Concept
Who Qualifies as a Buyer
Buyer in ordinary course of business
Who Qualifies as a Buyer
A bank holds a perfected security interest in a boat dealer's showroom inventory. A customer who knows the bank has a lien on the dealer's stock buys a boat from the dealer in good faith. Section 9-320(a) says that a buyer in ordinary course of business "takes free of a security interest created by the buyer's seller, even if the security interest is perfected and the buyer knows of its existence."1 Whether the customer keeps the boat free of the lien therefore turns first on one question: is the customer a buyer in ordinary course of business?
Section 1-201(b)(9) answers that question, and its definition must be read together with § 9-320(a) to decide whether a particular buyer takes free of a perfected security interest.2 A buyer in ordinary course of business is a person who, in good faith and without knowledge that the sale violates a third party's ownership rights or security interest in the goods, buys from a person regularly engaged in the business of selling goods of that kind. The definition excludes pawnbrokers.3 The customer in our hypothetical fits: the dealer regularly sells boats, and the customer bought in good faith.
Two kinds of knowledge appear in this rule, and they point in opposite directions. Knowing that a security interest exists costs the buyer nothing. A buyer in ordinary course takes goods free of a perfected security interest even with that knowledge, and takes free of an unperfected one as well.4 Knowing that the sale itself violates the secured party's rights does cost the buyer, because the definition requires the buyer to lack that knowledge.5 The customer who knows of the bank's lien but has no reason to doubt the dealer's right to sell stands on the protected side of that line.
The definition and the text of § 9-320(a) together produce a checklist. A buyer must satisfy every item to take free:
- The buyer acts in good faith and without knowledge that the sale violates the secured party's rights in the goods.6
- The seller is regularly engaged in the business of selling goods of that kind.7
- The buyer gives new value, which means the buyer does not buy in bulk and does not take the goods as security for, or in total or partial satisfaction of, a pre-existing debt.8
- The competing security interest is one created by the buyer's seller.9
- The buyer is not a person buying farm products from a person engaged in farming operations.10
Each item screens out a different buyer. A boat dealer who sells its own delivery van fails the second item, because the dealer does not regularly sell vans. A supplier who accepts a boat from the dealer to wipe out an old bill gives no new value. A buyer who purchases a crop from a farmer falls within the farm-products carve-out, which § 9-320(a) states in its own terms. A buyer whose seller received the goods subject to a lien that an earlier owner created faces a security interest the buyer's seller did not create, and the rule does not reach it.
A buyer who misses any one item is not a buyer in ordinary course of business and cannot rely on § 9-320(a). The sections that follow take the elements in turn: first the requirement that the security interest be one created by the seller, with its subparts on the seller's business, good faith and knowledge, and the nature of the purchase, and then the farm-products exception.