Concept
The Chattel Paper Conflict
Purchaser of chattel paper: other security interests
Chattel Paper Purchaser Priority
The Chattel Paper Conflict
A dealer who sells goods on credit has the buyer sign a security agreement that reserves a security interest in the goods for the unpaid price. That agreement is now called chattel paper, and the dealer may assign it to a bank, either by outright sale or to secure a loan.1 Once the paper changes hands, more than one financer can claim it, and the law must choose between them.
Section 9-330(b) of the Uniform Commercial Code makes that choice for a purchaser of chattel paper. It gives the purchaser priority over a security interest in the paper that is claimed other than merely as proceeds of inventory, provided the purchaser meets the conditions the subsection lists.2
The subsection is an exception, so the rule it overrides comes first. A security agreement is effective against purchasers of the collateral, and the security interest continues in the collateral notwithstanding a sale or other disposition. A buyer therefore takes subject to the interest, and if the seller defaults, the secured party can potentially repossess the collateral from the disappointed buyer.3 Article 9 relieves certain buyers and transferees of that burden, among them holders in due course and certain purchasers of chattel paper and instruments who give new value and take possession.4 Without such an exception, a secured party that perfects by possession of tangible paper or by filing takes priority over later-arising competing interests.5
Inventory financing supplies the classic collision. A lender holds a perfected security interest in a dealer's inventory of cars. When the dealer sells a car on credit, the buyer's contract becomes chattel paper, and that paper is proceeds of the inventory, because proceeds include whatever the dealer acquires on selling the collateral.6 The lender may have expected the dealer to sell the paper and apply the money to the inventory loan. If the dealer sells the paper and does not use the money to reduce that loan, the lender and the purchaser each claim the same contracts. Sometimes the lender claims even more, having lent against specific contracts in the first place.7
The hypothetical below follows that second case from the purchaser's side.
Harbor wins even though Summit filed first. Summit advanced money in reliance on the contracts themselves, so it claims more than proceeds, and subsection (b), with its knowledge requirement, governs. Subsection (a) covers the original secured creditor who claims the paper merely as proceeds, and the next section draws that line.8 Harbor was not required, as a matter of good faith, to search the records for prior security interests.9
Summit could have protected itself. Had it perfected by taking possession of the contracts and kept them in its vault, Ortega would have had nothing to deliver, and Harbor could not have taken possession of the paper.10 The paper itself offers a second protection: if it indicates an assignment to an identified secured party other than the purchaser, the purchaser has wrongful knowledge and cannot qualify for priority.11
Older sources distinguish tangible from electronic chattel paper. The 2022 amendments eliminated both defined terms and revised the definition of chattel paper to address bundled or hybrid transactions, particularly leases in which the value of the services exceeds the value of the goods. Chattel paper now arises only where the transaction's predominant purpose is to give the lessee the right to possess and use the leased goods.12 The statute's own text still refers to authoritative tangible and electronic copies of the record, as the full text of the subsection shows:
A purchaser of chattel paper has priority over a security interest in the chattel paper which is claimed other than merely as proceeds of inventory subject to a security interest if the purchaser gives new value, takes possession of each authoritative tangible copy of the record evidencing the chattel paper, and obtains control under Section 9-105 of each authoritative electronic copy of the record evidencing the chattel paper in good faith, in the ordinary course of the purchaser's business, and without knowledge that the purchase violates the rights of the secured party.13
The subsection imposes five cumulative conditions, and each gets its own section below:
- The purchaser gives new value for the paper.
- The purchaser takes possession of each authoritative tangible copy and obtains control of each authoritative electronic copy of the record.
- The purchaser acts in good faith.
- The purchaser acts in the ordinary course of its own business.
- The purchaser acts without knowledge that the purchase violates the secured party's rights.
A purchaser who misses any one of the five falls back on the ordinary rule that a perfected secured party takes priority over later-arising competing interests.14