Concept
Buyers of Tangible Collateral
Priority over unperfected security interests (§ 9-317)
Buyers of Tangible Collateral
A debtor's sale does not end the secured party's claim. Article 9 provides that a security interest “continues in collateral notwithstanding sale,” so a buyer ordinarily takes the goods subject to the interest and may lose them to the secured party if the seller defaults on the secured debt.1 Section 9-317(b) is the first exception this chapter takes up.
Under that subsection, a buyer, other than a secured party, of goods, instruments, tangible documents, or a security certificate takes free of a security interest if the buyer gives value and receives delivery of the collateral without knowledge of the security interest and before it is perfected.2 The drafters chose “takes free” over “is subordinate to,” and every buyer who meets the qualifications takes free, not only a buyer in ordinary course of business.3 The qualifying buyer keeps the goods, and the secured party must look to the debtor for payment.
The rule has four elements, each taken up in its own part below: the transferee must be a buyer and not a secured party, must give value, must receive delivery, and must lack knowledge of the security interest. The contest then reduces to two dates, the date the buyer has met every requirement and the date the secured party perfected.4 The second date is the date of perfection, which is not necessarily the date of filing, because perfection may occur first in another way.5
That comparison differs from the one that governs lien creditors. Against a lien creditor, the first-in-time rule of § 9-317(a) sets the time of perfection against the time the lien attached,6 and a signed security agreement plus a filed financing statement can serve in place of perfection.7 The buyer rule has no such substitute. It asks only whether the security interest was perfected before the buyer finished its purchase.8
Only collateral that can be physically delivered falls within the rule.9 Buyers of collateral that cannot be handed over are governed by rules taken up later in this chapter.
Two other rules reach the same buyers. Subsection (b) opens by yielding to subsection (e), which lets a purchase-money secured party that files within a grace period defeat a buyer who would otherwise win.10 And a buyer in ordinary course of business of goods (other than farm products) from a seller that created the security interest takes free of a perfected interest, even if the buyer knows it exists, and takes free of an unperfected one as well.11 A buyer outside that protection depends on subsection (b), which defeats a security interest only if the interest is still unperfected when the buyer completes the purchase.12
Buyer Who Gives Value
Two requirements sort transferees before any question of dates arises: the transferee must be a buyer and not a secured party, and the buyer must give value.13
Value is the easier of the two to satisfy. Section 1-204 sets only minimal requirements, and a buyer who merely promises to do something in return for the goods has given value, so the buyer need not have paid when the goods arrive.14 Value is broad enough to include any consideration, even a pre-existing debt. A creditor who accepts goods from the debtor in payment of an old obligation has therefore given value.15
A welding rig shows how the pre-existing-debt point plays out. S took a security interest in a debtor's rig on September 1 and did not perfect until October 20. On October 5 the debtor delivered the rig to B, a supplier, in satisfaction of an $8,000 debt the debtor owed B, and B knew nothing of S's interest. B gave value by cancelling the debt, took delivery without knowledge, and did so before S perfected. B takes free, and S cannot recover the rig from B when the debtor defaults.16
A transferee who gives nothing fares differently. Had the debtor given the rig to a nephew on October 5, S would prevail against the nephew. Article 9 has no provision protecting donees, so the security interest follows the rig, and the secured party wins even if it had not perfected.17 Timing and knowledge are the same in the two transfers. Only what the transferee gave differs, and that difference decides the contest.
The status requirement keeps lenders out of the rule. When the debtor transfers collateral to another secured party, the rights of the competing security interests are generally governed by the priority rules treated earlier in this chapter,18 and § 9-317(a)(1) itself subordinates a security interest to a person entitled to priority under § 9-322.19 The buyer rule is reserved for transferees who acquire the collateral outright.20
When a problem presents a transferee, ask two questions first: did the transferee take the collateral as a buyer or as a lender, and what did it give for it? A transferee that passes both must still satisfy delivery, knowledge, and timing.
Delivery of the Collateral
A buyer who gives value without knowledge can still lose by taking delivery too late. For tangible collateral, the buyer must “receive delivery” in addition to giving value and lacking knowledge.22 A contract is not delivery, even one the buyer has fully paid for, and until delivery occurs the buyer stays exposed to a secured party who perfects in the meantime.
The Code does not define delivery for goods. The definition in § 1-201, a voluntary transfer of possession, applies to instruments and several other intangibles but not to goods. Applying it by analogy might lead one to conclude that a buyer who never got possession would lose to a prior unperfected secured party.23 The tractor example below treats receipt of possession as the decisive event.24
The tractor shows the rule working against a buyer who did nearly everything right. On February 1, Jones borrowed from Second State Bank and signed a security agreement covering a tractor. On February 2, Jones sold the tractor to Brown, who paid the full price and knew nothing of the bank's interest. The bank filed a financing statement on February 3, and Brown took possession on February 4. When Jones defaulted on February 5, the bank took the tractor, because Brown's possession came after the bank had filed. Move one date and the result reverses: had Brown received possession before the bank filed, Brown could keep the tractor.25 Payment on February 2 did not stop the bank from perfecting on February 3, because Brown had not yet taken the tractor.
The tractor and the forklift divide the work between value and delivery. A promise satisfies value, so payment is unnecessary for a buyer who has taken delivery.26 Payment does nothing to supply delivery, so a buyer who paid in full but has not taken the goods stays exposed. For each buyer, list four dates: sale, payment, delivery, and the secured party's perfection. Compare only the delivery date with the perfection date, and remember that perfection may precede, and need not coincide with, the date of filing.27 The common error is to compare the contract or payment date instead.
One exception overrides all of this. Subsection (b) yields to subsection (e): if a purchase-money secured party files a financing statement before or within 20 days after the debtor receives delivery of the collateral, its security interest takes priority over the rights of a buyer that arise between attachment and filing, subject in turn to §§ 9-320 and 9-321.28 A later part of this chapter treats that grace period. Outside it, the buyer's delivery must come first.
Without Knowledge
The last requirement looks to the buyer's state of mind. A buyer takes free only if it gives value and receives delivery “without knowledge of the security interest.”30 The Code defines knowledge as actual knowledge,31 so the buyer loses only if it was in fact aware of the interest. Notice does not count.32
The standard tolerates considerable doubt. A transaction can look a little suspicious and still leave the buyer “without knowledge.”33 Suspicion, or a failure to look into the debtor's affairs, does not by itself amount to awareness of a particular security interest in particular collateral.
Knowledge can arrive by any route, including a conversation, a letter, or an earlier negotiation, but it must actually arrive.
The rule asks what the buyer knew when it had both given value and received delivery.34 A buyer who first learns of the interest after delivery keeps the goods, provided the interest was still unperfected when delivery occurred. A buyer who learns of it before delivery, even after paying in full, has not received delivery without knowledge and takes subject to the interest. Late discovery therefore costs a qualified buyer nothing, and early discovery is not cured by payment already made.
Knowledge also matters only while the security interest is unperfected. If the secured party perfects before the buyer takes delivery, the buyer loses on timing, whatever it knew.35
Do not carry this standard into § 9-320. A buyer in ordinary course of business may know that a security interest exists and still take free. It loses only if it knows that the sale violates the secured party's rights, for example because the security agreement forbids the sale.36 Under § 9-317(b), by contrast, actual knowledge of the interest itself defeats the buyer.