Concept
Possession, Delivery, and Control in Place of a Signed Record
Enforceability (§ 9-203)
Possession, Delivery, and Control in Place of a Signed Record
A security interest is enforceable against the debtor and third parties only if the statute's conditions are met, and one of those conditions asks for evidence that the debtor agreed.1 The usual evidence is a security agreement that the debtor has signed and that describes the collateral.2 A writing is not indispensable, though. Article 9 also accepts possession of specified collateral, or control of specified collateral, as evidence that the agreement exists.3
Each of these substitutes replaces the signed record and nothing else. The debtor must still agree to grant the security interest, value must still be given, and the debtor must still have rights in the collateral.4 What disappears is the need for a signed writing that describes the collateral: possession and delivery make a description unnecessary, and control does so to a lesser extent.5
A different departure from the description rule should not be confused with these three. In six circumstances, Article 9 carries attachment from one type of collateral to another, specified type, so that the security agreement need not describe the added property. Proceeds are the best-known case, and the agreement need not even use the word.6 Supporting obligations, meaning guarantees and letter-of-credit rights that stand behind collateral, are also among the related property that later units cover.7 This unit asks a narrower question: when may the secured party's own possession, delivery, or control take the place of the debtor's signed record?
Possession
Section 9-203(b)(3)(B) satisfies the evidence condition without a record when the collateral is not a certificated security and the secured party possesses it under § 9-313 pursuant to the debtor's security agreement.8 A secured party who holds collateral on those terms has taken a pledge, and nothing need be signed.9 The pawn loan is the familiar illustration: the borrower leaves jewelry with the lender, and the lender's hold on the jewelry is the security.
Pledge is also the oldest way to bind outsiders. Before filing systems existed, taking possession was the only way a secured party could gain rights against other secured parties, buyers, and lien creditors, and it limited credit because debtors usually need to keep using what they pledge.10 Today possession is one route to attachment among several. It spares the secured party any need to describe the collateral, because the property in its hands identifies itself.11
Possession proves little by itself, which is why the statute requires that the secured party hold the collateral pursuant to the debtor's security agreement. A person may hold another's goods for safekeeping, for repair, or as a favor, and none of those is a security bargain. The agreement may be oral, but it must exist. The VAR checklist names what must accompany the possession: value, agreement, and rights in the collateral.12 Ted O. may have Fred's watch in his hands, but if the two never agreed, orally or otherwise, that the watch would secure anything, the A in VAR is missing and Ted has no security interest. Had Fred agreed, even orally, that Ted could keep the watch as security for a $100 loan, and had Ted made the loan, nothing more would be needed.
The agreement is the parties' bargain in fact.13 Its substance counts and its vocabulary does not. A seller who sells a piano on credit and recites that "title shall remain in Store until all of the payments are made" is a secured party despite the language, and a retailer who takes diamonds on consignment is governed by Article 9 even though no one intended a security interest.14 The reverse holds as well. A creditor who merely holds property, with no bargain that it stands behind the debt, has no security interest, and a judgment creditor who seizes property by attachment, garnishment, or execution has a judicial lien created by law outside Article 9.15
Possession means physically holding something, so this route reaches only collateral that can be held, such as goods, money, and paper instruments like promissory notes. Intangibles do not qualify. A lender who orally agrees to take a debtor's accounts and then takes the accounts ledger holds paper about the accounts and none of the accounts themselves, so nothing attaches by possession. A lender who takes the debtor's promissory notes under the same oral agreement holds the collateral itself, because the paper embodies the right to be paid, and the interest attaches with no signed record. Deposit accounts and similar intangibles are reached through control, which is discussed below.16 Certificated securities are excluded from this subsection because they have their own route through delivery, and chattel paper is handled in a separate paragraph of the current text.
Article 9 does not define possession, but the idea is that the secured party or its agent has dominion over the collateral and the debtor is excluded from access to it. Debtor access to the collateral ordinarily destroys the attempt to attach a security interest through possession.17 The exclusion matters because possession replaces a record only if the debtor has actually parted with the property. A debtor who can still reach and use the collateral looks no different from a debtor who never granted anything.
Possession is only as durable as the secured party's hold. Suppose a debtor owes a lender $100,000, and the lender holds the debtor's painting under an oral agreement that it secures the debt. The debtor asks for the painting to show a prospective buyer, and the lender hands it over. The oral agreement did satisfy the evidence condition, but only because the lender's possession evidenced it. Once possession is released, no signed record describes the painting and none of the permitted methods is present, so the lender is unsecured as to the painting.18
For that reason a signed record remains the better practice even where possession would suffice. A record sets out the debt secured and the rights of the parties,19 and it keeps the interest enforceable if the collateral must go back to the debtor.
Delivery of Certificated Securities
Certificated securities, which the possession subsection excludes, have a route of their own. Section 9-203(b)(3)(C) satisfies the evidence condition when the collateral is a certificated security in registered form and the certificate has been delivered to the secured party under Section 8-301 pursuant to the debtor's security agreement.21 No record of the security agreement is required.22 A certificated security is an investment interest, such as a share of stock, represented by a paper certificate, and registered form means the certificate names its owner. Like possession, delivery makes a description of the collateral unnecessary.23
Article 9 borrows Article 8's idea of delivery because certificates often sit with someone other than their owner. A broker, a custodian, or a friend may hold the paper, and a rule demanding the secured party's own physical possession would exclude every such pledge. Delivery under § 8-301 can occur in three ways:
- The secured party itself acquires possession of the certificate.
- A person other than a securities intermediary holds the certificate and acknowledges that it holds the certificate for the secured party.
- A securities intermediary has possession of a registered certificate, and the certificate is registered in the secured party's name, payable to the secured party, or indorsed to the secured party.24
Two illustrations show how the second and third forms differ. A and B agree that B will have a security interest in a certificated security A owns, to secure a loan B made to A, and C, who is not a securities intermediary, holds the certificate. When B asks, C acknowledges that it holds the certificate for B's benefit, and B's interest attaches. If C is instead a securities intermediary holding a registered certificate, C's acknowledgment would not be enough. But if A, at B's request, indorses the certificate to B and leaves it in C's possession, B has taken delivery.
An ordinary holder's acknowledgment is enough, while an intermediary's possession counts only when the certificate itself carries the secured party's name, order, or indorsement. The difference tracks what an intermediary ordinarily does: it holds securities for its customers, and the debtor may be one of them. A bare statement from the debtor's own custodian would leave the certificate registered in the debtor's name and would show nothing about whether the debtor gave anything up.
Delivery satisfies only the evidence condition, and only when it occurs pursuant to the debtor's security agreement.25 That agreement may be oral, but it must exist, value must still be given, and the debtor must still have rights in the security.26 A certificate that reaches the secured party for another reason, such as safekeeping, shows no security bargain. Subsection (C) speaks only of securities in registered form. A certificate in bearer form falls outside it, but investment property is among the collateral that subsection (D) reaches through control, which comes next.27 As with possession, a signed record stating which debt the collateral secures and what each party may do remains the better practice.28
Control
Collateral that cannot be held in the hand needs a different substitute for the signed record, and for many intangibles that substitute is control. Section 9-203(b)(3)(D) satisfies the evidence condition when the collateral is controllable accounts, controllable electronic records, controllable payment intangibles, deposit accounts, electronic documents, electronic money, investment property, or letter-of-credit rights, and the secured party has control under the section governing that type pursuant to the debtor's security agreement.30 Possession cannot serve for such assets, because a deposit account or a letter-of-credit right has no physical form to take into custody. The statute therefore pairs possession of specified collateral with control of specified collateral.31 Control, like possession, relieves the secured party of describing the collateral, though to a lesser extent.32
Control departs from possession in one respect that students often carry over by mistake: the debtor need not be excluded. None of the recognized ways of obtaining control of a deposit account requires that the debtor be shut out of the funds.33 Debtor access, which ordinarily defeats possession of goods,34 can coexist with a secured party's control of an account, and that suits an asset the debtor draws on every day.
What counts as control depends on the type of collateral, and the statute points to a separate control section for the types it lists: Sections 7-106, 9-104, 9-105A, 9-106, 9-107, and 9-107A.35 Deposit accounts, for example, run through § 9-104.36 The analysis therefore starts by classifying the collateral and then applies the control section for that classification.
The deposit account is the model case, and its control section recognizes three ways to obtain control:
- The secured party is itself the depositary bank with which the account is maintained.
- The secured party, the debtor, and the depositary bank have authenticated a record providing that the bank will follow the secured party's instructions about the funds without further consent from the debtor.
- A secured party that is not the depositary bank becomes the bank's customer on the account.37
Each route puts the secured party where it can reach the funds without the debtor's cooperation. The record in the second route proves that control exists. The debtor's agreement that the account secures the debt is a separate bargain, and under subsection (D) it may be oral.38
The phrase "pursuant to the debtor's security agreement" does real work, because control can exist for reasons that have nothing to do with a security bargain. A bank has control of every deposit account it maintains simply because it is the depositary bank.39 A bank that has made an unsecured loan to a customer therefore has control of the customer's account. But if the customer never agreed, orally or in a record, that the account would stand behind the loan, the control is not pursuant to any security agreement, and no interest attaches under subsection (D).40 A secured party's good position does not replace the debtor's agreement.
Control also has a duration. The statute is phrased in the present tense, so a secured party relying on control alone satisfies the evidence condition only while it "has control," just as with possession.41 A signed agreement describing the collateral does not depend on control. For investment property, writing that description is easy: in a nonconsumer transaction the agreement may use the terms securities account, securities entitlement, or commodity account, may say "investment property," or may describe the underlying asset.42
Chattel paper has its own paragraph in the statute. Under § 9-203(b)(3)(E), the third condition is met when the collateral is chattel paper and the secured party has possession and control under § 9-314A pursuant to the debtor's security agreement.43 The text joins possession and control with "and," so this paragraph asks for both where every other alternative asks for one. Sources written before the amendments treat control of electronic chattel paper under § 9-105 as one of the control routes, but the current text addresses chattel paper separately.44