Concept
What the Lender Keeps
Purchaser of chattel paper: proceeds claim
What the Lender Keeps
A purchaser who beats an inventory lender for chattel paper under § 9-330(a) does not leave the lender with nothing. The lender loses the paper but keeps a claim to what the dealer received for it, and the purchaser's win carries a second benefit that matters when the car comes back. The lender's side comes first, because it shows why the two halves fit together.
The floor-plan illustration from earlier in this chapter shows the split. Financer A finances the dealer's inventory, the dealer sells a car on credit, and the dealer then sells the buyer's security agreement to financer B. B knew that A was financing the inventory, and B still has priority in the agreement over A's claim to it as proceeds of inventory. A's only remaining claim is to the proceeds arising from the dealer's sale of the paper to B.1
The general rule on dispositions explains why A keeps that much. A security interest continues in collateral after an unauthorized sale unless the buyer takes free under some other Article 9 provision, and it also attaches to the proceeds of the sale.2 Section 9-330 is such a provision for chattel paper. B takes the paper free of A's claim, but A's attachment to proceeds is untouched and reaches the cash B paid the dealer. A secured party may claim both the original collateral and the proceeds but may have only one satisfaction, and here A has lost the first claim and holds only the second.3
The dispute usually starts from the lender's own expectations. The lender may have counted on the dealer to sell the paper and remit the proceeds against the inventory debt, and the conflict arises when the dealer sells the paper but fails to use the proceeds to reduce the inventory loan.4 The lender's inventory priority does not carry over to chattel paper that is proceeds. Even a lender with a perfected purchase money security interest in the inventory has priority in that paper only if it qualifies under § 9-330, although the law deems it to give new value for chattel paper that is identifiable proceeds of the inventory.5
The purchaser's priority does not stop at the paper. Section 9-330(c) extends it, subject to § 9-327, to the paper's proceeds in two ways. Under paragraph (c)(1), the purchaser has priority in proceeds to the extent that § 9-322 provides it. Under paragraph (c)(2), the purchaser has priority when the proceeds consist of the specific goods covered by the paper or cash proceeds of those goods, "even if the purchaser's security interest in the proceeds is unperfected."6
Paragraph (c)(2) does its most important work when the goods come back. Suppose the buyer defaults and the dealer repossesses the car. The inventory lender's security interest reattaches to the car under its after-acquired property clause, because the car is again inventory in the dealer's hands. The purchaser, by contrast, has no security interest in the dealer's inventory as such and can reach the car only by claiming it as proceeds of the paper.7 Without paragraph (c)(2), the lender that lost the paper contest could win the car, and the purchaser's priority in the paper would count for little because the goods behind it would belong to the lender. Paragraph (c)(2) closes that gap. A chattel paper transferee that had priority over the inventory secured party in the paper itself also has priority in the returned goods.8 The statute does not require the purchaser to have perfected as to the car, so the purchaser need not have filed against goods it never held.9
That priority is derivative. It exists only because the purchaser had priority in the paper, and subsection (c) protects only a purchaser that has priority under subsection (a) or (b).10 A purchaser that wins a dealer's installment contract under subsection (a) and then sees the buyer default shows the rule working: when the dealer repossesses the car, the purchaser prevails in it as proceeds of the paper. The next example shows the same facts with one condition missing.
Both scenes turn on the same hinge: whether the purchaser cleared the conditions of subsection (a) for the paper. One of those conditions is that the paper not indicate an assignment to an identified assignee other than the purchaser. For electronic chattel paper, the test looks to the authoritative copies of the record.11 A failure on the legend, on new value, or on possession or control ends the analysis for the car as well as the paper. When the purchaser does clear those conditions, the assets divide cleanly. The purchaser keeps the paper, its proceeds, and the specific goods behind it, and the lender keeps its claim to the cash the dealer received for the paper.