Concept
The Farm Products Exception
Buyer in ordinary course of business
The Farm Products Exception
Section 9-320(a) shields a buyer in ordinary course from the security interest the buyer's seller created, but it carves out one sale: the buyer must not be "a person buying farm products from a person engaged in farming operations."1 A buyer inside that carve-out cannot invoke the provision, even if every other element of ordinary-course status is present.
Consider a farmer who gives a bank a perfected security interest in the season's crop and then sells the crop to a grain elevator. Under the majority rule that held until 1986, the elevator did not take free of the bank's interest unless the bank's past dealings with the farmer showed that it had authorized sales of the collateral. The farmer's sale therefore did not cut off the bank's right to follow the crop into the elevator's hands. If the farmer then failed to settle with the bank, the elevator sometimes had to pay twice.2
The rule rested on a judgment about the parties. Farmers typically market their products through agents or sell to financially sophisticated buyers, and it was thought reasonable to expect those buyers to check for filed financing statements. Farm lenders, for their part, were presumed to expect payment when the crop was marketed. Farm operations are cyclical and produce no regular cash flow, so a farm lender's expectations commonly center on a single sale of a collateralized crop.3
Federal law then reversed the default. Effective December 23, 1986, the Food Security Act of 1985 "federalized" the states' farm product rules and gave the states two options: adopt a prescribed central filing system or follow an "actual notice" rule.4 Under the resulting rule, a buyer in ordinary course of farm products takes the goods free of a security interest even if it is perfected and even if the buyer knows it exists, unless the buyer and the secured party have complied with a federal notification scheme. To take free, the buyer must satisfy four conditions:5
- The buyer buys the farm products in the ordinary course of business.
- The seller is a person engaged in farming operations.
- The seller sells the farm products in the ordinary course of the seller's business.
- The seller is the person who created the security interest.
This layering sets two traps. A reader who stops at the text of § 9-320(a) reaches the pre-1986 result, which federal law displaced. A reader who assumes the buyer's protection reaches every claim against farm goods overlooks the agricultural lien: Article 9 contains no rule under which a buyer in ordinary course takes free of a perfected or unperfected agricultural lien.6