Concept
No Duty to Account or Replace
Use or disposition of collateral by debtor (§ 9-205)
No Duty to Account or Replace
A creditor who attacks a lien cannot point to what the lender never demanded. Section 9-205(a)(2) provides that a security interest is not invalid or fraudulent against creditors solely because "the secured party fails to require the debtor to account for proceeds or replace collateral."1 The clause completes the lead-in to § 9-205(a): a security interest is not invalid or fraudulent against creditors solely because of any listed circumstance.2 The earlier items on the list protected what the debtor was free to do. This one protects what the lender chose not to require.
To account for proceeds is to report what the debtor received on selling or collecting collateral and to turn it over to the lender. To replace collateral is to put substitute assets under the lien in place of what the debtor sold or collected. A lender may demand both, one, or neither, and under § 9-205(a)(2) a lender that demands neither keeps its lien.
Before the Code, a lender's silence on these points counted against it. Courts read the failure to demand reports, remittances, or substitutions as evidence that the debtor, not the lender, controlled the collateral, and they treated a lien in that condition as void against the debtor's other creditors. That was the Benedict rule, and Article 9 repealed it. Article 9 is a comprehensive scheme for security interests in personal property that supersedes the earlier legislation on chattel mortgages, conditional sales, and similar devices,3 and within that scheme the lender's lack of supervision is not a defect in the lien.
Each half of the clause protects a different feature of revolving financing. The accounting half protects the borrower's cash flow. A dealer repays a stock loan out of what it earns by selling the stock, and a rule that kept the lien safe only when every sale was reported and every dollar turned over would force the lender to supervise the sales floor. The replacement half protects the turnover of the collateral itself. If the lien survived only when the lender had designated a substitute for each item sold, a lender financing fast-moving goods would have to approve a new item for every sale.
The Code supplies the replacement automatically instead. A security agreement may create or provide for a security interest in after-acquired collateral, and priority in the new collateral relates back to the time of priority in the original collateral, which is the date of filing or other perfection. That is the "continuing general lien" or "floating lien," and the Code adopts it even though the debtor "has liberty to use or dispose of collateral without being required to account for proceeds or substitute new collateral."4 The after-acquired rule has limits, however. It does not extend to commercial tort claims and reaches consumer goods only with limitations, so automatic replacement is not available for every kind of collateral.
Other creditors start from a weak position. Under § 9-201, a secured creditor, even an unperfected one, has greater rights in its collateral than any other creditor unless the Code provides otherwise, and a creditor without a security interest or lien has no claim on any specific collateral.5 An unsecured creditor's route to the collateral is its own diligence, such as a judgment or execution lien under state law, and not a complaint about how closely the lender watched the debtor.6 How closely the lender watches is a matter of agreement between the lender and the borrower,7 and § 9-205(a)(2) keeps that choice from becoming a weapon for outsiders.
An agreement that does impose a duty changes who holds the grievance, not whether the lien is valid.
The security agreement is where accounting and replacement duties belong, and the Code leaves their content to the parties. An agreement may require the debtor to turn over proceeds from the sale of collateral periodically,8 and the amount of policing or control the lender exercises over the debtor's business and collateral is likewise a matter of agreement. Financing secured by accounts shows the same latitude: the agreement may let the debtor collect its own accounts without notifying account debtors of the assignment, or may let the lender notify them and collect directly.9 A lender that stays silent on both accounting and replacement therefore keeps its lien against attacking creditors.
On an exam, read who is complaining and about what. If the stem says only that the lender never asked for reports, remittances, or substitute collateral, and a creditor attacks the lien on that ground alone, the attack fails. If the stem adds that the agreement did require those things and the debtor ignored them, the debtor has breached its agreement with the lender, and the other creditors still gain nothing against the lien.