Concept
Filing as the Default
Perfection: filing and other required steps
Filing as the Default
Article 9 begins every perfection question with a filing. Under UCC § 9-310(a), a financing statement must be filed to perfect all security interests and agricultural liens, except as subsection (b) of that section and Section 9-312(b) provide otherwise.1 A financing statement is a record that names the debtor, names the secured party or its representative, and indicates the collateral, so that anyone considering a deal with the debtor can see that a lender may already hold an interest.2 Filing supplies only the public-step half of perfection. A security interest is perfected once it has attached and the applicable perfection requirement is met, and attachment itself requires the debtor's agreement to grant the interest, value from the creditor, and the debtor's rights in the collateral.3
Because the rule reaches every security interest that no exception removes, filing is the default: the method a lender uses whenever no other provision supplies a different answer. It takes that form because a filing leaves the collateral where it is. A manufacturer must keep running its machines and a dealer must keep selling its inventory, so a method that required the lender to hold the property would defeat the purpose of the loan.4 A filed record gives notice through the public file while the debtor goes on using the collateral.
A default governs only until something displaces it, and Article 9 displaces this one in three ways. Some interests need no filing because another provision already perfects them, as with an interest perfected under Section 9-309 when it attaches.5 For some collateral the Code takes filing out of play altogether: a security interest in a deposit account may be perfected only by control, so a financing statement does nothing for it.6 And for other collateral, such as chattel paper and instruments, Section 9-312(a) allows filing even though other methods are also open.7
This section therefore asks one question about each piece of collateral: is filing the right step? A yes answer opens two more, which the next two sections address: in which jurisdiction and office the financing statement belongs, and whether its contents are sufficient.8
Filing a Financing Statement
Section 9-310(a) turns the filing question into a hunt for exceptions. For any item of collateral, the first move is to ask whether subsection (b) or Section 9-312(b) removes the filing requirement. If neither does, a financing statement is required, and no other act by the lender, however diligent, takes its place.9 The default sorts collateral into three groups: collateral for which filing is the only method, collateral for which filing is one permitted method among several, and collateral for which filing cannot be used at all.
Subsection (b) of Section 9-310 reads best as a table of cross-references. Each entry names a situation in which filing is unnecessary because some other method or event does the perfecting: possession of the collateral by the secured party,10 control of intangible collateral,11 perfection on attachment under Section 9-309,12 compliance with a statute outside Article 9,13 and a short temporary-perfection period for some collateral.14 A purchase-money security interest in consumer goods shows the pattern, since the Code perfects it the moment it attaches.15 Read this way, the subsection ties together the five perfection methods this section covers. A student who asks whether the Code requires filing is really asking which method the collateral calls for, and must check the exceptions before reaching for a financing statement. One related rule completes the picture: a secured party that assigns a perfected security interest needs no new filing to continue the perfection.16
Agricultural liens belong to the first group, because none of the exceptions in Section 9-310(b) applies to them, and filing is therefore the only way to perfect one.17 The way the lien arises explains why. A statute outside Article 9 gives the lien to a supplier of goods or services to a farming operation, or to a landlord of farm land, and the lien's effectiveness cannot depend on the lienholder's possessing the farm products.18 The farmer keeps the crops and livestock, so possession is unavailable. Control is open only for the intangible categories listed in Section 9-314(a), and farm products are goods.19 That leaves the public record as the only place a later lender can learn that a feed dealer or a landlord may have a claim on the herd or the crop. A bank holding a consensual security interest in the same crops has more room, since goods may be perfected by taking possession, but a farmer needs the crops in the field and the barn, so filing is the practical method there too.20
Accounts and general intangibles also belong to the first group. They are purely intangible collateral, rights not evidenced by an indispensable writing, so there is nothing to possess, and apart from proceeds no other method applies to most of them.21
Collateral in the second group may be perfected by filing even though another method is also open. Section 9-312(a) lists chattel paper, controllable accounts, controllable electronic records, controllable payment intangibles, instruments, investment property, and negotiable documents.22 Each can also be perfected by possession or by control, so the provision confirms that a secured party who prefers the public record may use it. The choice matters, because the methods do not give equal protection.
That scene shows what filing leaves undone. Filing perfects the interest but leaves the paper with the debtor, and a holder in due course is not bound by the security interest; possession removes the instrument from the debtor's hands and so removes any chance of a holder in due course.23 Investment property follows a similar pattern: filing is permitted, but taking control gives the secured party a better priority position.24 Skipping a required filing therefore leaves the interest unperfected, while choosing filing over possession or control in the permissive group leaves it perfected but exposed to the very claimants the stronger method would have defeated.
The third group is where the instinct to file for everything fails. A security interest in a deposit account may be perfected only by control, so a financing statement does nothing for it.25
The same bar covers letter-of-credit rights and money. Letter-of-credit rights are perfected by control, tangible money by possession, and electronic money by control.26 A record indexed under the debtor's name would not show who can actually move the funds, and control and possession do. The bar governs these assets as original collateral, and the opening words of Section 9-312(b) mark the first exception: proceeds governed by Section 9-315(c) and (d).27 A deposit account that receives identifiable cash proceeds is treated under those provisions, a topic for a later section. A second exception comes from the supporting-obligation rule, under which perfection in collateral also perfects a security interest in a supporting obligation for it, so a letter-of-credit right backing a payment right perfected by filing rides along with that filing.28
Possession and Delivery
Under UCC § 9-313(a), a secured party may perfect a security interest in goods, instruments, negotiable tangible documents, or tangible money by taking possession of the collateral, and may perfect a security interest in certificated securities by taking delivery of them under Section 8-301.34 A document here means a document of title, such as a bill of lading or a warehouse receipt.35 A secured party that holds the collateral needs no financing statement, because possession is itself a perfection method and Section 9-310(b) lists collateral in the secured party's possession among the interests for which filing is unnecessary.36 For tangible money, possession is the only route.37 The rest of this subsection covers what can be possessed, when possession starts and stops counting, and whose possession counts when someone else holds the collateral.
Possession perfects because it gives notice by changing who holds the property. A lender thinking of dealing with a debtor can look at the collateral before lending, and should grow wary when the debtor does not have the thing the debtor claims to own.38 That reasoning explains why the hold must be real. A pledge needs more than an agreement to pledge; it needs delivery of possession to the secured party or, in some instances, to a third person acting for it, and there is no pledge where the debtor remains in possession, even if the debtor purports to act as the secured party's agent.39 The interest must also have attached, so a creditor who holds the debtor's property without an agreement that it secures the debt has no interest for the possession to perfect.40 Field warehousing shows the same concern at work. A lender running a field warehouse on the borrower's premises can guard against loose supervision by also filing a financing statement, so that it stays perfected even if the warehouse is not properly operated.41
Because possession takes the collateral out of the debtor's hands, it suits only collateral the debtor can do without. A debtor needs its equipment and inventory to stay in business, so possession plays a minor part next to filing in commercial lending.42 It survives for collateral the debtor does not use day to day, such as a negotiable instrument not yet due, chattel paper, or stock certificates.
The categories in Section 9-313(a) share one feature: each has a physical embodiment that works as the exclusive representation of the right. Accounts and general intangibles have none, so possession cannot perfect them. A creditor who collects ledger cards, journals, computer print-outs, and sales slips has gathered records of the receivables, not the receivables themselves, and perfects nothing by doing so.43
A negotiable promissory note payable to the debtor lies on the other side of the line. Under Article 9, only the holder of a note can enforce it, and to be a holder one must be in possession. A lender that holds the note therefore leaves no one else able to enforce it, and perfection begins the moment possession does.44
The timing rule follows from the notice theory. If perfection depends on the secured party's possession, perfection occurs not earlier than the time the secured party takes possession and continues only while the secured party retains possession.45 A filing keeps giving notice from the public file wherever the collateral goes, but possession gives notice only while the debtor is kept away from the collateral. Once the secured party hands the collateral back, the debtor again looks like an unencumbered owner, and the Code treats the interest accordingly.
The repair-shop ending reflects a Section 9-313 rule: a secured party that has possession does not relinquish it by delivering the collateral to a person other than the debtor, or an ordinary-course lessee from the debtor, if that person was instructed before delivery or is instructed contemporaneously with it.46 The test asks who receives the collateral and under whose direction. The debtor can never be that person. A third party who acts on the secured party's instructions leaves the debtor excluded, and the exclusion is what the rule protects. Certificated securities have a refinement of their own: a security interest in a certificated security in registered form is perfected by delivery and remains perfected by delivery until the debtor obtains possession of the security certificate.47 A separate temporary-perfection rule, covered in a later section, cushions the effect of releasing certain collateral to the debtor.
When someone other than the debtor, the secured party, or an ordinary-course lessee holds the collateral, a different rule applies. For collateral other than certificated securities and goods covered by a document, the secured party takes possession through that holder only when specified conditions are met.48 The central condition is that the holder authenticate a record acknowledging that it holds the collateral for the secured party's benefit.49 The signed record answers a real gap, because a custodian's physical hold does not show for whom the custodian holds. No holder can be made to supply the acknowledgment, since a person in possession of collateral is not required to acknowledge that it holds possession for a secured party's benefit.50
A lender facing a holder that refuses to sign has two alternatives. It may file a financing statement, which is permitted for instruments, or it may take the notes into its own hands.
Goods covered by a certificate of title form a final exception. With respect to goods covered by a certificate of title issued by the enacting state, a secured party may perfect by taking possession of the goods only in the circumstances described in Section 9-316(d).51 Otherwise the title statute governs, as the last subsection of this section explains.52
Control
Under UCC § 9-314(a), a security interest in controllable accounts, controllable electronic records, controllable payment intangibles, deposit accounts, electronic documents, electronic money, investment property, or letter-of-credit rights may be perfected by control of the collateral.57 The 1999 Code created control as a perfection method,58 and control stands to intangibles as possession stands to goods. A bank might possess a tractor and so perfect its interest in the tractor; the same bank might obtain control over a customer's account at a brokerage, by putting the bank's name on the account, for example, and so perfect its interest in the debtor's stocks and bonds.59 The statute leaves the definition of control to a separate section for each asset (Sections 7-106, 9-104, 9-105A, 9-106, 9-107, and 9-107A), so any control problem begins by classifying the collateral and then applying the test written for that asset. Control, like possession, perfects only an interest that has attached.60
Possession has nothing to grip when the collateral is an entry in a bank's records or a brokerage's ledger, so the Code asks for the nearest functional equivalent: a position from which the secured party can direct the asset. A financing statement cannot show that. It tells a searcher only that a lender may have an interest. For a deposit account, control commonly rests on an agreement with the depositary bank, or on the secured party's being the bank's customer on the account.61
Where both routes are open, control is usually the better choice. A financing statement is unnecessary where perfection is by control, so a lender with control needs no filing at all.62 A secured party with control of investment property or a deposit account also generally ranks ahead of one that has only filed, even when the controlling party obtained control later; it is often second in time but first in right.63
Perfection by control has a clock, and the clock mirrors the one for possession. A security interest in controllable accounts, controllable electronic records, controllable payment intangibles, deposit accounts, electronic documents, electronic money, or letter-of-credit rights is perfected by control when the secured party obtains control and remains perfected by control only while the secured party retains control.64 The violin returned to the debtor taught that lesson for goods, and the control rule applies it to intangibles.
Investment property runs on a longer clock. Perfection by control begins no earlier than the time the secured party obtains control, but it does not end the moment control does; it continues until further conditions the rule lists are met, which in general depend on whether the debtor has regained the certificate, the registration, or the entitlement.66
Chattel paper follows a combined rule. It arises when a dealer sells goods on credit and the buyer signs a security agreement reserving the dealer's security interest for the unpaid price; the signed agreement is the chattel paper, and the dealer may assign it to a bank by outright sale or to secure a loan.67 Under UCC § 9-314A(a), a secured party may perfect a security interest in chattel paper by taking possession of each authoritative tangible copy of the record evidencing it and obtaining control of each authoritative electronic copy.68 Perfection under that rule arises no earlier than the time the secured party has taken possession and obtained control, and it lasts only while the secured party retains both.69 The rule operates copy by copy, because a copy left with the debtor would leave the debtor holding the very record a competing lender would look for.
The possession half of the rule borrows machinery already covered. Section 9-314A applies Section 9-313(c) and (f) through (i) to a tangible copy, so the third-party acknowledgment rule and the instructed-delivery rule work for chattel paper as they do for goods.70 A financing statement is unnecessary for chattel paper perfected by possession and control, so a lender that completes both halves needs no filing.71 A lender holding the only paper copy while the debtor keeps the authoritative electronic copy has completed only one half and is unperfected under this rule, though it could still perfect by filing, which Section 9-312(a) permits for chattel paper.72
Control is sometimes one choice among several and sometimes the only choice, and Section 9-312(b) marks where it becomes the only one. A security interest in a deposit account may be perfected only by control, a security interest in a letter-of-credit right may be perfected only by control except where the supporting-obligation rule applies, and a security interest in electronic money may be perfected only by control.73 Each of those rules gives way to the proceeds provisions of Section 9-315(c) and (d).74 The earlier discussion of filing met the same limits from the other side. Control is the step that replaces filing for this collateral.
An exam fact pattern will often give a lender a financing statement describing all of the debtor's deposit accounts and then ask whether the lender is perfected in the debtor's checking account at another bank. The analysis asks whether the lender has control, through a control agreement with that bank or as the bank's customer on the account.75 If neither appears in the facts, the filing does nothing for the account as original collateral.76 The lender's remaining footing would be the proceeds provisions, which depend on tracing the deposit to collateral in which the lender was already perfected.77
Automatic Perfection
Section 9-309 lists the security interests that are perfected when they attach, and for each one the second stage of perfection drops out: the secured party needs no filing, no possession, and no control.84 This is the fourth perfection method, and it operates as an exception written into the general definition of perfection, which applies the attachment-plus-a-step formula except as Section 9-309 provides.85 Section 9-310(b) supplies the matching exception to the filing default, making a financing statement unnecessary for any interest perfected under Section 9-309 when it attaches.86 Only attachment matters for these interests, and attachment requires the debtor's agreement to grant the interest, value, and the debtor's rights in the collateral.87 The anchor of the list is a purchase-money security interest in consumer goods, subject to an exception in Section 9-311(b) for consumer goods covered by a title statute or treaty.88
Both qualifiers must be met, and each has its own test. A purchase-money security interest secures the price of the collateral: it belongs either to a seller who keeps an interest in the goods to secure the unpaid price or to a lender whose advance was in fact used to buy them.89 Consumer goods are goods bought or used primarily for personal, family, or household purposes, and the classification turns on the use the debtor makes of the goods. Potted trees in a nursery's hands are its inventory, and trees a retailer buys to resell to its customers are the retailer's inventory to the extent the retailer has rights in them.90 A single lawn mower is inventory on a hardware store's shelf, a consumer good once a homeowner buys it, and equipment once a landscape business buys it.91 A lender that finances a retailer's stock therefore cannot claim automatic perfection, because the stock is inventory in the retailer's hands.
The Code exempts this one category because the costs and benefits of a public record come out differently here. A filing for every installment sale of a washing machine or a couch would fill the filing offices with records of small transactions and impose fees out of proportion to the credit extended.92 The benefit of the record would also be slight, since consumer goods are usually inexpensive and lose value quickly, lenders other than the seller seldom rely on them, and anyone who lends against a consumer's belongings has long known to ask about an unpaid seller.93 The same reasoning marks the edge of the rule: once the collateral is business equipment, other lenders do rely on it, and the justification for skipping public notice is gone.
Exam fact patterns usually test that edge by describing a loan that looks purchase-money and asking whether the lender is perfected without a filing.
The scene shows that the rule has two halves and the lender must satisfy both. A purchase-money interest in equipment fails the consumer-goods half, and a non-purchase-money interest in consumer goods, such as a loan secured by a washer the borrower already owned, fails the purchase-money half.94 Two further limits apply even when both halves are met. Consumer goods covered by a certificate-of-title statute are excluded by the text of the rule itself, so a family car bought on installment is not perfected on attachment; the last subsection of this section explains what perfects it.95 And a consumer-goods fixture, such as a furnace installed in a home, is perfected on attachment, but a fixture filing is still needed to prevail over certain real estate interests.96
The rest of Section 9-309 matters mainly for recognition, since a student must know which interests perfect on attachment but need not recite every clause. The entries to know are these:
- An assignment of accounts or payment intangibles that does not, alone or with other assignments to the same assignee, transfer a significant part of the assignor's outstanding accounts or payment intangibles.97
- A sale of a payment intangible.98
- A sale of a promissory note.99
- A security interest arising under Article 2 or 2A in favor of a seller or lessor, which lasts only until the debtor obtains possession of the goods.100
- A security interest in investment property created by a broker or securities intermediary.101
Each entry has its own logic. A furniture seller that sells office furniture on a ninety-day payment plan and then assigns the buyer's three monthly payments to a finance company has made an assignment of accounts; whether that assignment perfects on attachment depends on whether it, alone or with others to the same assignee, transfers a significant part of the assignor's outstanding accounts.102 The rule rests on the idea that casual or isolated assignments, which no one would think of filing, should not fail for want of a filing, while anyone who regularly takes a debtor's accounts is expected to file.103 The word sale carries weight in the next two entries, because a loan secured by a note or a payment intangible earns no automatic perfection, and the usual marker of a sale is that the transferor bears no recourse if the obligor fails to pay.104 The line among intangibles is sharp. A bank that buys a loan participation is perfected on attachment, and so is a buyer of mortgage notes, but a buyer of a credit card company's accounts must file in the seller's name, and a buyer of car loans documented as chattel paper must file or take possession.105 A buyer of a promissory note who wants more than automatic perfection can also take possession of the note, which keeps anyone else from becoming a holder in due course.106 An Article 2 seller's interest is perfected without filing only until the debtor obtains possession, and after that the seller is an ordinary unperfected secured creditor unless it files.107
Automatic perfection spares the secured party any step, and the price is that outsiders receive no notice of the interest. The Code makes the secured party absorb part of that price, and the clearest case is the consumer who buys goods from another consumer. A buyer who gives value, has no knowledge of the security interest, and buys primarily for personal, family, or household purposes from a person who used or bought the goods for such purposes takes free of the security interest, even a perfected one, if the purchase comes before a financing statement is filed.108 The rule counterbalances the automatic-perfection rule, because a household buying a used refrigerator from a neighbor has no record to search and cannot learn of an unfiled seller's interest, so the Code lets the amateur buyer take free.
A seller that wants protection against the casual buyer can file anyway, since filing is permitted for these interests even though it is not required. Once a financing statement is on record, the casual buyer takes subject to the interest, which is why a lender on valuable consumer goods sometimes files despite automatic perfection.109 Automatic perfection covers a narrow band of transactions. In loans of any size the lender must still choose among filing, possession, and control.110
Compliance With Other Law
Section 9-311(a) removes another class of collateral from the filing default: except as subsection (d) provides, the filing of a financing statement is neither necessary nor effective to perfect a security interest in property subject to the statutes the subsection lists.115 The rule works in two directions at once. A lender whose collateral falls inside one of those statutes need not file, and a lender who files anyway gains no protection, because the Code has assigned the work of giving notice to a different public record.116 Compliance with that other regime is the fifth perfection method, and the lender's first task is to recognize when the collateral belongs to it. A family car bought on installment is excluded from automatic perfection when a title statute applies,117 and this subsection explains what perfects it instead.
Article 9 defers here because a financing statement exists to tell later lenders and buyers where to look, and a second record in the wrong office would only mislead them. When a federal registry or a state title office already records interests in a type of property and fixes who wins against a lien creditor, the Code treats that entry as the equivalent of filing, as subsection (b) states below. The deference reaches three situations, each with its own test:
- A federal statute, regulation, or treaty whose requirements for a security interest's obtaining priority over the rights of a lien creditor preempt Section 9-310(a).118
- A certificate-of-title statute, whether the state's own or that of another jurisdiction, under which a security interest is indicated on a certificate of title as a condition or result of obtaining priority over the rights of a lien creditor.119
- A non-UCC central filing statute of the state, which each enacting state lists for itself.120
The federal category is defined by function. A federal enactment qualifies only if its own requirements for priority over a lien creditor preempt the Article 9 filing rule, and the federal law dealing with aircraft is the standard example: a lender with a security interest in an aircraft complies with that system, and a financing statement adds nothing.121 Other federal recording schemes are less settled. In the leading decisions a UCC filing has been held enough against a lien creditor for patents and for federally registered trademarks, but ineffective for copyrights, so a lender taking intellectual property must check the rule for the particular asset.122 The preemption is also narrow. A federal statute that preempts all of Article 9 under Section 9-109(c)(1) removes Article 9 entirely, but a statute that preempts only the filing rule of Section 9-310(a) leaves the remaining Article 9 rules in place.123 Federal acts that cover filing typically leave open the creation of the interest, priorities, and foreclosure, and many courts fill those gaps by analogy to Article 9.124
Certificate-of-title statutes form the second situation, and the label has a precise meaning. A statute counts only if it provides for the security interest to be indicated on the certificate as a condition or result of obtaining priority over a lien creditor. A state statute that issues titles without tying perfection to the notation falls outside the category, and the lender must then use another method, usually filing. Automobiles and trucks are the core case, while coverage of snowmobiles, motorcycles, boats, construction equipment, and farm equipment varies from state to state, so the type of collateral alone does not settle whether a title statute applies.125 The deference makes sense because the title certificate is where a buyer or lender of a vehicle will look for encumbrances. Another jurisdiction's title statute gets the same deference, which matters because vehicles cross state lines.126
Subsection (b) states what compliance accomplishes. Compliance with the other law's requirements for priority over a lien creditor is equivalent to filing a financing statement, and a security interest in the covered property may be perfected only by that compliance, subject to subsection (d) and to Sections 9-313 and 9-316(d) and (e) for goods covered by a certificate of title.127 Three results follow. A lender who complies with the other law has no reason to file a financing statement. A lender who only files has not perfected, because the statute makes compliance the exclusive method. And possession perfects titled goods only in the limited circumstances Sections 9-313 and 9-316(d) and (e) describe. The same subsection keeps the interest perfected despite a later change in the collateral's use or in who holds it, since the entry that gives notice sits in the title or registry record and does not change when the car moves to a work site or is lent to a relative.128
A fact pattern that shows a lender's careful filing against a titled vehicle is therefore testing whether the lender noticed the title statute.
Subsection (c) divides the lender's position between the two regimes. Duration and renewal of perfection achieved by compliance are governed by the other law, and in all other respects the security interest remains subject to Article 9.129 The split follows from where the record lives. The notation or registration sits in another office under another statute's terms, so that statute decides how long the entry lasts and what must be done to keep it alive.
Subsection (d) sends one group of titled goods back to ordinary filing. During any period in which collateral subject to a subsection (a)(2) statute is inventory held for sale or lease by a person in the business of selling goods of that kind, Section 9-311 does not apply to a security interest in that collateral created by that person.130 A bank that finances a dealer's automobiles held for sale therefore cannot perfect by noting its lien on the certificates of title and files a financing statement covering the inventory instead.131 The carve-out lasts only while the cars are inventory; once a car is sold to a customer, it becomes the customer's titled automobile and the title rules govern again. The text sets two further limits: the carve-out reaches only security interests the dealer itself created, and it refers only to subsection (a)(2) statutes, so a federal registry under subsection (a)(1) is untouched by it.