Concept
Former Secured Parties
Request for accounting (§ 9-210)
Former Secured Parties
A debtor who wants information usually writes to the lender it dealt with, and that lender may no longer hold what the debtor is asking about. Lenders sell loans and transfer the liens that secure them, often without the debtor's knowledge, and the debtor goes on addressing its requests to the lender whose name is on the loan papers.
The baseline answers in § 9-210(b) assume a recipient that still holds something. A secured party answers a request for an accounting by signing and sending an accounting, and it answers a request regarding a list of collateral or a statement of account by signing and sending an approval or correction.1 First Bank can give neither answer honestly, because it no longer claims the presses or the debt.
The statute does not let First Bank stay silent. Subsection (b) imposes the baseline duty on a secured party other than a buyer of accounts, chattel paper, payment intangibles, or promissory notes or a consignor, and it makes that duty subject to subsections (c), (d), (e), and (f).2 Subsections (d) and (e) speak to the recipient that once held an interest and holds none now. Each gives it a short substitute for the baseline answer: a signed record that disclaims any interest and, if the recipient knows them, names and gives the mailing address of any assignee or successor. Subsection (d) handles the former claimant of collateral that receives a request regarding a list; subsection (e) handles the former claimant of the obligations that receives a request for an accounting or a request regarding a statement of account.
No Longer Claiming Collateral
Subsection (d) governs the recipient that has left the collateral behind. A person that receives a request regarding a list of collateral, claims no interest in the collateral when it receives the request, and claimed an interest in the collateral at an earlier time must send the debtor a signed record within 14 days after receipt.3 Section 9-210(b) is subject to subsection (d), so this person does not answer with the baseline approval or correction.4 It cannot approve a list of assets it does not claim, and it cannot correct the list without describing a position it no longer holds.
The former claimant can still tell the debtor that it is out and, if it knows, who is in. Subsection (d) requires exactly that, and the requirement turns what would otherwise be silence into a referral.
Each condition does separate work. The first confines subsection (d) to list requests, which concern the assets; requests for an accounting and for a statement of account concern the debt and fall under subsection (e). The second measures the recipient's position at the moment the request arrives, so a recipient that still claims the collateral that day falls outside subsection (d) and answers under the baseline rule of approval or correction.5 The third makes the recipient a former claimant. A person that never held an interest has no earlier claim to disclose and no successor to name, and subsection (d) asks nothing of it.
The signed record has two parts. The first is a disclaimer of any interest in the collateral.6 The second applies only if the recipient knows the facts: the record must give the name and mailing address of any assignee of or successor to the recipient's interest in the collateral.7 The mailing address matters because a name alone gives the debtor nowhere to send its request.
The words if known to the recipient limit the second part. The recipient reports what it knows and need not investigate. A lender that sold its loan through an intermediary may never have learned who the final buyer was, and a lender that released its lien after the loan was repaid has no assignee to name. In either case the signed disclaimer alone completes the response.
The third condition catches the debtor whose request lands on a stranger.
The difference turns on the earlier claim. A former claimant must answer because it holds the debtor's only lead, and a stranger holds none.
No Longer Claiming Obligations
Subsection (e) repeats the structure of subsection (d) and applies it to the debt. A person that receives a request for an accounting or a request regarding a statement of account, claims no interest in the obligations when it receives the request, and claimed an interest in the obligations at an earlier time must send the debtor a signed record within 14 days after receipt.9 Two things change from subsection (d): the requests that trigger the duty, and the thing disclaimed, which is now the obligations instead of the collateral.
The ordinary answers to those two requests assume the recipient is still owed the money. A request for an accounting draws a signed accounting, and a request regarding a statement of account draws a signed approval or correction.10 Subsection (e) displaces both answers for a former holder of the debt.11 A lender that sold the loan last spring cannot report what is owed on it or vouch for the debtor's figure, because the debt now runs to someone else.
The screen from subsection (d) carries over with the debt in place of the collateral. The request must be an accounting request or a statement-of-account request, the recipient must claim no interest in the obligations on the day the request arrives, and it must have claimed an interest in them earlier. The signed record again has two parts. The first disclaims any interest in the obligations.12 The second, which applies only if the recipient knows the facts, gives the name and mailing address of any assignee of or successor to the recipient's interest in the obligations.13
The type of request decides which disclaimer First Bank owes. Because First Bank sold both the loan and the lien, a list request draws a disclaimer of the collateral under subsection (d), while an accounting request or a statement-of-account request draws a disclaimer of the obligations under subsection (e). Had Acme sent a request regarding a statement of account and proposed a figure, First Bank would not have approved or corrected the figure. It would have sent the same signed disclaimer of the obligations, with Second Lender's details.
The limit if known to the recipient applies here as well. The recipient reports what it knows and need not investigate. A lender whose loan was repaid in full has no assignee to name, and a lender that sold through an intermediary may never have learned the final buyer. In either case the signed disclaimer alone completes the response.
The second condition is the one most often tested. A lender that still holds the loan claims an interest in the obligations when the request arrives, so a disclaimer would misstate its position.
A lender that sold only part of a loan and kept the rest still claims an interest in the obligations and stands in the same position. A recipient that never held an interest in the obligations is no former claimant, and subsection (e) imposes no disclaim-and-redirect duty on it. What follows when a recipient that owes a response stays silent belongs to the enforcement sections later in this chapter.
The Baseline Answer: Approving or Correcting
A secured party that still claims an interest answers a debtor-drafted request by approving or correcting the draft. Under § 9-210(b)(2), a secured party complies with a request regarding a list of collateral or a request regarding a statement of account by signing and sending the debtor an approval or correction.15 The statute offers two acts, and the secured party chooses between them by reading the debtor's draft against its own records. A draft that matches is approved. A draft that differs is corrected by stating what the list or the figure should say. Both acts end the same way, with a signed record sent to the debtor.
The accounting response shows why the statute takes this shape. On a request for an accounting, the secured party signs and sends an accounting that it must prepare itself.16 On the other two requests the debtor submits a list of collateral or a statement of the aggregate amount of unpaid secured obligations, and the secured party responds to a version that already exists.17 The response costs the secured party little: a correct draft costs a signature, and an incorrect one costs a correction.
A secured party that disagrees with the debtor's list or figure replaces it with its own, and the debtor learns exactly where the two versions differ. An error in the debtor's draft does not excuse the secured party from answering, because correction exists to repair such errors. A reply that neither approves nor corrects leaves the debtor with no answer at all.
The first three steps come from the words of paragraph (b)(2). The fourth comes from the opening of subsection (b), which sets the period at 14 days after receipt and makes the duty subject to subsections (c) through (f).18 Approval or correction is therefore the baseline for a secured party that still claims an interest, and the later subsections qualify it for particular recipients. The signature requirement does the most practical work, since a telephone call produces no signed record.
A secured party most often loses this issue by treating the request as a courtesy and answering informally or not at all.
A telephone call fares no better than silence. If the lender's loan officer phones the debtor's treasurer and says the figure looks about right, no signed record has gone to the debtor, and the duty remains unmet however promptly the officer spoke.
The consequences for a secured party that stays silent are the subject of the later sections on noncompliance. For now, the sorting rule is that the type of request fixes the type of answer: an accounting request calls for an accounting, and the two debtor-drafted requests call for approval or correction.