Concept
Why Debtors Can Demand Information
Request for accounting (§ 9-210)
Debtor's Request for Accounting
Why Debtors Can Demand Information
A creditor who searches the public record and finds a filed financing statement learns very little. The notice indicates merely that a person may have a security interest in the collateral indicated, and only further inquiry of the parties will disclose the complete state of affairs.1 Often the secured party answers that inquiry informally. When it does not, Section 9-210 of the Uniform Commercial Code provides a statutory procedure under which the secured party, at the debtor's request, may be required to make disclosure.2
Later creditors and purchasers may legitimately need more detail than a bare notice supplies, so Article 9 provides a procedure that requires the secured party to disclose it.3 Under § 9-210, a debtor can obtain a statement of the amount due on the obligation and a statement of the collateral. The debtor submits an authenticated record asking for a list of the collateral, a statement of account, or an accounting, and the secured party has 14 days after receipt to respond.4
The statute gives the right to demand disclosure only to the debtor. A secured party should not have to disclose details to a casual inquirer or to a competitor who asks for them, and the debtor is the person with a use for the answer. A debtor typically requests a statement in connection with negotiations with later creditors and purchasers, or to establish its credit standing and prove which of its assets are free of the security interest.5
Article 9 treats the debtor as the party whose choices count at other points as well. When a secured party proposes to accept collateral in satisfaction of the debt, for example, the debtor consents by agreeing to the terms in a record authenticated after default or, except in a partial satisfaction, by failing to object within 20 days of the proposal.6
The prospective lender is not shut out of the information; it gets the information through Acme, the debtor, who typically makes the request for exactly that purpose. What the limit prevents is a secured party's being made to answer to anyone who asks.
The word debtor in § 9-210 reaches beyond the borrower. A third person who puts up its own property as security for someone else's debt falls within the Article 9 definition of debtor, even though that person is not personally liable on the obligation.7 Such a person has a debtor's rights, including the right to receive statements of account of the indebtedness and of the collateral and to recover losses when the secured party fails to furnish them. These rights arise only when the secured party knows that the collateral belongs to the third person.8
Knowledge is the trigger because a secured party has no duty of inquiry into who really owns the collateral. Short of knowing that the collateral belongs to a third person, it may deal exclusively with the debtor who owes the obligation.9
The sections that follow take the procedure in order: the three kinds of request; the 14-day duty to respond, which does not bind a buyer of accounts, chattel paper, payment intangibles, or promissory notes, or a consignor;10 the position of a former secured party; charges for responses; and enforcement. The stakes of ignoring a request are real. A secured party that fails to comply is liable to the debtor for $500 and for any damages the failure causes (§ 9-625(f)). To the extent a party is misled by its failure to answer a request for a list of collateral, it may claim an interest only as shown on the debtor's list.11