is relevant, a form traditionally regarded as determinative of title may be considered as evidence of the parties' intention. Where the secured transaction arises in connection with a sale of goods, § 2-401 may determine the location of title to the extent it is relevant.8 State the rule with that precision: title is immaterial to Article 9 rights and obligations, which is a narrower claim than saying title is meaningless everywhere. The later section Where Title Still Matters develops the point.
The opening clause of § 9-202 marks the second limit. For consignments and for sales of accounts, chattel paper, payment intangibles, and promissory notes, the Article makes separate provision, so a transaction in one of those categories follows its own treatment and not the general title-neutral instruction. Carve-Outs in the Text, below, takes up each category.