Concept
Perfection Defined
Perfection: filing and other required steps
Perfection by Filing and Other Steps
Perfection Defined
A security interest in personal property passes through two stages under Article 9, attachment and perfection, and the second decides contests with other claimants. Attachment is in effect the creation of the interest: without it there is no security interest at all, and with it the secured party can enforce the interest and realize on the collateral, at least against the debtor.1 Perfection is the further status. Under Section 9-308, a security interest is perfected if it has attached and every applicable perfection requirement in Sections 9-310 through 9-316 has been satisfied, except as Sections 9-308 and 9-309 provide otherwise.2 If those requirements are met before attachment, the interest is perfected at the moment it attaches.3 Perfection is thus a term of art, and Sections 9-308 through 9-316 spell out how to achieve it in each type of transaction.4
The reason to care is priority. Whether a security interest is perfected, and when it became so, often decides how it ranks against another claim to the same collateral.5 A perfected secured creditor stands nearly as far above an unperfected one as the unperfected one stands above a general creditor, and perfection also wins priority over a later lien creditor.6 The most dangerous lien creditor is the bankruptcy trustee. Section 544(a) of the Bankruptcy Code lets the trustee invalidate an unrecorded transfer that a creditor who extended credit and obtained a lien on the petition date could avoid under nonbankruptcy law, whether or not any such creditor actually exists.7 A secured party who perfects before bankruptcy usually keeps the collateral to itself; one who has not perfected must share with the general creditors.8
The priority rules rest on notice. Perfection tells the world that a security interest may exist. It warns later creditors to stay away if they do not want a lower priority, and it tells future lenders and purchasers from the debtor what the collateral will be worth to them if they take an interest in it.9 The same purpose explains why a secured party that never perfects is not without rights against the debtor. Perfection is not usually critical to enforcing the interest against the debtor, who granted it and needs no notice of it.10
Agricultural liens follow a parallel formula. An agricultural lien is perfected if it has become effective and the applicable requirements of Section 9-310 have been satisfied, and it is perfected the moment it becomes effective if those requirements were met beforehand.11
The rest of this chapter follows the steps in order. It begins with filing a financing statement, the default method, and the alternatives of possession, control, and automatic perfection. It then turns to where to file, what a financing statement must say, compliance with other law, and temporary perfection. It finishes with perfection that follows collateral and proceeds, and with what it takes to stay perfected.