Concept
Identifying the Control Route
Duty to release deposit-account control after the obligation ends (§ 9-208(b))
Identifying the Control Route
A secured party can obtain control of a deposit account in more than one way, and § 9-208(b) assigns a different release duty to each. Before asking what the secured party must do, ask how it got control.
The first paragraph of § 9-208(b) governs a secured party with control under § 9-104(a)(2). It requires that party to send the bank a signed record releasing the bank from any further obligation to comply with the secured party's instructions.1 This is the control-agreement route. The debtor, the secured party, and the depositary bank authenticate a record in which the bank agrees to follow the secured party's directions about the funds without any further consent from the debtor.2 The secured party's power rests on the bank's agreement, so the release the statute demands goes to the bank.
The second paragraph governs a secured party with control under § 9-104(a)(3) and prescribes different duties, which the following sections develop.3 This is the customer route: the secured party becomes a customer of the bank on the deposit account.4 Often the account is made a joint one, so that both the debtor and the secured party can withdraw. On default, the secured party simply takes the money out and applies it to the debt.5 Here the secured party's access comes from its own position on the account.
The split makes sense once you ask what stands between the debtor and its money. Under a control agreement, the bank's commitment to obey the secured party is the obstacle, so the cure is a release sent to the bank. A secured party that is itself a customer already holds a place on the account, and a message to the bank would not change who can reach the funds. The cure there is to move the money out of the secured party's reach, either by paying the debtor or by placing the balance in an account in the debtor's name.6 Each duty fits its route, and either duty applied to the other route would leave the debtor still blocked from its own funds.
Two facts change the answer, so a fact pattern must supply them. Take Harbor Finance, which lent to Delia's Dairy and has control of the dairy's deposit account at Northgate Bank. Delia has repaid in full, Harbor has no remaining commitment to lend, and Delia has sent a signed demand for release. That is not enough to answer, because the word control covers both routes.
Suppose first that Delia, Harbor, and Northgate signed a single record in which Northgate agrees to follow Harbor's instructions without further consent from Delia. Harbor's control rests on § 9-104(a)(2), and § 9-208(b)(1) requires Harbor to send Northgate a signed record releasing the bank from any further obligation to comply with Harbor's instructions.7
Now change one fact. Harbor instead became a customer on the account, as in a joint account from which Delia and Harbor can both withdraw, so its control rests on that status rather than on a control agreement. A release addressed to Northgate no longer fits. Section 9-208(b)(2) governs, and Harbor must do one of two things: pay Delia the balance on deposit, or transfer that balance into a deposit account in Delia's name.8
Two boundaries keep the sorting honest. First, the two paragraphs of § 9-208(b) discussed here name only the control-agreement and customer routes. A secured party that is itself the depositary bank has control under § 9-104(a)(1), a third route these paragraphs do not mention, so do not stretch either duty to cover it.9 Second, the collateral here is a deposit account, which is Article 9's name for a bank account. It is a different asset from an account, meaning money owed to the debtor by a third party, and the two are perfected and foreclosed upon differently.10 The notice a secured party must send to an account debtor belongs to a separate provision, § 9-209, and should not be imported into the deposit-account analysis.11