Concept
Related Buyer Protections
Priority over unperfected security interests (§ 9-317)
Related Buyer Protections
Section 9-317(b) frees a buyer of goods, instruments, tangible documents, or a security certificate from a security interest, but only if the buyer is not a secured party, gives value, and takes delivery of the collateral without knowledge of the interest and before it is perfected.1 Value includes a preexisting debt, and knowledge means actual knowledge, not simply notice.2 The rule rewards reliance on a record that shows nothing. A buyer who pays on the strength of a clean record has been misled by it; a buyer who knew of the interest, or who finished the purchase after the secured party perfected, has no such complaint. Subsection (b) therefore cannot reach an interest that was already perfected when the buyer took delivery, and it gives way to the purchase-money grace period of subsection (e).
A sale without the secured party’s consent does not, by itself, end the secured party’s interest. The interest continues in the collateral in the buyer’s hands unless some provision of Article 9 frees the buyer, and the interest that continues is the one the security agreement describes.3 That interest can exceed the original loan. A bank that secured a $10,000 loan with Beth’s cattle, under a clause allowing future advances, held an interest in the cattle totaling $15,000 once it advanced $5,000 more.4 Section 9-317(b) is one freeing provision, and it reaches only unperfected interests. Two others free the buyer even from a perfected interest: § 9-320(a), for the buyer in ordinary course of business, and § 9-320(b), for the consumer who buys consumer goods from another consumer.5
Each of those two protections answers a problem that subsection (b) leaves alone. The first is timing. A buyer who completes the purchase after the secured party has perfected loses under subsection (b) however innocent it is, and a seller whose stock a lender has financed is usually selling goods already subject to a perfected interest. The second is invisibility. A purchase-money interest in consumer goods is perfected without any filing, so a buyer who searches the records before paying finds nothing and still meets a perfected interest.6 The record search that justifies subsection (b) cannot protect the buyer in either setting, so the Code protects the buyer directly.
The buyer in ordinary course comes first, because that protection reaches furthest: it frees the buyer even from a perfected interest that the buyer knows about. The consumer-to-consumer buyer follows, and that protection depends on whether the secured party filed.
Buyers in Ordinary Course
A buyer in ordinary course of business escapes both limits that confine a buyer under § 9-317(b). Subsection (b) offers no protection against an interest perfected before delivery, and none to a buyer who knows of the interest.7 Section 9-320(a) removes both limits. A buyer in ordinary course of business, other than a person buying farm products from a person engaged in farming operations, “takes free of a security interest created by the buyer’s seller, even if the security interest is perfected and the buyer knows of its existence.”8 The definition ties the buyer to the seller’s business: the buyer must buy from a person in the business of selling goods of that kind, so the rule applies primarily to a buyer of inventory, much as a shopper buys from a showroom floor.9 The two rules therefore ask different questions. Subsection (b) asks when the buyer acted and what the buyer knew; § 9-320(a) asks who created the interest and whether this sale violated it.
The broader protection follows from what an inventory lender wants. A lender with a security interest in inventory normally intends the debtor to be able to sell that inventory free and clear, and a lender that could repossess goods from the debtor’s customers would defeat the purpose of the arrangement.10 Subsection (b) could not serve those customers, because a lender that has filed against a retailer’s stock is usually perfected long before any given sale. Section 9-320(a) works whether the lender is perfected or not, since the buyer in ordinary course takes free of an unperfected interest as well.11
Knowledge works differently under the two rules, and the difference is a frequent exam trap. Under subsection (b), a buyer who actually knows of the security interest loses. The buyer in ordinary course loses only if it knows that the sale is in violation of the security interest.12 Comment 3 to § 9-320 states the result: the buyer takes free if it merely knows that a security interest covers the goods, and takes subject if it knows in addition that the sale violates a term in an agreement with the secured party.13 The distinction tracks the lender’s expectations. Because an inventory lender expects sales, learning that an interest exists tells a buyer nothing about whether this sale is wrongful, while learning that the security agreement forbids the sale supplies the one fact that does. In one illustration, a retailer gave its manufacturer a security interest in inventory under an agreement that barred sales to other retailers who might resell at a discount. Another retailer knew of that prohibition and bought anyway, and it took subject to the interest.14
The first two steps screen out transferees who look like buyers but fall outside the definition. A person who takes collateral in satisfaction of a debt is not a buyer in ordinary course, and neither is a person who takes a security interest or a buyer in a bulk transfer, as when one business is sold to another.19 A donee fares worse still. Article 9 has no provision protecting donees, so the secured party prevails against a donee even if it never perfected.20 The seller’s business is the second screen. A buyer of an automobile that a car repair garage used as equipment takes subject to the perfected interest the garage created, because the garage did not deal in automobiles, and a buyer from a car-rental company that periodically sold off its older cars stands in the same position.21
A creditor paid in goods shows how the two buyer rules can sort one transferee in opposite ways. Manufacturer transferred inventory to Retailer in satisfaction of a pre-existing obligation. Retailer was therefore not a buyer in ordinary course, and because Manufacturer’s secured party, SP-1, had not consented to the disposition, Retailer took the inventory subject to SP-1’s interest.22 Cancelling the old debt would count as value under subsection (b), so the transfer satisfies one element of that rule and still fails the ordinary-course definition.23
The fourth step costs students the most points, because the protection runs only against an interest created by the buyer’s own seller.24 Suppose Retailer sells one of the transferred items to a customer who qualifies as a buyer in ordinary course from Retailer.25 The customer’s seller is Retailer, but Manufacturer created SP-1’s interest, so § 9-320(a) does not free the customer, who takes subject to the interest. A court reached the same result on different facts. A dealer sold a used motor home to a good faith purchaser while it was still subject to a security interest granted by the previous owner, who had traded the motor home in to the dealer. The court read the ordinary-course rule to free a buyer only from interests granted by its own seller, here the dealer, and because the secured party had not entrusted the motor home to the dealer, § 2-403 gave the purchaser no help.26 The limit has a structural reason. A lender who finances one debtor accepts that debtor’s sales but has not agreed that a later owner may pass the goods along free of the lien, and a buyer who looks only at its own seller cannot detect an interest created further up the chain.
Farm products fall outside § 9-320(a) altogether. A buyer of crops therefore prevails under Article 9 only over unperfected interests, through § 9-317(b), and a perfected lender’s interest follows the crop into the buyer’s hands.27 A federal notification scheme can still free a buyer of farm products even from a perfected interest, unless the buyer and the secured party have complied with that scheme.28
A purchase-money lender cannot rescue itself by filing on time. Subsection (e) gives a lender that files within 20 days after the debtor receives delivery priority over a buyer whose rights arise before the filing, but it applies “except as otherwise provided in Sections 9-320 and 9-321,” so a timely filing gains the lender nothing against a buyer in ordinary course.29
Consumer-to-Consumer Buyers
Section 9-317(b) protects only a buyer who completes the purchase before the secured party perfects, and one common lender is perfected from the start. A seller of consumer goods who keeps a purchase-money security interest for the unpaid price is perfected without filing, and the Code treats that perfection as automatic when the interest is created.31 The main exception is a motor vehicle required to be registered, where the lender perfects only by filing or by complying with the state certificate of title law.32 A buyer who purchases a used freezer from the original consumer months later therefore meets an interest perfected long before, and subsection (b) cannot help that buyer.
Automatic perfection saves lenders money, but it shifts a cost to later buyers. If creditors had to file on every consumer credit sale, the filing offices would bulge, and each filing would add little, because creditors already know that sellers of consumer goods hold automatically perfected interests and are on guard when a consumer tries to borrow against such goods.33 The public record, however, shows nothing, so a neighbor who wants to buy a refrigerator from the original owner has no way to learn of the seller’s purchase-money interest.34 Section 9-320(b) supplies the antidote: a buyer of goods from a person who used or bought them primarily for personal, family, or household purposes takes free of a security interest, even if perfected, when the buyer meets the conditions below.35 Sparing the amateur buyer is fair, and the lender keeps control of the risk, because a lender that wants protection against such buyers can still file.36
The last condition does the balancing. Perfection is already in place, so the line between protected and unprotected buyers falls at the one public act the lender can still choose to take, the filing of a financing statement.37 The Code permits that filing for consumer goods on an optional basis.38 Because the test asks whether the purchase came before the filing, a lender that files after the buyer has bought is too late. For a motor vehicle, the equivalent public act is the lender’s lien on the certificate of title, and a buyer who buys after that lien appears does not take free.39
The refrigerator shows the rule at work. A store sells a refrigerator to a consumer on credit and keeps a purchase-money interest that is perfected without filing or any other public act.40 A neighbor who later buys the refrigerator from the original owner, for value, without knowledge, for household use, and before any filing, takes it free. If the store had filed before the neighbor bought, the neighbor would take it subject to the interest.41
The rule is narrow because the consumer requirement runs on both sides of the sale. It is aimed at sales “by amateurs to amateurs,” so a seller in the business of selling the goods, or a buyer who wants them for business use, falls outside it.42 A deep freeze that Jones traded to Frosty, another dealer in deep freezes, shows the buyer-side limit. Appliance held a security interest in the freezer and never filed, yet its interest was superior to Frosty’s rights, because Frosty did not buy for personal, family, or household purposes.43
This rule should be kept apart from the ordinary-course rule taught just before it. Section 9-320(a) frees a buyer who purchases from a seller in the business of selling goods of that kind, even when the buyer knows of the interest. Section 9-320(b) frees only an amateur buyer who lacks knowledge, buys from an amateur, and buys before filing. On an exam, an automatically perfected interest in a household item sold to a neighbor calls for the second rule, and the lender’s answer to it is to file.