Concept
Minerals at the Wellhead
Buyer in ordinary course of business
Minerals at the Wellhead
A buyer who purchases oil, gas, or other minerals at the wellhead or minehead, or after extraction, receives the protection a customer receives when buying from a merchant’s stock. If that buyer qualifies as a buyer in ordinary course of business, it takes free of “an interest arising out of an encumbrance.”1 The Code’s definition of the ordinary-course buyer reaches a buyer of minerals at the wellhead or minehead.2
Article 9 uses the same landmarks when it tells a lender where to perfect. The place to perfect a security interest in minerals that attaches upon extraction is the wellhead or minehead, and the same rule governs accounts resulting from the sale of those minerals there.3 One location therefore marks both where the lender perfects and where the buyer buys.
A mineral buyer must still qualify as a buyer in ordinary course, so two familiar limits apply. The seller must be in the business of selling goods of that kind. A buyer of goods that are not inventory is not ordinarily a buyer in ordinary course, and that principle has been applied to a buyer of an automobile that a car-repair garage, not an auto dealer, used as equipment.4 The buyer’s knowledge, in turn, disqualifies it in only one situation. A buyer who merely knows that a security interest covers the goods still takes free; a buyer who also knows that the sale violates a term of the agreement with the secured party does not.5
The refinery and the contractor differ on two facts, and each fact is a requirement. The goods must be oil, gas, or other minerals bought at the wellhead or minehead or after extraction, and the seller must be in the business of selling goods of that kind. The rig fails both. A buyer of goods that are not inventory is not ordinarily a buyer in ordinary course and takes subject to a perfected security interest created by its seller.6 A problem about an oil or mining company therefore calls for sorting the goods before sorting the buyers. Crude oil bought at the well falls within the mineral rule; drilling equipment falls under the general rule, where the seller-in-the-business element defeats the buyer.
The UCC Exception for Farm Products
The mineral rule widens ordinary-course protection; the Code’s rule for farm products narrows it. A buyer in ordinary course of goods other than farm products takes free of a perfected security interest created by its seller, even if the buyer knows the interest exists, and takes free of an unperfected interest as well.9 Section 9-320(a) withholds that protection from “a person buying farm products from a person engaged in farming operations.”10
Because the carve-out sits inside the provision that grants the protection, a farm-products buyer cannot invoke § 9-320(a) at all. The secured party may follow its interest into the hands of a buyer of crops, such as a grain elevator or food processor, or into the hands of a buyer of livestock.11 However well the buyer otherwise qualifies, the exclusion removes the protection from the transaction itself. Article 9 likewise contains no rule that frees an ordinary-course buyer from a perfected or unperfected agricultural lien.12
Classification decides which rule governs, because inventory is defined to exclude farm products. Farm products include livestock, born or unborn; aquatic goods produced in aquacultural operations; supplies used or produced in a farming operation; and products of crops or livestock in their unmanufactured states.13 Goods other than farm products that a person holds for sale or lease are inventory instead. The carve-out also looks to the seller, who must be a person engaged in farming operations.
The Code treated farm products differently because of the way many agricultural goods are marketed.14 A farm-product sale often moves a farm’s entire crop or all of its livestock to a single buyer on a single day, which invites comparison to a bulk sale.15 The cost of the rule fell on the buyer. When a farmer failed to settle with secured parties, a buyer of farm products sometimes had to pay twice unless it could show that the secured party had authorized the debtor to sell.16
The peanut case shows the exception at full strength. A farmer gave a United States government agency a security interest in a peanut crop, and the agency filed a financing statement. The farmer sold the crop to a company that buys and sells farm products. The company took the crop subject to the security interest and was liable to the United States for conversion when it resold the crop.17
The exception works chiefly against a perfected lender, because the Code already favors a buyer over an unperfected interest. A buyer wins against an unperfected interest if it gives value and takes delivery without knowledge of another party’s attempt to create the interest, and before the interest is perfected.18 The farm-products clause removes only the extra shield of § 9-320(a), the one that defeats a perfected interest. A buyer of crops therefore prevails only over unperfected security interests under § 9-317(b), and the exception usually applies only where the secured party has perfected.19
A buyer who loses § 9-320(a) may still win by showing that the lender authorized the sale. Parties often specify in the security agreement whether the debtor may sell the collateral without the secured party’s permission, and a buyer from an authorized debtor takes free. Without authorization the buyer takes subject to the lien, unless it can show that the creditor has a history of allowing secured goods to be sold without giving the debtor written authorization.20
The exception also stops at the point where the goods stop being farm products. It does not apply where the farmer processes the crop into something else and then sells the resulting product.21 In one cotton case, the cotton ceased to be farm products after ginning, and the buyer took free of the security interest.22 The definition points the same way, since it reaches products of crops and livestock only in their unmanufactured states.23
Critics attacked the farm-products exception, and Congress answered with preemptive legislation in the Food Security Act of 1985, 7 U.S.C. § 1631.24 The next part explains what that statute does to the Code’s rule.
Federal Override and Its Limits
The Food Security Act of 1985 reverses the Code’s result for most farm-product buyers. Congress enacted it in response to criticism of the farm products exception, and it provides that, regardless of § 9-320(a), farm-product buyers take free of security interests created by their seller.27 The statute’s own text says that, “notwithstanding any other provision of Federal, State or local law,” a buyer who in the ordinary course of business buys a farm product from a seller engaged in farming operations takes free of a security interest the seller created, even though the interest is perfected and the buyer knows of it.28 The statute took effect on December 23, 1986, and “federalized” the states’ farm product rules.29
Auctioneers, representatives of grain elevators, and other purchasers of farm products stimulated the change.30 The Code rule had left such buyers exposed to paying twice for the same crop.31
The statute protects a buyer only when four things are true. The buyer must buy in the ordinary course of business, the seller must be a person engaged in farming operations, the seller must sell in the ordinary course of its own business, and the seller must be the person who created the security interest.32 The last condition keeps the federal rule aligned with the Code, which protects a buyer only from an interest created by its own seller.33 The allocation tracks a general feature of Article 9: a secured party dealing with a later owner can investigate where the goods came from, while the earlier secured party has no reason to search filings against anyone but its own debtor.34
The federal act also defines “buyer in ordinary course” for itself, and that definition has no knowledge exclusion. Under the UCC, a buyer who has notice that the sale violates the ownership right or security interest is not a buyer in ordinary course. Under federal law, a notice telling the buyer that a particular farmer’s sale violates a security agreement does not by itself keep the buyer from qualifying.35
The override is strong but not absolute, because the statute shifts to the lender the burden of reaching the buyer. A state could meet the federal scheme in either of two ways: by adopting a prescribed central filing system or by following an “actual notice” rule.36 Where the state has not enacted a central filing system, the secured creditor can get protection against an ordinary-course buyer only by giving that buyer notice in the form the federal law specifies.37 Nineteen states had enacted a central filing system as of October 1, 2017, so in most states the direct notice is the lender’s only route.38
The notice is much harder to give than a UCC-1. It requires the debtor’s social security or taxpayer identification number and identifies the farm products by type, county, crop year, and amount, so a creditor can easily fail to give proper notice. The lender also needs the buyers’ names. The farm debtor typically supplies them or the lender procures them itself, and the list would include large-scale bulk purchasers in the debtor’s county and adjoining counties. A farmer who sells outside the normal trade area can defeat the system, particularly in states that bar the bank from sending notice to anyone not on the farmer’s list.39
Where the state does have a central filing system, the buyer takes subject to the lender’s interest if the Secretary of State notifies it of an effective financing statement or of the security interest in the farm products, and the buyer has not obtained a waiver or release from the secured party. That is the central filing exception.40
For crops, the two rules combine into a single result. Article 9 does not give the usual protection to a buyer of crops, who prevails only over unperfected security interests. Under the federal act, however, an ordinary-course buyer of crops takes free of security interests unless there is compliance with the act’s notice or filing requirements.41
A buyer who relies on the knowledge point above should also recall the Code’s own statement of that limit: a buyer fails to qualify under § 9-320(a) only if it knows that the sale is “in violation” of the security interest.43