Concept
The Floating Lien Rule
After-acquired property
After-Acquired Property Clauses
The Floating Lien Rule
Section 9-204(a) answers a lender's first practical question: can one agreement reach what the debtor does not yet own? It can. "Except as otherwise provided in subsection (b), a security agreement may create or provide for a security interest in after-acquired collateral."1 After-acquired property is property the debtor acquires after the security transaction, and it becomes additional security for payment of the debt.2 The opening qualifier makes the permission general but not unlimited: the rule does not extend to commercial tort claims or, with limitations, to consumer goods, and later sections take up those limits.3
The lender gets this result through language in the security agreement. The agreement provides that the transaction is secured by certain collateral regardless of when the debtor acquires it. Such a provision is usually called an "after-acquired property" clause, because it lets the security interest extend to property the debtor acquires after the loan is made.4 One form of the clause says the secured party's interest "extends to all collateral of the kind which is the subject of this agreement which the debtor may acquire at any time during the continuation of this agreement in connection with the operation of the business of the debtor."5
The clause adds a time dimension to the collateral description and adds nothing along the dimension of type. The words "of the kind which is the subject of this agreement" in the clause quoted above say so directly. A standard illustration makes the line visible. A retailer's security agreement covers "all present and future radios as inventory." The retailer, who has been handling the X make of radio, takes on the Y make, and no new filing is necessary. If the retailer decides instead to handle refrigerators under financing by the same secured party, the old agreement does not reach them. A new security agreement is necessary, and the financing statement should be amended to refer to refrigerators as inventory.7
Any after-acquired clause therefore calls for two questions, asked in order. First, is the item of a kind the description names? If it is not, the clause never comes into play. Second, did the debtor acquire the item after the agreement was signed? If so, and the item falls within the description, the clause carries the lender's interest to it. Treating "hereafter acquired" as a grant of everything the debtor later buys skips the first question and misstates the rule.
Section 9-204 adopts the principle of a "continuing general lien," or "floating lien," even though the debtor "has liberty to use or dispose of collateral without being required to account for proceeds or substitute new collateral."8 That freedom explains why the clause matters. A lien tied to the particular items the debtor owned at signing would shrink as the debtor sold them, and the debtor owes the lender no substitute collateral. The clause lets the lien follow the replacements instead, so the lender's security does not depend on the original items staying put. The lender also keeps its place in line: priority in after-acquired collateral relates back to the time of priority as to the original collateral, whether that was set by filing or another method of perfection.9 Perfection and priority effects are developed later in this chapter.