Concept
Attachment to Related Property
Enforceability (§ 9-203)
Attachment to Related Property
A security agreement is the parties’ bargain in fact, and when the debtor signs it, the agreement reaches only the collateral its description reasonably identifies.1 The description therefore marks the outer edge of the secured party’s interest. Section 9-203(b), however, opens with the words “Except as otherwise provided in subsections (c) through (i).”2 Earlier sections covered exceptions that stand in for the signed agreement, such as possession of, or control over, specified collateral.3 The exceptions in § 9-203(f) through (i) keep the agreement in place and relax what it must describe. Once an interest has attached to one asset, an interest attaches automatically to a related asset the agreement never mentions.4
Each carry-over answers one question: when the secured party holds an attached interest in described collateral, which related assets travel with it without a separate description? This unit takes up five answers: the proceeds the collateral produces, the supporting obligation behind a right to payment or performance, the lien that secures a right to payment, the security entitlements in a securities account, and the commodity contracts in a commodity account.
The reason for the exceptions is that each related asset either comes from the described collateral or is so closely tied to it that the parties are presumed to have meant it to be covered. Without the exceptions, a sale of described equipment would turn the collateral into a price the description does not name. A guaranty or mortgage backing a described right to payment would stay outside the grant, even though the right is worth far less without it. Drafters would then have to anticipate every form the collateral might take and every asset that might someday support it.
Two limits apply to every carry-over. First, each depends on an attached interest in the original collateral. Nothing passes unless value has been given and the debtor has rights in that collateral, so if either condition fails, no interest exists to carry anything along.5 Second, these rules speak only to attachment. Whether the interest in the related asset is perfected, or beats a rival claimant, belongs to later parts of the course. The common error is to ask whether the agreement describes the related asset and to conclude that it is uncovered. For these assets the better question is whether the interest in the main collateral has attached.
Proceeds
The first carry-over, in § 9-203(f), gives the secured party rights to proceeds the moment its interest in the original collateral attaches.6 A lender whose signed agreement describes only the debtor’s equipment therefore needs no further drafting to reach what the debtor gets by selling that equipment. The interest attaches to any identifiable proceeds, whether or not the agreement uses the word proceeds.7
The rule exists because a secured party bargains for the value of the collateral, and a sale converts that value into something the description does not name, usually cash or a right to payment. If the interest stopped at the words of the agreement, every sale would release the lender’s security at the moment the collateral became money. The Code instead presumes that the parties intend the interest to follow the collateral into its proceeds, even where their agreement is silent.8 That presumption was first codified in 1972. The current provisions reach items that decisions under the former Code had excluded, among them insurance payable on injury to or destruction of collateral and distributions such as cash and stock dividends.9
Section 9-102(a)(64) defines proceeds in five categories, each describing a different way value can leave collateral.10
- Whatever is acquired upon the sale, lease, license, exchange, or other disposition of the collateral.11
- Whatever is collected on, or distributed on account of, the collateral.12
- Rights arising out of the collateral.13
- To the extent of the collateral’s value, claims arising out of its loss, nonconformity, or interference with its use, defects or infringement of rights in it, or damage to it.14
- To the extent of the collateral’s value and to the extent payable to the debtor or the secured party, insurance payable by reason of the loss or nonconformity of, defects or infringement of rights in, or damage to, the collateral.15
The first category captures what the debtor receives by transferring the collateral. The second captures what the collateral yields while the debtor keeps it, such as collections on a right to payment and stock dividends. The third reaches rights arising out of the collateral. The fourth and fifth cover collateral that is damaged or destroyed, where a claim against a wrongdoer or a payment from an insurer stands in the place of the lost asset. Both carry an express limit tied to the collateral’s value. The limit follows from the idea that proceeds replace the collateral, since the interest in a replacement stops where the value the secured party bargained for stops.
Falling within a category does not finish the inquiry, because the interest attaches only to identifiable proceeds.16 In the simple case, identification is easy. A lender holds an attached interest in all of a debtor’s equipment, and the debtor sells a machine for money. The lender has an attached interest in that money as long as it remains identifiable as the price of that sale, though the agreement uses neither “proceeds” nor “money.”17 The same is true when the buyer of a secured automobile gives the debtor a note and a security interest. Both are directly traceable to that car.18
The difficulty begins when proceeds are mixed with other money. If funds that are proceeds are commingled with funds that are not, the lowest balance in the total fund between the time of commingling and the time of tracing is presumed to be identifiable proceeds. This is the lowest intermediate balance rule.19 Suppose a debtor deposits $100 of sale proceeds into an account holding $500, withdraws $550, and then deposits $200 from other sources, ending at $250. The balance fell to $50 at its lowest point, so $50 is identifiable proceeds.20 At that point the account held only $50, so no more than $50 of the $100 could still have been in it. The later $200 has no link to the sale, because money from another source does not replenish proceeds already spent. The rule credits the secured party with the part of the proceeds that demonstrably survived.
Not everything that comes out of collateral qualifies, because the definition turns on a disposition, a collection or distribution, or a loss. A calf born to a pledged cow involves none of these, and offspring are generally not treated as proceeds. A lender who wants offspring covered should name them in the grant. A second boundary arises when the parties agree to shift the lender’s interest from one machine to another machine the debtor owns. The second machine is collateral because of that agreement, and it is not proceeds of the first. Exchange and disposition contemplate a transfer by the debtor to a third party, not the movement of a security interest from one of the debtor’s assets to another.21
Supporting Obligations
The second half of § 9-203(f) gives a right to payment the same protection proceeds receive. Attachment of a security interest in collateral is also attachment of a security interest in a supporting obligation for that collateral.23 The agreement need not mention supporting obligations, because this is another exception to the rule that the description must identify what it covers.24
A supporting obligation is a letter-of-credit right or a secondary obligation that supports the payment or performance of an account, chattel paper, a document, a general intangible, an instrument, or investment property.25 A letter-of-credit right is the debtor’s right to be paid under a bank’s letter of credit when the debtor is its beneficiary. A secondary obligation is a promise by someone other than the main obligor to answer if the main obligor fails to perform, and a guaranty is the familiar example. The definition lists the kinds of collateral that can be supported, so a support is identified by what it backs.
The rule makes sense once you ask what the support is worth and to whom. The letter of credit or guaranty has no value to the debtor apart from its function of making payment on the main right more certain. A lender who takes an interest in an account expects to be paid from it, and the second source of recovery is part of that expectation. If the interest reached the account and left the support with the debtor, the lender would hold the weaker half of the asset it bargained for. The carry-over keeps the right and its support together, and it spares the drafter from listing every guaranty or letter of credit that might later back a described account.
The carry-over passes only through supported collateral in which the lender’s interest has attached. Suppose Delta’s parent company had guaranteed the account, and a different lender’s agreement with Marlow described only Marlow’s equipment. That lender has no interest in the account, so the guaranty backs nothing the lender holds, and nothing passes. A lender whose agreement describes accounts and who has given value holds the account and, with it, the guaranty, though the word guaranty never appears.
Liens Securing Payment
The third carry-over, in § 9-203(g), follows a right to payment to the lien that secures it. Attachment of a security interest in a right to payment or performance that is secured by a security interest or other lien on personal or real property is also attachment of a security interest in that security interest, mortgage, or other lien.27 A lender who holds an attached interest in a promissory note secured by a mortgage therefore holds an interest in the mortgage too. The security agreement need not describe the mortgage or any other lien.28
The reason lies in the lien’s role. A mortgage has no function apart from the debt it secures, because it exists to be enforced against the property if the debt goes unpaid. A lender who takes an interest in a mortgage-backed note is counting on payment of the note and, if the obligor defaults, on the property behind it. If the interest stopped at the note, the lender would hold the paper debt while the lien that gives the debt its strength stayed with the debtor. The drafter would also have to guess which of the debtor’s present and future notes will carry liens and name each one. A description of the right to payment is enough.29
The two suppliers differ in one fact, which is whether the lender’s interest reaches the right to payment. The rule is derivative, so the lien passes only through an attached interest in the secured right. If value was never given, or the debtor had no rights in the note, no interest in the note exists to carry the mortgage along.30
Securities and Commodity Accounts
Two one-sentence rules complete the group, and they work alike. Attachment of a security interest in a securities account is also attachment of a security interest in the security entitlements carried in that account, and attachment in a commodity account is also attachment in the commodity contracts carried in it.32 A record that describes the account therefore carries its contents with it, and the description need not name them.33
Both rules involve a container and its contents, which Article 9 treats as separate collateral. Investment property includes a security, a security entitlement, a securities account, a commodity contract, and a commodity account.34 A security entitlement is what a customer holds, through a broker, in a particular financial asset, and the securities account carries those entitlements. A commodity account is an account a commodity intermediary maintains to carry a commodity contract for a commodity customer.35 A commodity contract is a commodity futures contract, an option on a futures contract, a commodity option, or another contract that meets the further tests in the definition.36 The two rules are one idea applied twice, since in each case an interest in the container reaches the contents.
The reason lies in what an account is. An account is valuable to a lender only for what it carries, so a rule that stopped the interest at the edge of the container would give the lender a shell. The contents also change from day to day, because a debtor who trades in the account sells some holdings and buys others. A list of entitlements drawn up on the day of signing would describe a portfolio that no longer exists a month later. By attaching the interest to whatever the account carries, the statute lets the description stay at the level of the account, which is the level at which the parties think about the deal.
The carry-over starts at the account. If value has not been given, or the debtor has no rights in the account, no interest attaches to the account, and nothing passes down to the contents.37 The rule extends an interest that already exists and never supplies a missing condition. The signed record must also carry an adequate description of the account itself.38 That is where consumers need care. As the earlier discussion of descriptions needing more detail explained, in a consumer transaction a description of a securities account or a commodity account by type alone is not enough, so the agreement must add something, such as the firm that holds the account. A grant of “A’s securities accounts” made to secure a household loan leaves no attached interest in the account and nothing for the carry-over to extend. An individual who borrows to fund a business is not in a consumer transaction, so a description by type is enough there.
The merchant’s two accounts show that the carry-over runs in one direction only. It reaches downward from the account the agreement describes to the contracts that account carries.39 It does not reach sideways to a different account the description leaves out, so the description still marks the outer edge of the interest.
Steps two and three decide whether the interest attaches to the account at all. Step four requires no search of the agreement for the words entitlement or commodity contract, because the statute makes that inquiry unnecessary.40