Concept
Beyond a Mere Proceeds Claim
Purchaser of chattel paper: other security interests
Beyond a Mere Proceeds Claim
Section 9-330 gives a purchaser of chattel paper two routes to priority over an earlier secured party, and the earlier party's claim to the paper decides which route applies. Subsection (a) covers the creditor who claims the paper “merely as proceeds.” Subsection (b) covers the creditor who claims something more, one who has loaned money to the debtor somehow in reliance upon the chattel paper.1 The text of subsection (b) makes the same cut: it reaches a security interest in chattel paper “claimed other than merely as proceeds of inventory subject to a security interest.”2 Until you decide which subsection you are in, you cannot test the purchaser's priority.
The proceeds-only case is the familiar one. An inventory lender holds a floating lien on a dealer's cars and their proceeds. The dealer sells a car on credit, and the buyer signs a security agreement for the unpaid price. That agreement is chattel paper, and the lender's claim to it is only that it is proceeds of the inventory.3 The lender may well have expected the dealer to sell the paper and remit the money against the inventory loan. When the dealer sells the paper and fails to pay down the loan, the lender and the purchaser of the paper assert conflicting claims.4
A lender can stand in a stronger position. The 1999 revision does not elaborate on “merely as proceeds,” so the dividing question is reliance: did the lender lend in reliance on the paper itself?5 A lending formula that counts the paper is one obvious example. Suppose a lender agrees to advance a percentage of the cost of the dealer's inventory plus a percentage of the face amount of its receivables, and the receivables include installment contracts. The contracts helped fix the size of the loan, so the lender's claim to them rests on more than the fact that they arose from selling a car. That claim is “other than merely as proceeds,” and subsection (b) governs.
The classification matters because it sets how much the purchaser must know. Under subsection (b), the purchaser must lack knowledge that its purchase violates the rights of the secured party, in addition to giving new value, taking possession or control, and acting in good faith and in the ordinary course of its business.6 Subsection (a) is more generous. The purchaser may take free even if it knows that its purchase may violate the prior creditor's rights, and the only restriction on what it knows is the requirement of good faith.7 Former § 9-308 drew a similar line. A buyer facing a mere proceeds claim took free if it gave new value and took possession in the ordinary course, even though it knew the specific paper was subject to a security interest. A buyer facing a stronger claim had to act without that knowledge.8
The difference tracks reliance. A proceeds-only lender expected the paper to be sold, so the purchaser who buys in good faith and in the ordinary course deserves protection, and the lender has a cheap safeguard of its own in the form of a legend, discussed below. A lender that lent against the paper bargained for that very paper, and the dealer's sale cuts directly across the loan. A purchaser who knows that its purchase violates such a lender's rights has a weaker claim to take free.
The dealer-financer example shows the proceeds side of the line. A dealer gave financer A a perfected security interest in its automobile inventory and the proceeds of its sale. The dealer sold a car to a buyer who signed a security agreement for the unpaid price, then physically delivered that chattel paper to financer B. B paid value and regularly bought this kind of paper from the dealer. B knew that A was financing the dealer's inventory, yet B has priority over A's claim to the paper. A's only claim is as proceeds, so what remains to A is the claim to the proceeds the dealer received from selling the paper to B.9
A purchaser who sees such a statement in a financing statement has exactly the knowledge subsection (b) forbids.10 Change the facts so that Delmar lent only against the boats and the contracts reached it merely as proceeds, and subsection (a) governs instead. That subsection carries no separate no-knowledge condition, and the only restriction on what the purchaser knows is good faith.11
A legend protects the lender on either side of the line. If the chattel paper itself indicates that it has been assigned to an identified secured party other than the purchaser, the purchaser is conclusively treated as knowing that its purchase violates that party's rights. A legend on the face of the paper therefore protects a secured creditor whether it claims merely as proceeds or otherwise.12
Students often treat the label “inventory lender” as the classification, and it is not. The lender's claim to the paper decides the question, and the lending formula usually reveals that claim.