Concept
Perfection That Follows Collateral
Perfection: filing and other required steps
Perfection That Follows Collateral
One perfecting step against the right asset can leave a lender perfected in a second asset it never targeted. Section 9-308(d) provides that perfection of a security interest in collateral also perfects a security interest in a supporting obligation for the collateral.1 Subsections (d) through (g) of Section 9-308 work the same way, and a financing statement is unnecessary for an interest perfected under any of them.2 The four rules cover the supporting obligation behind a payment right, the lien that secures a payment right, the security entitlements carried in a securities account, and the commodity contracts carried in a commodity account.
The ordinary rule is that each asset needs a step of its own. A security interest is perfected once it has attached and the applicable requirements of Sections 9-310 through 9-316 are met.3 A bank financing a dealer's automobile inventory, for example, cannot perfect by noting its interest on the certificates of title. It must use another permissible step, most likely a financing statement covering the inventory.4 The carry-over rules replace that step for the accessory. The lender already holds a completed step in the principal asset, and the Code lets that perfection reach the accessory. The rules supply no new step of their own. If the lender is not perfected in the principal asset, it has nothing to carry over, and the rule gives it nothing.
Supporting Obligations
A supporting obligation is a letter-of-credit right or a secondary obligation that supports the payment or performance of an account, chattel paper, a document, a general intangible, an instrument, or investment property.5 The most common supporting obligations are suretyship obligations, including guarantees, and letter-of-credit rights. If a debtor's parent corporation guarantees payment of the debtor's accounts receivable, the guaranty is a supporting obligation of those accounts.6
Both halves of the rule operate automatically. Under Section 9-203(f), a security interest in the supported collateral attaches to the supporting obligation. Under Section 9-308(d), perfection in the collateral perfects the interest in the supporting obligation. Section 9-310(b)(1) confirms that no separate filing is necessary, and Section 9-322(b) gives the lender essentially the same priority in the supporting obligation that it has in the original collateral.7 The attachment half is one of several places where Article 9 lets attachment to one type of collateral carry over to another specified type. It operates as an exception to the rule that a collateral description must reasonably identify what it describes, so the security agreement need not mention the guaranty or letter-of-credit right at all.8
The rule makes sense because a guaranty or letter-of-credit right has value only through the right it supports. A lender perfected in the account but still unperfected in the backstop would hold only half of what it bargained for. The Code avoids that result by treating the backstop as moving with the supported collateral.
The extension matters most beside the control-only rule for letter-of-credit rights. Except as Section 9-308(d) otherwise provides, a security interest in a letter-of-credit right may be perfected only by control under Section 9-314.9 Control is a perfection method the 1999 Code added, and it rests on the secured party acquiring control of the collateral.10 Two situations follow. When the letter-of-credit right is the lender's original collateral, only control perfects it, and a financing statement accomplishes nothing. When the right is a supporting obligation for a right to payment in which the lender is perfected, the exception applies and no control is needed.
An exam stem that pairs a filed financing statement with a letter-of-credit right invites the quick answer that only control will do. That answer is right only half the time, so the first question is whether the right is collateral in its own right or an accessory to a payment right in which the lender holds an interest.
The carry-over also needs a completed step to carry. Suppose a lender's interest has attached to a guaranteed account, but the lender has taken no perfecting step. It is unperfected in the account, and so it is unperfected in the guaranty that supports it. The analysis therefore asks two questions in order: what does this obligation back, and is the lender perfected in that thing?
Liens, Entitlements, and Contracts
Three more extensions follow the supporting-obligation pattern. Perfection of a security interest in a right to payment or performance also perfects a security interest in the security interest, mortgage, or other lien on personal or real property securing the right.13 Perfection in a securities account also perfects the security entitlements carried in it, and perfection in a commodity account also perfects the commodity contracts carried in it.14 In each, perfection in the principal asset does all the work, and no financing statement is needed for the accessory.15 Attachment follows the same path as the perfection, so the security agreement describing the note or the account reaches the lien, the entitlements, or the contracts without listing them.16
The lien rule matters when a lender's collateral is a right to payment that is itself secured by a lien, as when a bank takes a security interest in a promissory note secured by a mortgage on the maker's land. The bank perfects in the note by its own Article 9 step, and that perfection carries over to the mortgage. The bank records nothing in the real property records. The Official Comment adds two corollaries. An attempt to perfect an interest in the secured obligation by complying with non-Article 9 law, such as recording an assignment of the mortgage, would be ineffective, and the comment rejects the contrary decision in In re Maryville Savings & Loan Corp.17 It is also implicit that a lender cannot obtain a security interest in a lien, such as a real-property mortgage, unless the lien comes coupled with an equally effective security interest in the secured obligation.18 The lien follows the obligation. The rules draw an almost clean line between the real estate universe and the personal property side, and the mortgage is the one piece that crosses it, carried by the note.
The other two extensions run from a container to its contents. A securities account is the account at a brokerage or other intermediary in which a customer's holdings are carried, and each holding is a security entitlement. Perfection in the account carries over to the entitlements, and perfection in a commodity account carries over to the commodity contracts carried in that account.19 A lender that described the account and perfected in it would be unperfected in the very positions it meant to take if each position needed a step of its own.
All three extensions carry a perfection the lender already has, so each is only as good as the step beneath it. A lender whose interest in the note, the securities account, or the commodity account has attached but remains unperfected is unperfected in the accessory too. The extension also adds nothing outside the described collateral, as the unmortgaged parcel and the second brokerage account both show.