Concept
Dragnet Clauses
Future advances
Dragnet Clauses
A dragnet clause secures everything the debtor owes. Instead of describing one particular later loan, it says the collateral stands behind every obligation the debtor owes the secured party, whether the obligation exists today or arises tomorrow.
Mortgage law shows how much room such a clause has to work with, because it places few limits on what a mortgage may secure. The secured debt can be absolute or contingent, liquidated or unliquidated, and it can be an antecedent debt or a future advance. Devlin v. Wiener, 232 Conn. 550, 555 (1995).1 A mortgage can even secure an obligation that is not a debt at all. One New York case on that point, Jeffrey Towers, Inc. v. Straus, 31 A.D.2d 319 (N.Y. App. Div. 1969), arose when a purchase money mortgagee sold a mortgagor several acres from a larger tract the mortgagee owned.2
A hypothetical shows how that breadth plays out. A debtor owes a lender $2,000 on an unsecured note. A month later the debtor borrows $5,000 from a mortgagee and mortgages land to secure "all obligations now or hereafter owed." Months after that, the debtor guarantees a friend's loan from the same mortgagee. Does the mortgage stand behind the $2,000 note? Behind the guaranty? The nature of those debts does not keep them out. The first is antecedent and the second contingent, and a mortgage can secure either kind.3 The question that remains is what the clause's words reach, a question of construction. No one had either debt in mind when the $5,000 loan was made.
The answer matters to every party with a stake in the collateral. The lender gains a single pool of collateral behind its whole relationship with the debtor. The debtor may find that collateral tied up until every obligation is paid, including obligations that did not exist when the agreement was signed. Later creditors who read the agreement before lending cannot tell from one loan's balance how much of the collateral's value is already spoken for.
The earlier discussion of dragnet clauses and relatedness bears directly on this construction question, and the cross-collateralization section that follows shows what happens when the pooled collateral meets competing claimants. When you face a broad clause on a fact pattern, first ask what the debtor owes the secured party. Then ask whether the clause, read as written, covers each of those obligations.