Concept
Working a Neighbor-Sale Problem
Buyer of consumer goods
Working a Neighbor-Sale Problem
A neighbor who buys a household good from a debtor can take it free of one lender's security interest and subject to another's on a single set of facts, because § 9-320(b) tests the buyer against each security interest separately.1 The subsection frees the buyer even from a perfected interest if the buyer buys from a person who used or bought the goods primarily for personal, family, or household purposes, buys without knowledge of the security interest, buys for value, buys primarily for the buyer's own personal, family, or household purposes, and buys before a financing statement covering the goods is filed.2 Knowledge, payment, and purpose usually read the same against every lender. The filing condition is what separates the lenders, because each one decided for itself whether to file.3
The first move in any such problem is to sort the other parties by status. They are secured parties, transferees, or lien creditors.4 A neighbor who buys the goods is a transferee, not a competing lender. Article 9 governs the secured party's rights against a transferee. The priority rules among lenders apply only when the transferee is itself a secured party.5 For a household buyer, § 9-320(b) is therefore the controlling rule.
The standard two-lender problem shows the sequence at work. On July 1, Dave bought a new stereo for his home from Sally for $1,200 and gave her a security interest for the price, payable at $100 a month. On August 1, Dave borrowed $500 from Happy Finance and gave Happy a security interest in the same stereo, and Happy filed a financing statement in the proper office that day. On August 15, Dave sold the stereo to his neighbor Peter for $1,000 cash. Peter wanted it for his home and took in good faith, without knowledge of either interest. Dave has defaulted on both debts.9 What can each lender reach?
Step one separates the lenders. Sally financed the price, so she holds a purchase-money security interest in consumer goods, perfected automatically on attachment. The facts mention no filing by her.10 Happy lent cash rather than financing the price, and it perfected by filing on August 1. Step two is quick. Dave bought the stereo for his home and held it as a household good until he sold it, so the seller-side requirement is met against both lenders.11
Step three is where the problem divides. Against Sally, Peter bought without knowledge of her interest, paid $1,000, and bought for use in his home.12 No financing statement covered her interest when he bought, so all four conditions are met and Peter takes free of her perfected interest.13 Against Happy, the first three conditions come out the same way, because Peter's ignorance, his payment, and his household purpose do not change with the lender asserting the interest. The fourth condition defeats him. Happy filed on August 1, two weeks before Peter bought, and the condition asks only whether a financing statement covering the goods was on file before the buyer bought.14 It does not matter that Peter never searched the files. One failed condition is enough, because all four must be met.
Step four changes nothing. Nothing in the facts puts the stereo in either lender's possession, so the subsection (e) exception never comes into play.15 Step five states the result. Peter holds the stereo free of Sally's interest and subject to Happy's, so Happy's lien follows the stereo into Peter's home and Dave's default lets Happy enforce it there.16
Perfection cannot explain the split, because both lenders were perfected on August 15. The difference lies in the record. Happy's financing statement was on file for anyone who looked, while Sally's lien was invisible to a neighbor with no filing to search. Sally could have defeated Peter by filing before the sale, because once a purchase-money secured party files, any buyer takes the consumer goods subject to the security interest.17 A filing after August 15 would have come too late, because the condition protects a buyer who buys before the filing.18
A dealer in the chain defeats the buyer at step two. On January 15, D bought a new TV from S and gave S a security interest for the price. D used the TV as consumer goods, and S has not filed. On March 1, D sold the TV to B, who was in the business of buying and selling used TVs. On April 1, B sold it to P, who used it in her home as consumer goods. D has defaulted.19 S's purchase-money interest was perfected automatically, so the lack of a filing does not make it unperfected. P bought from B, a dealer, and a casual buyer must buy from someone who is holding the goods as consumer goods. A consumer who buys from a department store is not a casual buyer, and neither is P.20 Her good faith and ignorance never come into play. P's status as a purchaser for value without knowledge does not rescue her either, because S's security interest was perfected before she attained that status.21
A written answer should therefore begin each lender's analysis with how its interest was perfected and whether anything was filed. It should then confirm that the seller held the goods as consumer goods. The buyer's result against that lender follows from those facts.