Concept
Attachment Without Agreement
Enforceability (§ 9-203)
Attachment Without Agreement
Section 9-203(b) sets out the ordinary path to an enforceable security interest, and subsection (c) lets four kinds of interest bypass it. Subsection (b) is subject to Section 4-210 on the security interest of a collecting bank, Section 5-118 on the security interest of a letter-of-credit issuer or nominated person, Section 9-110 on a security interest arising under Article 2 or 2A, and Section 9-206 on security interests in investment property.1 Article 9 recognizes these as security interests that arise by operation of law, not agreement, so in these circumstances a security interest attaches to collateral without the debtor's security agreement.2
The cross-referenced provision, not subsection (b), then says when the interest arises and how long it lasts. In each setting the transaction itself supplies what a signed record would otherwise prove: a seller ships under reservation, a bank credits an item it holds, a broker credits an asset to a customer's account before the price arrives. The statute names those events, so it does not ask for a signature as well.
A fifth rule, taken up last, reaches a similar result by another route. When a business changes hands, subsections (d) and (e) make the predecessor's security agreement effective against the successor, and the secured party needs no new signature from the successor.3
Each exception is conditional. A collecting bank's lasts only until final settlement, an issuer's only until reimbursement, and the sales-article exemption only while the debtor lacks the goods. When the condition fails, the exception stops excusing the missing agreement. A problem that shows no debtor-signed record, no possession, and no control therefore deserves one more check before the conclusion that nothing attached: do the facts fit one of these provisions on its own terms?
Sales and Lease Interests
Articles 2 and 2A can produce a security interest without any Article 9 bargain, and § 9-110 is the cross-reference that says so.4 A seller's retention of title and its shipment under reservation each create a security interest, under sections 2-401 and 2-505. A buyer's or lessee's interest in goods it has rightfully rejected, or whose acceptance it has justifiably revoked, arises under sections 2-711(3) and 2A-508.5 All of these interests are subject to Article 9. As long as the debtor does not have possession of the goods, however, the secured party needs neither a signed security agreement describing the collateral nor possession under the debtor's agreement.6
Possession is the controlling fact, and the identity of the debtor depends on whose interest is at stake. When a seller reserves title or ships under reservation, the seller holds the interest, the buyer is the debtor, and the goods are with the seller or a carrier. When a buyer or lessee holds rightfully rejected goods, the buyer or lessee holds the interest, the seller or lessor is the debtor, and the goods are with the buyer or lessee. In both cases the debtor lacks the goods.
While the debtor lacks possession, three things follow: no security agreement is necessary, no filing is required to perfect the interest, and the parties' rights on default are governed by Articles 2 and 2A. The exemption lasts only so long as the debtor does not have, and does not lawfully obtain, possession.7 If the buyer receives the goods while the seller reserves title or a security interest for the price, Article 9 applies fully and a written security agreement is necessary.8
The line falls at possession because, until the goods reach the buyer, the sales transaction itself shows the seller's position, and a separate Article 9 document would only repeat it. Once the buyer holds the goods, the arrangement looks like any other credit sale in which the seller keeps an interest, and the usual requirements return. The reflex on an exam is to demand a signed agreement whenever a seller reserves title. Ask first who holds the goods:
The second mill's invoice says what the first mill's shipping term says. What changed is possession, and with it the ordinary conditions return, including a signed agreement that describes the collateral.9
Collecting Banks and Issuers
When a bank pays out value against something it holds, § 9-203(c) lets the bank's security interest exist without a signed agreement. Two cross-references apply: § 4-210 for a collecting bank and § 5-118 for a letter-of-credit issuer or nominated person.11 Each banking provision says for itself when its interest attaches and how long it lasts, so no debtor-signed security agreement is needed while its conditions continue.12 The two interests share one design: the bank gives value, keeps an interest in what it holds, and loses the interest once it has been made whole. The collecting bank's version is simpler, so it comes first.
A collecting bank sends a customer's check or other item through the banking system toward payment. Its security interest in an item in its possession attaches when it gives withdrawable credit against the item.13 In the standard illustration, Bank B takes from its customer A a check drawn by D on Bank C, and B lets A withdraw the amount before the check is collected. B then has a security interest in the check, enforceable against D if Bank C does not pay it. B needs no security agreement and no filing.14
The rule tracks the bank's position. A bank that lets a customer draw on a deposit before the check is paid has already put out its own money on the strength of an item that may still be dishonored. The check is the thing standing behind that advance, and the interest lets the bank look to the item and to those liable on it. Because the arrangement shows itself in the ordinary course of collection, a customer-signed record would prove nothing the transaction does not already show.
The exception lasts only while the bank stays exposed and keeps the item. No security agreement is necessary so long as the collecting bank does not receive final settlement for the item and does not give up possession or control of it for purposes other than collection through the banking system.15 Final settlement ends the exception because it is the payment that makes the bank whole; once Bank C has settled for B's check, the advance to A no longer needs the check behind it. Surrender ends it for a different reason, since the bank no longer holds what stood behind its advance. The qualifier about collection through the banking system protects routine handling: a bank that forwards the check toward the paying bank is still collecting it and has given up nothing.
The letter-of-credit issuer is in the same position. A letter of credit is a bank's undertaking to pay a beneficiary who presents the documents the letter requires, and the issuer then looks to its customer for reimbursement. A security agreement is not necessary to attach the issuer's security interest to the documents presented, as long as the issuer has not been reimbursed for or otherwise recovered the value it gave under the letter of credit.16 The cross-reference in subsection (c) names a nominated person alongside the issuer, so the same exception reaches both.17
The reasoning mirrors the collecting bank's. By honoring a presentation, the issuer pays out its own funds, and until the customer reimburses it, the presented documents are its tangible assurance. The exception gives the issuer an interest in them without waiting for the customer to sign anything.
The collecting bank's exception ends in the same way. If Bank C settles for B's check, or B gives the check up for some purpose other than collection, B can no longer rely on the exception, just as reimbursement ends it for Harbor. In both settings the exception lasts while the bank is out of pocket and keeps hold of what it took.
A student who finds no signed record in these facts may conclude that the bank is unsecured, but that reasoning applies subsection (b) where subsection (c) has displaced it. Ask three questions instead: what did the bank give, what does the bank hold, and has the bank been made whole?
Securities Dealer Interests
The last cross-reference in § 9-203(c) points to § 9-206, which covers security interests in investment property that arise as securities trades settle.19 In a trade the asset often moves before the price is paid, which leaves the party that moved first exposed to a counterparty who may never pay. Article 9 answers by giving that party a security interest in what it delivered, and the interest attaches without a debtor-signed security agreement because the trade itself creates it.20 Two situations qualify, one involving a securities intermediary and its customer, the other involving the delivery of paper. In both, the interest secures a single obligation: the price that remains unpaid.
A securities intermediary is a firm, such as a broker, that holds assets for customers in securities accounts. Suppose a customer buys a financial asset through the intermediary under an agreement to pay for it at the time of purchase, and the intermediary credits the asset to the customer's securities account before the customer actually pays. The credit creates a securities entitlement, and the intermediary holds a security interest in that entitlement to secure the customer's obligation to pay the purchase price.21 An ordinary security agreement in a nonconsumer transaction could describe such collateral as a securities entitlement or as “investment property,” but this interest needs no description because it needs no agreement.22
The sequence explains the rule. By crediting the account first, the intermediary hands over what the customer bought on the customer's promise to pay, so the customer holds something of value before the price arrives. The interest puts the thing sold behind the price.
The intermediary's interest rests on two facts in a particular order: an agreement to pay at purchase, which creates the debt, and a credit to the account before payment, which creates the exposure. Hale's case has both. Park's case has the agreement but lacks the exposure, since he paid first, and once a price has been paid the interest has nothing left to secure.
The second situation involves paper. A person that delivers a certificated security, or another financial asset represented by a writing, in a securities-dealing transaction holds a security interest in what it delivered, which secures payment for the delivery.23 Dealers trade by delivering paper while payment follows, and without this interest the deliverer would stand as an unsecured seller until the money arrived. The collateral differs from the intermediary's: here the interest attaches to the certificate or writing-represented asset itself, while the intermediary's attaches to the entitlement its own credit created.
This interest is narrow. A delivery that does not fit it must satisfy § 9-203(b) in the ordinary way, because subsection (b) governs except as subsections (c) through (i) provide.24 A student who runs the intermediary and dealer facts through the possession and control alternatives taught earlier will wrongly find nothing attached, because neither interest depends on a record, possession, or control. Whether such an interest is perfected, and how it ranks against other claimants, are separate questions that this unit does not reach.
Successor Debtors
The ordinary route to enforceability asks the debtor to have signed a security agreement describing the collateral.26 A business that changes hands often ends up owned by someone who signed nothing, and § 9-203(d) closes that gap. A person becomes bound as debtor by a security agreement entered into by another person if, by operation of law other than Article 9 or by contract, one of two things happens.27 Either the security agreement becomes effective to create a security interest in that person's property,28 or the person becomes generally obligated for the other's obligations, including the one the agreement secures, and acquires or succeeds to all or substantially all of the other's assets.29 Article 9 calls the signer the original debtor and the person who steps in the new debtor.30
Both alternatives turn on contract or on law outside Article 9. Article 9 does not make a stranger a debtor; it recognizes as a debtor a person whom contract or other law has already tied to the agreement, and subsections (d) and (e) then make the predecessor's agreement effective against that person.31
The second alternative has two parts, and each does its own work. The obligation half links the successor to the bargain: a person who answers for the original debtor's debts, the secured one included, has taken on what the collateral stands behind. The asset half links the successor to the collateral: a person who succeeds to all or substantially all of the original debtor's assets holds the property the secured party relied on. Neither half suffices alone. A person who takes on the debts but few assets has not stepped into the original debtor's property position, and a person who takes the assets without answering for the debts has not stepped into its obligations. That person's separately owned property has no reason to be swept into an agreement the person never made.
Once a new debtor is bound, subsection (e) removes the need for a new signed agreement. The original agreement satisfies § 9-203(b)(3) for the new debtor's existing or after-acquired property to the extent the agreement describes it, and no other agreement is necessary to make the interest enforceable.32 The original debtor supplied the proof of consent when it signed, and a successor that took on the debt and the business carries that bargain forward. Demanding a new signature would let the successor escape a secured claim by declining to sign a paper, though it had taken both the debt and the assets.
A standard illustration shows the mechanics. A signs a security agreement granting B an interest in all of A's equipment, then owned or thereafter acquired, to secure a loan B made to A. A then sells the entire business to C, and under principles of successor liability C becomes obligated on A's obligations. C is bound by the security agreement, and the agreement suffices to attach a security interest to all of C's equipment.33 C signed nothing, and nothing more was required.
Subsection (e) speaks only to the third condition of § 9-203(b), so the other two remain. Value must have been given,34 and the new debtor must have rights in each item of collateral before the interest attaches to it,35 so equipment the new debtor buys next year is caught when the new debtor acquires rights in it. The description sets the outer limit as well: the interest reaches the new debtor's property only to the extent the original agreement describes it, so an agreement covering equipment gives B nothing in C's inventory.36 Perfection, which most security interests accomplish by filing,37 is a later question, including whether the secured party's earlier filing carries over to the new debtor.
Pell's purchase raises a different question from whether Pell is a new debtor. Becoming a new debtor decides whether the original agreement reaches the buyer's own property. It does not decide what happens to the collateral the buyer bought, which is a separate matter of the secured party's rights against transferees. A student who sees a transfer of collateral and concludes that the transferee is a new debtor has run the two together, and the two-part test is what separates them.