Concept
Three Types of Requests
Request for accounting (§ 9-210)
Three Types of Requests
The secured party’s duty to respond attaches to a request and to nothing looser.1 A request, in turn, is a record of one of three types.2 A debtor who telephones the secured party, or who sends an informal note that fits none of the three descriptions, has not triggered the statute, however clearly the debtor’s wishes came across. The three types are a request for an accounting, a request regarding a list of collateral, and a request regarding a statement of account.3
All three rest on the same frame: each is a record, signed by a debtor, that reasonably identifies the transaction or relationship it concerns.4 The word record excludes the spoken request and leaves the secured party with something it can date, file, and answer. The signature ties the request to a debtor, the only person the definitions entitle to make it. The identification requirement matters because one debtor may owe the same lender on several loans, and a secured party cannot answer a question until it knows which obligation is meant. Readers of older materials will meet the word “authenticated” where the current text says “signed”; the 2022 amendments made that substitution in § 9-620, for example.5
The three types differ in who writes the first draft. In a request for an accounting, the debtor asks the recipient to supply the information. In the other two, the debtor drafts it, either a list of what it believes is the collateral or a statement of what it believes is the aggregate unpaid amount, and asks the secured party to approve or correct the draft.6
| Request | What the debtor puts on paper | What the secured party sends back |
|---|---|---|
| Accounting | A request for an accounting of the unpaid obligations; no figures, no list | An accounting |
| List of collateral | The debtor’s own list of what it believes is the collateral | An approval or a correction |
| Statement of account | The debtor’s belief about the aggregate unpaid amount as of a specified date | An approval or a correction |
The response follows the same split. A secured party answers a request for an accounting by signing and sending an accounting,7 and answers either of the other two by signing and sending an approval or a correction.8 The first job builds an answer from the secured party’s own side of the transaction, while the other two review a draft the debtor has already put on paper. The 14-day deadline and its exceptions belong to the next section; this one takes the three definitions in turn.
Request for an Accounting
A request for an accounting is a record signed by a debtor that asks the recipient to provide an accounting of the unpaid obligations secured by collateral and reasonably identifies the transaction or relationship that is the subject of the request.9 That sentence makes four demands, and a communication that misses any one of them is not a request, whatever the debtor meant by it, because the response duty attaches only to a request as the statute defines it.10
The first two steps give the secured party a clear trigger and give both sides a paper trail. A record can be stamped on receipt, and the 14-day response period runs from receipt, so a written request lets either side prove when the clock started; a telephone conversation cannot.11 The signature requirement confines the right to a debtor, so a competitor’s signed letter fails at step two even though it satisfies every other step.12
Step three defines what the debtor asks for, and the notable point is what the debtor need not supply. The definition requires a request that the recipient provide an accounting of the unpaid obligations secured by collateral; it says nothing about the debtor stating an amount, a date, or a list of assets.13 The request is therefore open to a debtor who has lost its statements or never kept them, and the secured party answers it by signing and sending an accounting.14 The two requests described next work the other way: the debtor drafts, and the secured party signs and sends an approval or a correction.15
Step four exists because a debtor may deal with the same lender through more than one loan, more than one security agreement, or both. A secured party that receives a bare demand for “an accounting” cannot tell which obligation is meant, and a duty with a 14-day deadline cannot fairly run against a recipient that has to guess. The statute’s word is reasonably, which sets a standard of sufficiency. The debtor need not recite every term of the deal, but the record must let the recipient tell which transaction or relationship is in question, and a loan date, a loan number, or a description of the financed equipment would ordinarily do that work.
Students meet this definition most often through a sincere but defective communication, where the debtor plainly wants the information and still has not triggered the statute.
The identification step produces a second kind of failure, in which the paper is in order and the target is unclear.
Request Regarding List of Collateral
A request regarding a list of collateral is a record signed by a debtor that asks the recipient to approve or correct a list of what the debtor believes to be the collateral securing an obligation, and that reasonably identifies the transaction or relationship that is the subject of the request.17 The record, the debtor’s signature, and the identification of the transaction repeat the frame already seen in the request for an accounting. The list is what sets this type apart. The debtor writes down the collateral it thinks secures the obligation and asks the recipient to approve or correct that writing, so information travels in the opposite direction from an accounting request: the debtor states what it believes, and the secured party confirms the statement or fixes it.
Placing the first draft with the debtor suits the two parties’ positions. The debtor owns the assets and ordinarily knows which of them it pledged, so drafting a list is a modest task, while the secured party’s job shrinks to comparing that list with its own records and signing an approval or a correction.18
The statute’s word is believes, and the word has a practical consequence. The debtor must list what it believes to be the collateral, but nothing in the definition requires the list to be accurate. The point of asking for a correction is to find out where the debtor’s understanding is wrong, so a rule that demanded accuracy before the debtor could ask would defeat the request’s own function. A list that omits one asset, or includes an asset the secured party does not claim, is still a proper list for purposes of the definition, and the response does the correcting. What the debtor cannot do is leave the list out, because without a list there is nothing for the recipient to approve or correct.
Once a proper request arrives, the duty to answer follows § 9-210(b). A secured party, other than a buyer of accounts, chattel paper, payment intangibles, or promissory notes or a consignor, must comply within 14 days after receipt.19 For a request regarding a list of collateral, compliance means signing and sending the debtor an approval or a correction.20 Approval tells the debtor that the list is right as written, and correction hands back the list as the secured party says it should read. Either way the answer is a signed record. The later sections on enforcement and noncompliance cover what follows when a secured party does not respond.
The usual exam question is whether a debtor’s letter that plainly seeks collateral information is a request regarding a list of collateral at all, and the answer depends on whether the debtor put a list on paper.
The third request type applies the same approve-or-correct design to the amount of the unpaid obligations rather than to the assets. A quick way to sort a debtor’s letter is therefore to ask what the debtor put on paper for the secured party to review: a list of assets, a figure for the debt, or nothing at all.
Request Regarding Statement of Account
A request regarding a statement of account is a record signed by a debtor that asks the recipient to approve or correct a statement indicating what the debtor believes to be the aggregate amount of unpaid obligations secured by collateral as of a specified date, and that reasonably identifies the transaction or relationship that is the subject of the request.22 Most of that structure is familiar. The request is a signed record from a debtor, it ties itself to an identifiable transaction, and it asks the secured party to approve or correct a draft the debtor wrote, the same design used for the list of collateral.23 What changes is the content of the draft. The list request puts assets in front of the secured party, and this request puts a dollar figure in front of it, so the secured party’s review consists of comparing the debtor’s number with its own records.
Two features of the statutory language shape that figure. The first is the specified date. A secured obligation does not stand still, because interest accrues and payments reduce the balance, so a bare number has no fixed meaning until it is tied to a day. A secured party cannot approve or correct “about $40,000” without knowing which day the debtor has in mind, whereas $40,000 as of June 30 is a proposition it can check against its books and either confirm or answer with a different number for the same day. The second feature is the aggregate: the debtor states a single total for the unpaid obligations secured by the collateral. The word believes does the same work here that it does in the list request. The debtor need not be right, because the correction exists to reveal where the debtor’s number is wrong.
The two debtor-drafted requests and the accounting request therefore differ in who first puts the amount on paper. In a request for an accounting, the secured party does, and the debtor supplies no figures.24 In a request regarding a statement of account, the debtor proposes the aggregate amount and the date, and the secured party confirms or corrects them. A debtor with its own payment records can use the second route, and a debtor without usable records has the first.
A proper request starts the same response period that governs the other types. A secured party, other than a buyer of accounts, chattel paper, payment intangibles, or promissory notes or a consignor, must comply within 14 days after receipt.25 For a request regarding a statement of account, compliance means signing and sending the debtor an approval or a correction.26 If the secured party’s books show the amount the debtor stated for the stated date, it approves the statement. If they show a different amount, it signs and sends the amount it says is right. Whether the 14 days have begun depends on the five parts of the definition.
Steps three and four separate this request from its siblings, and they are where a sincere letter most often fails. A debtor who has attached a figure but no date, or a figure and a date but no request for approval or correction, has written a note about the debt and has not made a request regarding a statement of account.
The usual exam question is whether a letter that gives the lender a number is enough, and the answer depends on whether the number comes with a date and a request for the lender’s review.
The heading a debtor puts on the letter does not decide which type it is, because each definition looks to what the record asks the recipient to do. A letter that states the debtor’s belief about the unpaid amount as of a date and asks the lender to approve or correct that figure fits the statement-of-account definition, and the lender’s task is then to approve or correct it.27