Concept
Attachment Without an Agreement
Enforceability (§ 9-203)
Attachment Without an Agreement
Every attachment rule so far has traced back to the debtor's own bargain. Section 9-203(b) makes a security interest enforceable against the debtor and third parties with respect to the collateral "only if" its conditions are met: value, the debtor's rights in the collateral, and the debtor's agreement, which can be evidenced by a signed record or by one of the substitutes the last section taught. But the subsection opens with a qualification: "Except as otherwise provided in subsections (c) through (i)."1 Those lettered subsections are exceptions, and some of them let a security interest attach without the debtor's own security agreement.
The words "only if" cut both ways. They make the three conditions exclusive, so a lender whose transaction does not fit one of the exceptions cannot borrow from it by analogy. Such a lender must satisfy subsection (b) as written. When a deal does fit an exception, the exception controls, and the lender does not need to prove the condition that the exception displaces. In either case the first step is to identify which rule governs.
The sections that follow work through the exceptions in four groups: sales and lease interests, collecting banks and issuers, securities dealer interests, and successor debtors. Successor debtors come first here because they show most plainly how an interest can attach to a debtor who signed nothing.
Subsection (d) applies when a new debtor becomes bound as debtor by a security agreement that another person entered into.2 The paradigm case is a business sale. Suppose Lender holds a signed security agreement from Alpha Tooling covering Alpha's assets. Alpha then transfers substantially all of its assets to Beta Manufacturing, and Beta becomes generally obligated for Alpha's obligations. Beta has signed nothing in Lender's favor. Even so, Beta is bound by the security agreement that Alpha entered into.3 Lender does not need a new agreement from Beta to satisfy the agreement requirement.
The agreement requirement exists to show that a debtor consented to encumber its property. Here the consent comes from the agreement the original debtor made, and Beta, by taking over the assets and the obligations, steps into that agreement. The rule speaks to the agreement. By its own terms, the opening clause of subsection (b) displaces only what an exception displaces, so a lender should still check the other conditions of subsection (b) in a successor case.