Concept
Contrast With Consumer Buyers
Buyer in ordinary course of business
Contrast With Consumer Buyers
Section 9-320 gives two kinds of buyer a way to take goods free of a perfected security interest, and the rules protect different buyers for different reasons. Under subsection (a), a buyer in ordinary course of business takes free of a security interest created by the buyer’s seller “even if the security interest is perfected and the buyer knows of its existence.”1 Under subsection (b), a buyer of goods from a person who used or bought them primarily for personal, family, or household purposes takes free of a security interest, even if perfected, but only if the buyer buys without knowledge of the interest, for value, for personal, family, or household use of the buyer’s own, and before a financing statement is filed.2 A transferee who qualifies under neither rule is sorted by status: purchaser for value without knowledge under § 9-317(b), buyer in ordinary course under § 9-320(a), or casual buyer under § 9-320(b).3 The two buyer rules differ in four respects: who the seller is, what the buyer wants the goods for, what the buyer may know, and what the lender’s filing does.
The seller comes first. A buyer in ordinary course must buy from a person in the business of selling goods of that kind, so subsection (a) applies primarily to buyers of inventory.4 A lender with a security interest in inventory normally intends the debtor to sell the inventory free and clear, and subsection (a) honors that expectation.5 Subsection (b) covers a different kind of sale. In Professor Gilmore’s words, it is intended for sales “by amateurs to amateurs”: the seller must have used the goods primarily for personal, family, or household purposes, and the buyer must buy them for the same kind of use. If the seller is in the business of selling the goods, or if the buyer is purchasing for a business, subsection (b) does not apply.6 The buyer’s purpose therefore decides cases under subsection (b), while the text of subsection (a) asks only whether the buyer is a buyer in ordinary course taking from the seller who created the interest.7
The lender’s filing matters under subsection (b) and nowhere under subsection (a), and automatic perfection explains why. A purchase-money security interest in consumer goods is perfected when it attaches, with no filing and no other public act.8 A person who wants to buy the goods from the original owner therefore has no way to learn of the interest.9 Subsection (b) is the antidote, which is why it is sometimes called the “garage sale” exception. The amateur buyer takes free, and the protection ends once the lender files a financing statement. For a motor vehicle, the counterpart of filing is the lender’s perfecting its lien on the certificate of title.10
A freezer shows the rule at work. Jones buys a deep freezer for home use from Appliance Company on credit, and Appliance takes a purchase-money security interest but never files. Six months later Jones sells the freezer to Smith, a next-door neighbor who pays value, knows nothing of the lien, and wants the freezer for home use. Smith takes free. Had Appliance filed, Smith would have taken subject to its interest.11 Subsection (a) has no filing condition at all. A buyer in ordinary course of goods other than farm products takes free of a perfected security interest, and also of an unperfected one, so the filing that would defeat the neighbor does nothing against a shopper at the dealer’s counter.12
The same freezer shows the buyer’s purpose cutting the other way. Suppose Jones trades the freezer to Frosty, a dealer in freezers, for a more expensive model. Appliance’s unfiled interest is superior to Frosty’s rights, because Frosty did not buy for personal, family, or household purposes.13 Subsection (a) cannot rescue Frosty either. It protects a buyer from a person in the business of selling goods of that kind, and Jones is a household owner.14 The two rules do not fill each other’s gaps, and a buyer who fits neither description takes subject to the lien.
Knowledge is the third difference, and the hypothetical shows it. Under subsection (a), a buyer who merely knows that a security interest covers the goods still takes free. The buyer loses protection only by knowing, in addition, that the sale violates a term of the agreement with the secured party.15 Subsection (b) has no such softening, since the consumer buyer must buy without knowledge of the security interest at all.16 The antidote is aimed at the buyer who had no way to find out, and a buyer who actually knows does not need it.
Subsection (a) also limits itself in a way that catches buyers further down the chain. It frees the buyer only from a security interest created by the buyer’s own seller. Suppose Frosty keeps the freezer and resells it to Lee, who buys it for her kitchen. Lee is a buyer in ordinary course of Frosty’s goods, but Jones created Appliance’s interest, not Frosty, so subsection (a) does not free Lee. She is not a casual buyer either, because Frosty did not hold the freezer as consumer goods. She may be a purchaser for value without knowledge, but that status does not help when the security interest was perfected before she attained it.17 Appliance’s interest was perfected the moment it attached.18
A buyer who takes subject to the interest does not necessarily take subject to everything it secures. If a buyer not in ordinary course cannot qualify under § 9-317(b) and the secured party later makes an advance, the buyer takes free of the interest as it secures that advance when the secured party made the advance with knowledge of the purchase or 45 days or more after it. The buyer does not take free if the secured party made the advance, or a commitment to advance, without knowledge of the purchase and within the 45 days.19 The next part develops that protection.
Subsection (c) belongs to the consumer rule alone. To the extent a filing affects the priority of a security interest over a buyer of goods under subsection (b), the period of effectiveness of a filing made in the jurisdiction where the seller is located is governed by § 9-316(a) and (b).20 Because a filing is irrelevant to a buyer in ordinary course, subsection (c) never enters an analysis under subsection (a). Both rules begin “except as otherwise provided in subsection (e),” a qualification that the discussion of goods held by the secured party covers.21