Concept
Comparing Other Buyer Rules
Buyer of consumer goods
Comparing Other Buyer Rules
Section 9-320(b) is one of several Article 9 rules that let a buyer take goods free of a security interest, and it is the one most easily confused with its neighbors. It protects a buyer from a person who used or bought the goods for use primarily for personal, family, or household purposes. It works even against a perfected security interest, provided the buyer meets the conditions the subsection lists.1 Two neighboring rules cause most of the exam errors. One protects a buyer in ordinary course of business and appears in the first subsection of the same section. The other protects a buyer who gives value and takes delivery without knowledge while the security interest is still unperfected.
The rules differ because each answers a different problem, and each problem dictates which facts matter. The consumer buyer rule fits the household sale, where nothing may yet be on file for the buyer to find. Its conditions track that setting: the buyer must lack knowledge of the security interest,2 and the buyer must buy before a financing statement covering the goods is filed.3 The ordinary-course rule fits the retail shelf, where the seller is in the business of selling goods of that kind. The unperfected-interest rule rests on the record itself, since the secured party has not perfected. Knowledge and timing appear in more than one of these rules, but they do different work in each. Never carry a condition from one rule into another without checking that rule's own text.
When a problem gives you a buyer who beat a security interest, sort it with three questions, in this order:
- Who sold? A household seller points to § 9-320(b). A seller in business selling goods of that kind points to the ordinary-course rule.
- Was a financing statement on file when the buyer bought? Under § 9-320(b), a filing before the purchase ends the buyer's protection.
- What did the buyer know? Under § 9-320(b), buying with knowledge of the security interest also ends it.
If the seller was neither a household nor a dealer, or the household-sale conditions fail, ask whether the security interest was unperfected when the buyer gave value and took delivery. That question brings in the third rule.
The next section applies this sorting to a sale between neighbors, where the seller's identity and the timing of the filing both decide the result.