Concept
Conditions for Purchaser Priority
Purchaser of chattel paper: proceeds claim
Conditions for Purchaser Priority
Section 9-330(a) gives a purchaser of chattel paper priority over a security interest in that paper claimed merely as proceeds of inventory, but only if the purchaser meets the conditions the subsection lists.1 The contest is one instance of a question that runs through Article 9: when a debtor grants a security interest and then transfers the collateral, does the interest follow the collateral or end with the transfer?2 Once the lender's claim is classified as merely proceeds, the lender starts ahead, because a security interest in proceeds is automatically perfected when the interest in the original collateral was perfected.3 Each condition below is a step the purchaser must take to displace that result, and a purchaser that misses one leaves the lender's priority intact.
The conditions fall into two numbered paragraphs, and the purchaser must satisfy both, since the first ends with “and.” They test different things:
- Paragraph (1) tests what the purchaser does. It must act in good faith and in the ordinary course of its business, give new value, take possession of each authoritative tangible copy of the record evidencing the paper, and obtain control under § 9-105 of each authoritative electronic copy.4
- Paragraph (2) tests what the paper shows. The authoritative copies must not indicate that the chattel paper has been assigned to an identified assignee other than the purchaser.5
Together they describe a purchaser that deals honestly in its regular business, pays fresh value, actually holds or controls the paper, and takes paper whose face points to no other assignee.6
The split between conduct and appearance follows from how the lender's interest exists. It arises as proceeds without any notation on the paper, and the purchaser is not sent to search the records. Instead of a search, the rule asks for observable evidence that the purchaser relied on the paper: honest dealing in its regular business, value paid to the dealer, and actual possession or control of what it bought. The condition on the face of the paper covers the opposite case. If the authoritative copies themselves name another assignee, the purchaser cannot claim to have relied on the dealer's apparent ownership, and the lender has a visible way to protect itself. Commentary describes § 9-330 as an attempt to conform the law to practice, and the conditions read that way.7 Apart from good faith, none of the conditions asks what the purchaser knew about the lender's interest, and the section on knowledge takes that point up.
The sections that follow take paragraph (1) in turn, beginning with the two requirements that describe how the purchaser deals, and end with the paper-based condition of paragraph (2).
Good Faith and Ordinary Course
The first words of paragraph (1) describe how the purchaser must act: “in good faith and in the ordinary course of the purchaser's business.”8 They state two requirements, and each polices something different. Good faith asks whether the purchaser dealt honestly and fairly in this transaction. The ordinary-course requirement ties the transaction to the purchaser's own regular line of work. The model purchaser is a finance company that routinely buys a dealer's installment contracts, pays a fair price, and keeps the paper. Neither requirement substitutes for the other, so the purchaser must clear both.
Good faith carries unusual weight here because subsection (a) restricts the purchaser's state of mind in no other way. Unlike former § 9-308, subsection (a) says nothing about the buyer's knowledge, and the only limit on what the buyer knows is the requirement that it act in good faith.9 A rule that lets a purchaser take free of a lender it may know about needs some way to separate the financer that buys paper in the regular course of business from the one that joins the dealer in diverting paper away from the lender, and good faith does that sorting.
The standard floor-plan illustration shows what good faith permits. A dealer gives financer A a perfected security interest in its automobile inventory and proceeds, sells a car to a buyer who signs a security agreement for the unpaid price, and delivers that paper to financer B, which pays value and regularly acquires such paper from this dealer. B knew that A was financing the dealer's inventory, yet B has priority over A's claim to the paper as proceeds, and A is left with its claim to whatever the dealer received from B.10 Awareness that a lender exists does no damage to good faith.
The line therefore runs between awareness of the lender, which is harmless, and participation in the dealer's diversion of the paper, which defeats good faith. A common error is to carry the knowledge condition of subsection (b) into subsection (a) and subordinate a purchaser merely because it knew of the inventory lender. Under subsection (a), the purchaser's knowledge matters only as it bears on good faith.
The second requirement measures the ordinary course against the purchaser's own business, not the dealer's.11 The buyer in ordinary course of goods runs the other way. An entrusting of goods to a merchant who deals in goods of that kind gives the merchant power to transfer the entruster's rights to a buyer in ordinary course, so that test looks to the seller's business. If A leaves a watch with B, a watch merchant, and B sells it to C, who buys in good faith, A cannot recover it from C.12 The chattel paper rule turns the lens around, and the reason lies in the lender's position. An inventory lender may expect the dealer to sell the paper its credit sales generate and to pass the cash on toward the inventory loan.13 A financer that regularly buys such paper is the kind of buyer that expectation anticipates. A purchase outside the purchaser's usual business falls outside it, and the rule gives such a purchase no protection.
The two requirements operate independently. An honest purchaser can still lose by buying outside its ordinary business, and a routine financer can still lose by dealing dishonestly. Both are only the first two conditions in paragraph (1), and the purchaser must also give new value and take possession or control.
New Value
Paragraph (1) next requires that the purchaser “gives new value,” and the phrase is a defined term that decides many contests.15 The requirement serves one commercial picture, a financer that gives the dealer real financing in return for the paper. A purchaser that takes the paper while giving the dealer nothing fresh has not helped the dealer turn receivables into cash, and the rule gives it no reason to displace an inventory lender whose interest reached the paper first.
Article 9 defines new value as any one of three things and then adds an exclusion that matters as much as the list:16
- money;
- money's worth in property, services, or new credit; or
- the release by a transferee of an interest in property previously transferred to that transferee.
Cash is the plain case, and new credit covers a purchaser that pays with a fresh extension of credit instead of money. The third form fits a purchaser that already holds an interest in something it received from the dealer, say a truck the dealer transferred to it earlier, and gives that interest up as the price of the paper. In each form the dealer gets something real in return, and that is the practical test to apply.
An obligation substituted for another obligation is not new value.17 The exclusion removes the most tempting false positive. A creditor the dealer already owes gives the dealer nothing new by accepting paper in place of the old promise, because the dealer owes the same debt afterward and has no more resources than before. If that exchange counted, any existing creditor could take a dealer's paper on account of what it was already owed and cut off the inventory lender's claim without advancing a dollar.
A bank that instead advances $20,000 in fresh loan proceeds against the same paper, and leaves the old note in place, has given money, and the condition is met. The line does not depend on whether a new document was signed, since a replacement note is a new document too. It depends on whether the dealer received something new or only saw an existing debt change its form.
Subsection (e) relieves one class of claimant of the need to show fresh funds. For purposes of subsections (a) and (b), the holder of a purchase-money security interest in inventory gives new value for chattel paper constituting proceeds of the inventory.18 That holder has already financed the very goods whose sale produced the paper, and requiring a second payment for paper that is the product of those goods would leave it unable to meet the element for want of a payment that makes no commercial sense. The deeming rule also fits the wider priority scheme: a perfected purchase-money holder in inventory is treated as giving new value for chattel paper that is identifiable proceeds of that inventory, and its priority in such paper depends on qualifying under § 9-330.19
The deeming rule is narrow. It supplies only the new value element, and only for chattel paper that is proceeds of the inventory in which the holder has the purchase-money interest. The holder must still act in good faith and in the ordinary course of its business, take possession or control, and take paper that carries no legend assigning it to someone else. A financer with no purchase-money interest in the inventory receives no deeming at all and must give real new value of its own.
Possession or Control
Beyond good faith, ordinary course, and new value, paragraph (1) requires that the purchaser “takes possession of each authoritative tangible copy of the record evidencing the chattel paper, and obtains control under Section 9-105 of each authoritative electronic copy of the record evidencing the chattel paper.”22 The sentence offers two ways of actually holding the paper, and the form of the record decides which applies: physical possession for a paper record, control for an electronic one. Both are keyed to the authoritative copy, and both reach every such copy. The condition is an act the purchaser performs, so it can be checked afterward by asking who holds the paper.
The condition makes sense in light of how the inventory lender holds its interest. That interest arises as proceeds and is perfected automatically, so the paper can stay in the debtor's hands, and a debtor that keeps the paper can sell it again. Holding the paper is the stronger protection: perfection by possession of an instrument, and of chattel paper as well, gives better protection than a filing, because when a secured party holds the note no one else can enforce it.23 The possession-or-control condition gives the purchaser the same advantage. A purchaser that holds every authoritative copy has removed whatever could be sold again, and its claim rests on a fact anyone can verify without searching the filing records. In the floor-plan illustration, the dealer physically transferred the buyer's security agreement to financer B, which paid value for it, and B took priority over the inventory financer's proceeds claim.24
Control under § 9-105 is the electronic counterpart of possession. It is a fact about how the electronic records are kept: the system must reliably show the purchaser as the party to whom the paper was assigned, and the dealer and purchaser cannot create control just by agreeing that it exists.25
The word each appears in both halves of the sentence, and the text controls the outcome. Possession of one authoritative tangible copy does not satisfy the condition when another authoritative copy sits elsewhere, and control of one authoritative electronic copy does not satisfy it when the dealer keeps control of another. Whoever holds an authoritative version can still deliver it to a later purchaser in the same way the first purchaser received it. A purchaser claiming priority over the lender must have taken the paper out of circulation, and it can claim that only if no one else retains an authoritative version.
The usual exam error is to treat payment plus a signed assignment as enough, or to treat a copy in the purchaser's file as the paper itself. Those facts show an honest purchase that gave value, but the condition asks who holds the authoritative version.
Older cases and study materials speak of “tangible chattel paper” and “electronic chattel paper.” The 2022 amendments eliminated those two definitions and revised the definition of chattel paper itself, and § 9-330(a) now speaks of authoritative tangible and electronic copies of the record.26 When you meet the older labels, read them as pointing to the same two ways of holding the paper: possession for a paper record and control for an electronic one.
No Assignment Legend
Paragraph (2) turns from the purchaser's conduct to the paper itself. The authoritative copies of the record evidencing the chattel paper must not indicate that it has been assigned to “an identified assignee other than the purchaser.”28 Paragraph (1) tested honesty, ordinary course, new value, and actual possession or control. Paragraph (2) tests appearance, and it looks at the face of the authoritative copies alone, with no inquiry into what the purchaser believed. Because the two paragraphs are joined conjunctively, a purchaser that satisfies every element of the first still has no priority under subsection (a) when the paper points to a different assignee.29
The condition doubles as the inventory lender's self-help. Because the lender's interest arises automatically as proceeds, nothing on the paper reveals it unless someone puts a notation there. A lender that wants to keep purchasers from taking priority can stamp the paper to show that it has been assigned to the lender, and a purchaser that later takes the stamped paper is subordinated even though the lender's claim rests only on proceeds.30 For tangible paper the indication normally takes the form of a written legend.31
The rule puts the burden of protection on the party who can carry it cheaply. Subsection (a) does not let the lender defeat a purchaser by proving that the purchaser knew of the lien, so the Code supplies a different lever, one that works through the paper instead of through the purchaser's state of mind.32 A stamp costs the lender little. A purchaser that must take possession of every authoritative tangible copy has the paper in hand and can read what it says. Because the test is the face of the paper, it is objective, and a stamp counts whether or not the particular purchaser read it.
The wording of paragraph (2) has three working parts, and each limits the occasions on which the condition fails:
- The authoritative copies must indicate that the chattel paper has been assigned, so a notation that says nothing about assignment does not trigger the condition.
- The indication must point to an identified assignee, a particular person or entity that the paper names.
- The assignee so identified must be someone other than the purchaser claiming priority.
The last part carries the most weight in practice. A legend exists to warn that another claimant stands behind the paper, and a notation that the paper was assigned to the purchaser itself warns of no one. It merely records the transaction under which the purchaser claims, so it leaves the condition satisfied.
An exam stem that wants a purchaser to lose despite satisfying every element of paragraph (1) will mark the paper.
Applying the Legend Condition
The legend condition is easiest to apply as a short inspection of a single object, and the inspection runs in four steps.
The third step carries the most weight. A stamp bearing the purchaser's own name leaves the condition satisfied, and a notation that names no one does not match the text's description of an identified assignee.34
The ordinary contest comes out the other way when the paper is clean. A secured party holds a security interest in all of a debtor's inventory, the debtor sells an item to a buyer who gives a promise to pay and a security interest in the goods, and the debtor then sells the resulting chattel paper to a purchaser. A purchaser that acts in good faith, in the ordinary course of its business, gives new value, and takes possession or control takes free of the secured party's interest so long as the paper carries no legend stating that it was assigned to that secured party or to anyone else.35 Where the secured party's interest exists only because the paper is proceeds, a purchaser meeting these requirements takes free even if it knows that the sale violates the secured party's rights.36 An exam stem that stresses the purchaser's awareness of the inventory lien, with no notation on the paper, therefore points toward a purchaser who wins.
Subsection (f) carries the same legend into the rules that do ask about knowledge. For purposes of subsections (b) and (d), if the authoritative copies indicate that the chattel paper has been assigned to an identified secured party other than the purchaser, the purchaser has knowledge that the purchase violates that secured party's rights.37 Subsection (a) asks no knowledge question, so under it the legend defeats the purchaser directly through paragraph (2). Under the knowledge-based rules the legend defeats the purchaser by supplying the knowledge those rules require, and it operates as conclusive proof, so a purchaser cannot escape by showing that it never noticed the stamp.38 A legend therefore protects the secured party whether its claim is merely as proceeds or something more. Subsections (b) and (d) have conditions of their own; what matters here is that subsection (f) makes the legend proof of knowledge instead of a fact the purchaser may contest.