Concept
Defects and Filing Office Errors
Assignment of a security interest
Defects and Filing Office Errors
Most security interests in personal property can be perfected by filing, which is more convenient than possession, the other common method, so the way a filing office handles a record touches nearly every secured transaction.1 Assignments add two points of risk. The first is the content of the record. Subject to the mortgage rule at the end of this section, an initial financing statement may reflect an assignment of all of the secured party's power to authorize an amendment by giving the assignee's name and mailing address as the name and address of the secured party.2 The second is the office's handling of what it receives.
Article 9 lists the filing officer's duties. Each filing is to be marked with a file number and the date and hour of filing, made available for public inspection, and indexed in the name of the debtor.3 The four parts below follow those duties: numbering and timing, public inspection, indexing, and the changes that apply when a filing is tied to land. A slip at any step can leave a correct filing hard to find, and the next part of the chapter turns to refused records and indexing mistakes.
File Numbers and Timing
For each record it files, the office does two things: it assigns the record a unique number, and it creates a record bearing that number and the date and time of filing.4 Later records find their way back to the initial statement through that number. The office must be able to retrieve a record by the debtor's name and by the file number assigned to the initial financing statement to which the record relates,5 and uniqueness is what makes the arrangement work. If two filed records shared a number, an assignment amendment citing it would point to two files at once.
The date-and-time entry fixes the record's place in the history of its file. One file may hold an initial statement, an assignment amendment, and later records, and the stamp shows the order in which they arrived.
Section 9-519(b) adds a safeguard to the number itself. A file number must include a digit that is mathematically derived from or related to its other digits, and the digit aids the office in determining whether a number communicated as a file number includes a single-digit or transpositional error.6 A transposition swaps two digits, as when a filer writes 4817 for 4871. A slip of that kind seldom yields nonsense. It yields another number of the same length, and that number may belong to an unrelated file, so an assignment keyed to it could attach to the wrong record unnoticed. Because one digit depends on the others, a number with a wrong digit or a swapped pair will often fail the check, and the office can catch the error on arrival. The digit narrows the risk of a misdirected filing without eliminating it.
Timing comes from section 9-519(h). The office must perform the acts that subsections (a) through (e) require at the time and in the manner prescribed by filing-office rule, but not later than two business days after it receives the record.7 Those acts include numbering and stamping, but they also include maintaining the record for public inspection and indexing it, so the two-day limit governs the entire task of putting a record into the searchable file. A record that has arrived but has not been indexed is invisible to someone searching under the debtor's name, and the limit caps that gap. A filing-office rule may set a faster schedule; the statute sets the ceiling.
One office is exempt. Subsections (b) and (h), the check-digit and timing rules, do not apply to a filing office described in section 9-501(a)(1), the office where a mortgage on the related real property is recorded.8 A county recorder who receives an assignment of a mortgage that is effective as a fixture filing is therefore not on the two-day clock. The exemption lifts those two requirements and nothing else, so that office must still maintain and index what it receives.
Maintaining the Public Record
The office must maintain each filed record for public inspection.10 The duty follows from the way filing works. Filing is how most security interests in personal property are perfected,11 and a filing protects no one unless a searcher can read it. A searcher who finds a filing can then obtain further details of the transaction, with the debtor's cooperation, through the request procedure in section 9-210.12
Searches run through the office. On request and payment of the proper fee, the filing officer issues a certificate of the filings made against a particular debtor and furnishes copies of the filed financing statements and statements of assignment.13 An assignment filing is therefore part of what a searcher receives, and a searcher who finds the initial statement can read the assignment in the same file to learn who the secured party of record is now.
The duty attaches only to records that were actually filed. An assignment that exists solely between the parties never enters the file, so the office has nothing to hold open.
Financer loses nothing in perfection by leaving the assignment unfiled. An assignee of a perfected security interest stays perfected against the original debtor's creditors and transferees without a new filing.14 What Financer gives up is visibility, because the public record keeps naming Seller as the secured party of record. The inspection duty keeps a filing useful once it is made; it cannot supply a filing no one made.
Retention has a second rule, aimed at the index. The office may not remove a debtor's name from the index until one year after the effectiveness of a financing statement naming the debtor lapses under section 9-515 with respect to all secured parties of record.15 The index is how a searcher locates the file, so a name deleted on the day of lapse would put the file out of reach that day. Holding the name for a year means that a search run six months after lapse still turns up the statement. The rule bars early removal and does not itself require removal when the year ends; the rules on removing and destroying lapsed statements are separate provisions of the Article.16 Because the year runs from lapse as to all secured parties of record, a file that names more than one secured party starts the clock only when effectiveness has lapsed as to each of them.
Indexing Assignments
Indexing is the step that makes a filed record findable. The office must index each filed record under subsections (c), (d), and (e) of section 9-519,18 and the general rule in subsection (c)(1) reaches most assignments. It directs the office to index an initial financing statement according to the name of the debtor and to index every related filed record in a way that associates it with the initial statement.19 An assignment amendment relates to an initial statement, so the general rule requires no separate entry for it under the assignor's or the assignee's name. The amendment travels with the initial statement and appears wherever a search under the debtor's name leads.
The index is keyed to the debtor because that is how searchers use it. The filing officer composes the index from debtors' names, and later parties search under the debtor's name; if the debtor's name is wrong, the index is wrong and later parties are misled.20 A searcher usually does not know who holds the interest today and is trying to find out, so an index keyed to the assignee would help only a searcher who already knew the answer. Association supplies the other half of the design: it carries every later record into the same search, so the chain of assignments can be read in one place.
The same logic limits the harm when the secured party's name is wrong. As one opinion explains, searches are not conducted under the secured party's name, and no filing is needed to continue perfection after an assignment, so an error in the name of the secured party or its representative will not be seriously misleading; in an appropriate case, however, such an error may give rise to an estoppel in favor of a particular holder of a conflicting claim to the collateral.21
A second entry arises only when a record adds a debtor. Under subsection (c)(2), a record that provides a debtor name not previously given in the financing statement to which it relates is also indexed under that new name.22 The entry protects a searcher who runs the added debtor's name and would otherwise miss a filing that now reaches that debtor. An amendment adding Co-Debtor LLC is therefore indexed under Co-Debtor LLC as well as through the initial statement, while an amendment assigning the interest to Financer supplies no new debtor name and is reached only through the initial statement. The assignee's name appears in the content of the record, where a reader can see it, but it is not an index key.
Indexing describes how the office files records away; subsection (f) describes what the office must be able to do when someone asks. It must maintain a capability to retrieve a record by the name of the debtor and by the file number assigned to the initial financing statement to which the record relates, and to associate and retrieve with one another an initial financing statement and each filed record relating to it.23 One version of the subsection states the file-number retrieval separately for the office described in section 9-501(a)(2).24 Name plus file number matters because a debtor can have more than one initial statement on file, and the name alone returns all of them. The number confirms the particular record, such as an assignment amendment that cites the initial statement's number, and the association confirms that the set of related records is complete.
Subsections (d) and (e) change this pattern for filings tied to land, the subject of the next part. For ordinary personal-property filings, the initial statement is indexed by the debtor's name and the assignment follows it.
Real-Property Indexing
Subsection (e) moves one class of assignments out of the debtor-name index and into the pattern of the land records. It applies when a financing statement is filed as a fixture filing or covers as-extracted collateral or timber to be cut, and it tells the office how to index an assignment filed under section 9-514(a) and an amendment filed under section 9-514(b).26 Statements of this kind include those covering timber to be cut, minerals and the like (including oil and gas), and accounts resulting from the sale of minerals at the wellhead or minehead.27 Each is tied to particular land, and the Code has the office index these filings the way mortgages are indexed.
The rule for the underlying statement comes first, because the assignment rule builds on it. The office indexes the statement under the names of the debtor and of each owner of record shown on it, as if they were the mortgagors under a mortgage of the real property described.28 Treating the debtor and each record owner as mortgagors puts the filing under the names a land-records searcher would use for a mortgage. Where the state indexes mortgages under the mortgagee's name, the office also indexes the statement under the secured party's name as if the secured party were the mortgagee, and where indexing is by description it treats the statement as a record of a mortgage of the real property described.29 The official text also brackets a clause requiring that such a statement be filed for record, which marks that clause as optional for an enacting state.30
Subsection (e) then fits an assignment into that mortgage pattern with two entries. The first is mandatory: the office indexes the assignment or amendment under the name of the assignor as grantor.31 The second depends on local law: to the extent the state indexes a record of the assignment of a mortgage under the assignee's name, the office also indexes the assignment under the assignee's name.32 The grantor entry mirrors the assignor's position in an ordinary mortgage assignment, where the assignor is the party conveying its rights. The assignee entry is conditional because the rule follows each state's own mortgage-indexing practice and adds no separate UCC convention. The contrast with the central index is sharp. There, an assignment amendment gets no entry under the assignor's or assignee's name and travels with the initial statement; here, the assignor's name is itself an index key.
An ordinary financing statement on a manufacturer's inventory, filed in the central office, shows the other side of the line. It is indexed in the name of the debtor, and an assignment amendment filed against it follows the initial statement under that name, with no grantor or assignee entry required.33 The kind of collateral or filing triggers real-property indexing; the route by which the assignment is made under section 9-514 matters only once that trigger is met.
Not every assignment connected with a fixture filing follows subsection (e). When a mortgage is effective as a fixture filing under section 9-502(c), section 9-514(c) allows an assignment of record of the security interest in the fixture only by an assignment of the mortgage in the manner provided by state law outside the UCC.34 Subsection (e) reaches an assignment filed under section 9-514(a) and an amendment filed under section 9-514(b), and an assignment of the mortgage is neither.35 The real-property office handles that assignment under the state's ordinary real-property law. A financing statement filed as a freestanding fixture filing, with no mortgage doing the filing, is assigned by a UCC filing and indexed under subsection (e). Both routes touch the land records but run under different law and different indexing provisions, so the first fact to find in any fixture problem is which instrument serves as the fixture filing.