Concept
The Benedict Rule Repealed
Use or disposition of collateral by debtor (§ 9-205)
Debtor's Use of Collateral
The Benedict Rule Repealed
Before the Code, a lender with a lien on a borrower's inventory or receivables had to worry about more than repayment. Under Benedict v. Ratner, 268 U.S. 353 (1925), and similar cases, an arrangement was void when the debtor had been given unfettered dominion or control over the collateral.1 Section 9-205(a) reverses that result. It opens a list of grounds on which a security interest is not invalid or fraudulent against creditors, and the grounds are freedoms the debtor keeps over the collateral.2 Comment 2 is blunter: the Code repeals the rule of Benedict and the cases like it.3
The old rule was sometimes thought to require a number of needless and costly formalities, and the example in Comment 2 shows what they looked like. The debtor had to remit to the lender every collection received, even though the lender immediately returned the money so that the loan stayed at an agreed level.4
The formalities also worked against the financing they were meant to protect. Recognizing a security interest in after-acquired property, and one that secures future advances, is what makes it practical to finance inventory and accounts, where the collateral turns over.5 The secured party can make present and future advances, often called revolving credits, secured by present and after-acquired inventory or accounts, and the result is what is often called a floating lien.6 Section 9-204 states the principle plainly. It adopts a "continuing general lien" even though the debtor "has liberty to use or dispose of collateral without being required to account for proceeds or substitute new collateral."7 A rule that voided a lien for that very liberty could not sit comfortably beside the financing Article 9 validates.
With the rule gone, the amount of policing or control the secured party exercises over the debtor's business and collateral is a matter of agreement.8 Except for procedure on default, freedom of contract prevails between the immediate parties to the security transaction.9 Comment 2 applies the point to accounts. The agreement may let the debtor collect its own accounts without notifying the account debtors that the accounts have been assigned. It may instead let the secured party notify the account debtors and collect from them directly.10
The debtor's other creditors are not left without rules. Section 9-201 supplies the starting point: the secured creditor wins unless the competitor finds a rule that says otherwise. Sections such as § 9-317 take up the secured creditor's competing claimants.11 Defined rules for defined contests thus replace the open-ended question of how much freedom the debtor enjoyed. The subsections that follow name the specific freedoms the Code protects, and none of them, standing alone, is a ground for attacking the lien.