Concept
Why Consumer Buyers Take Free
Buyer of consumer goods
Consumer Buyers of Consumer Goods
Why Consumer Buyers Take Free
Jones buys a deep freeze for home use from Appliance Company on installment credit. Appliance keeps a purchase-money security interest in the freezer and files nothing. Six months later Jones sells the freezer to a neighbor, Smith, who pays for it, wants it for her own kitchen, and has never heard of Appliance. Jones then defaults. Can Appliance repossess the freezer from Smith?
Under Article 9's default rule, it can. Under the consumer buyer rule of UCC § 9-320(b), Smith takes the freezer free of Appliance's interest, even though that interest is perfected, if she meets the rule's conditions.1 Four conditions apply, and the subsections below take them one at a time: the buyer must lack knowledge of the security interest, give value, buy for personal use, and buy before a financing statement is filed. This unit asks the prior question of why the Code reverses its own default for a buyer like Smith.
The default favors the secured party. Under § 9-201 the security agreement is effective against purchasers of the collateral, and § 9-315(a)(1) confirms that the security interest continues in the collateral despite a sale, unless the secured party authorized the disposition free of the interest.2 A buyer who purchases from the debtor therefore takes subject to the lien, as a buyer of land takes subject to a mortgage, and on the debtor's default the secured party may repossess the collateral from the disappointed buyer.3 Without an exception, Smith would lose the freezer to Appliance.
Article 9 does not leave every buyer in that position. Certain classes of buyers take free of even a perfected security interest, and additional classes take free of an unperfected one.4 A buyer who gives value and receives delivery without knowledge of the security interest, before it is perfected, takes free of it under § 9-317(b).5 Section 9-320 goes further and lets certain buyers, the consumer buyer among them, take free of perfected interests.6 Each exception rests on its own logic. Section 9-331, for example, only confirms that a holder in due course keeps its Article 3 rights against a secured creditor, because nothing in Article 9 cuts them off.7
The consumer buyer rule exists because automatic perfection leaves a gap. A purchase-money security interest in consumer goods is perfected the moment it attaches, with no filing and no taking of possession required.8 Several reasons support that choice. Filing for every consumer credit transaction would overfill the filing offices, the benefit of filing is marginal, and creditors know to be careful when a consumer borrows against consumer goods. Consumer goods also cost little and depreciate quickly, so lenders other than the purchase-money lender seldom rely on them, and a later creditor is unlikely to be fooled by the lack of a public filing.9 Those reasons speak to creditors. A later buyer stands differently. Smith, answering a neighbor's ad, had no filing to search and no way to learn that Appliance held an interest in the freezer. The consumer buyer rule is the antidote for that invisible lien, and it is only fair that the amateur buyer takes free.10 Commentary on the Code calls it the 'garage sale' exception and adds that it is hard to exaggerate its unimportance.11
The secured party can avoid the rule, and that choice allocates the risk. A purchase-money lender that files a financing statement before the sale forces any buyer to take the consumer goods subject to its interest.12 For motor vehicles the same logic runs through the certificate of title: an interest in a car bought for personal use is perfected only by filing or by compliance with a state title law,13 and the buyer's protection ends once the lender has noted its lien on the title.14 The rule therefore does its work chiefly where a purchase-money interest in household goods was perfected automatically and remained unfiled when the buyer bought. Where the interest was unperfected, § 9-317(b) already protects a buyer who gives value and takes delivery without knowledge.15
Three variations on Smith's purchase show how the pieces fit:
- Smith buys as described, before any financing statement is filed. She takes the freezer free, because Appliance's automatically perfected interest left her nothing to find.16
- Appliance files a financing statement before the sale. Smith takes the freezer subject to the interest, and Appliance may repossess it on Jones's default.17
- Jones instead trades the freezer to Frosty, a dealer in freezers. Appliance's interest still binds Frosty, who did not buy for personal, family, or household purposes, even though Appliance never filed.18