Concept
Article 9 Yields to Take-Free Rules
Holders and purchasers of negotiable instruments
Holders and Protected Purchasers
Article 9 Yields to Take-Free Rules
A debtor who disposes of collateral without the secured party's authorization does not ordinarily cut off the lien. The security interest continues in the collateral in the transferee's hands unless the transferee takes free under some other provision of Article 9, and it also attaches to the proceeds of the disposition.1 If two claimants then contest the same asset, the first to file or perfect usually prevails, and the filing or perfection date for the original collateral serves as the date for its identifiable proceeds.2 Section 9-331 interrupts that default for one group of takers.
A short scene shows how. A lender files a financing statement covering all of a debtor's accounts. An account debtor pays one account with a check, and the debtor indorses the check to a vendor to settle an old bill. The check is identifiable cash proceeds of the accounts,3 so the lender's interest in it dates from the original filing, and the first-to-file rule says the lender should win. The lender loses if the vendor takes the check as a holder in due course under Article 3. That status includes taking without knowledge of the lender's interest, and the filing gave the vendor no notice.4 The vendor has priority in the check.
Section 9-331(a) states the general principle behind that result. It names four kinds of taker whose rights Article 9 leaves untouched: a holder in due course of a negotiable instrument, a holder to whom a negotiable document of title has been duly negotiated, a protected purchaser of a security, and a qualifying purchaser of a controllable account, controllable electronic record, or controllable payment intangible.5 These takers "take priority over an earlier security interest, even if perfected, to the extent provided in Articles 3, 7, 8, and 12."6
The section sets no qualifying tests of its own. Article 3 supplies the holder-in-due-course rules, Article 7 the rules on due negotiation, Article 8 the protected-purchaser rules, and Article 12 those for controllable records.7 The opening words, "This article does not limit the rights of," make Article 9's continuation and priority rules step aside, and the closing phrase sends you to those other articles for two answers: whether the taker qualifies at all, and how far its protection reaches against the earlier security interest.8 The provision confirms what would probably have been assumed anyway. A person with holder-in-due-course rights, or the parallel rights under Articles 7 and 8, enjoys them against a secured creditor, and Article 9 does not change an outcome that Article 3 already dictates.9 Other take-free rules exist inside Article 9 itself. A nonexclusive licensee in the ordinary course of business, for instance, takes free of security interests created by the licensor even if they are perfected and the licensee knows of them.10
The policy choice sits in the other articles. Each answers the same question: when is it more important to preserve prior rights, and when is it more important to protect the marketplace even at the expense of prior rights?11 For negotiable paper, the answer favors the marketplace. Filing under Article 9 does not constitute notice of the earlier security interest to a holder or purchaser,12 and filing a financing statement is not notice of a claim or defense.13 A taker of such paper therefore bears no risk from a record it was never charged with searching.
The paper itself separates a protected taker from an unprotected one. Change the scene:
In the check scene the lender was earlier and perfected, and it lost anyway. A holder in due course has priority over a perfected security interest whichever came first. The same result appears in the Runnells Grain Elevator case. A grain elevator, as drawer, mailed a check representing the proceeds of a debtor's harvest to the debtor's landlords, even though the drawer had notice of a perfected security interest. The secured party's interest was prior and perfected, yet the landlords qualified as holders in due course and took free of it.14 What mattered was the landlords' status, not who knew what at the drawer's end.
A problem that pits a filed lender against a taker of paper therefore starts with a different question than most priority contests. Ask first whether the collateral is a negotiable instrument, a negotiable document of title, a security, or a controllable account, controllable electronic record, or controllable payment intangible. Then ask whether this taker meets the test that Article 3, 7, 8, or 12 sets for protection. If it does, the taker prevails whatever the filing dates were. If it does not, § 9-331 supplies no protection and the ordinary Article 9 priority rules resolve the contest.