Concept
Alternatives to a Signed Agreement
Enforceability (§ 9-203)
Alternatives to a Signed Agreement
A debtor-signed security agreement is one way to satisfy § 9-203(b)(3), and the statute does not make it the only way. The subsection lists several conditions and treats the requirement as met when any one of them holds. The signed agreement that describes the collateral is simply the first item on the list. If the security interest covers timber to be cut, that agreement must also describe the land.1 The other items offer a different authenticating event in place of a writing signed by the debtor. One is an authenticated security agreement that is not in writing. Others are the creditor's taking possession under 9-313, its taking delivery of certificated securities under 8-301, and its achieving control over certain kinds of collateral.2
These alternatives relax only the fifth of the steps § 9-203 lays out. The creditor must still give value, the debtor must still have rights in the collateral, and there must still be a security agreement. What each alternative provides is grounds for concluding that the parties have entered into that agreement, even though no signed writing exists.3 A secured party needs only one authenticating event, so the signed writing and the alternatives are interchangeable on that single element.4
Consider a pawn. Dana borrows $5,000 from Pawnco and hands over her watch. The parties agree orally that the watch secures the loan, and nothing is signed. Pawnco gave value, Dana owns the watch, and the parties have a security agreement, so the only open question is authentication. Pawnco's possession answers it. The same possession answers the description question, since the watch in Pawnco's hands identifies the collateral without any written words.
The description requirement shrinks along with the writing, though not evenly across the alternatives. Section 9-203(b)(3)(A) demands that an authenticated security agreement "provide a description of the collateral." Possession under (3)(B) and delivery to the secured party under (3)(C) make a description unnecessary. Control under (3)(D), which applies to deposit accounts and investment property, does so only to a lesser extent. Subsection (3)(D) does not require a description as such, but the secured creditor must still identify the deposit accounts or investment property it controls, so a description problem can survive even there.5
Possession, delivery of certificated securities, and control each work for particular kinds of collateral, and the sections that follow take them up in turn.