Concept
Priority in Proceeds
Purchaser of chattel paper: other security interests
Priority in Proceeds
A purchaser that wins the chattel paper also wins much of what the paper later becomes, and subsection (c) of § 9-330 fixes how much. Except as § 9-327 provides otherwise, a purchaser having priority in chattel paper under subsection (a) or (b) also has priority in the proceeds of the paper to the extent that § 9-322 provides for priority in the proceeds, or the proceeds consist of the specific goods covered by the chattel paper or cash proceeds of those goods, even if the purchaser's security interest in the proceeds is unperfected.1
The opening clause sets the entry condition: the purchaser must already have priority in the paper under subsection (a) or (b). Everything in subsection (c) is derivative. A purchaser that fell short on one of the conditions studied earlier, by buying paper whose legend names another assignee, for example, has no priority to extend, and subsection (c) gives it nothing.
Proceeds means whatever is acquired upon the sale, lease, license, exchange, or other disposition of collateral, and the definition reaches widely.2 When a dealer sells an inventory car, the buyer's trade-in car, check, cash, and the balance owed under a security agreement (chattel paper), a promissory note (instrument), or a bare promise to pay (account) are all proceeds of the inventory.3 That is why an inventory lender can claim a dealer's installment contract as proceeds of the car. Subsection (c) addresses the next link in the chain: the proceeds of the paper itself.
The two numbered clauses do different work. Clause (1) sends the question to § 9-322, so ranking in those proceeds follows that section's rules and not anything subsection (c) says on its own.4 Clause (2) is the special rule. It covers proceeds that are the very goods the paper describes, or the cash from selling them, and it applies even if the purchaser never perfected in those proceeds.5
Clause (2) matters most when goods return to the dealer. Suppose a dealer sells a car on credit, the buyer's promise and security agreement become chattel paper, and the dealer sells that paper to a finance company with priority in it. The dealer's inventory lender still holds an interest in the car it financed. If the buyer returns the car, the lender automatically has a security interest in the returned goods so long as the original debt is unpaid. If the lender perfected at the time of sale by a filing that is still effective, its interest stays perfected on the return; otherwise it must take possession of the returned goods or file.6
The first question about the returned goods is the dealer's title. Until the paper owner forecloses by sale or strict foreclosure, the dealer is likely a non-owner, a mere bailee for the chattel paper owner. Goods may also come back because the buyer rejects them or otherwise purports to transfer title back to the dealer, and then the dealer holds the goods on a different footing.7 In either case the finance company's route to the car is the one clause (2) provides: the car is the specific goods covered by the paper it owns.
The structure of the clause explains why it follows the goods. The purchaser paid for paper that rests on specific collateral, and without clause (2) the inventory lender could take the car the moment it returned, leaving the purchaser a claim against a defaulting buyer with the collateral gone. The perfection waiver fits the same design. Subsection (a) or (b) has already ranked these two financers in the purchaser's favor, and a filing requirement on the returned goods would reopen that contest at the moment of default. Chattel paper also fares better here than an account, because an unpaid transferee of an account holds an interest in returned goods that is subordinate to a perfected inventory lender.8
Because Gantry's priority in the truck is derivative, any defect in its priority in the paper is fatal to its claim to the truck. Had the contract carried a legend naming Northfield as the assignee, Gantry would never have held priority in the paper, and its claim to the returned truck against Northfield would fail for the same reason. A purchaser with priority in the paper has the proceeds priority as well, and a purchaser without it has neither.
The phrase even if unperfected has a narrow reach, and students most often overstate it. It lets the purchaser prevail over the inventory lender without a filing against the goods or possession of them. It does not turn the purchaser's unperfected interest into a perfected one. The ordinary routes to perfection in returned goods remain a still-effective filing or possession, and a purchaser with neither should not expect the clause to protect it against other claimants such as a creditor who levies on the goods.9 A buyer in the ordinary course of business who later buys the returned goods from the dealer takes free of both the inventory lender and the secured party holding the chattel paper.10 Clause (2) therefore settles one contest, between the paper purchaser and the inventory lender, and leaves every other contest to the rules that ordinarily govern it.