Concept
Liens Outside Article 9
Priority of liens arising by law (§ 9-333)
Priority of Possessory Liens
Liens Outside Article 9
Article 9 regulates security interests, the claims on a debtor’s goods that the debtor creates by agreement. Many creditors hold claims on the same goods with no agreement behind them, and Article 9 declines to govern the two most common kinds. Section 9-109(d) excludes “a landlord’s lien, other than an agricultural lien,” and “a lien, other than an agricultural lien, given by statute or other rule of law for services or materials, but section 9–333 applies with respect to priority of the lien.”1 The second exclusion has two parts. Its main clause removes the lien from Article 9. The clause beginning “but” puts Article 9 back for one purpose only, which is ranking the lien against a security interest in the same goods.
The exclusions follow from where these liens come from. A repairer or other artisan holds a lien because a statute or other rule of law grants it, and no agreement with the debtor creates it. The granting statute is therefore the natural source for the lien’s terms, and the state statutes that create liens of this kind commonly state their own priority rules.2 Liens given for services or materials are often called artisan’s liens.3 Anyone asking whether a repairer holds a lien, and for how much, must read the lien statute and not Article 9.
One point of contact remains. The goods that secure a repairer’s bill are often also collateral for a lender’s security interest, and when both claimants look to the same goods, someone has to say who is paid first. Article 9 already ranks competing claims to collateral, and § 9-333 supplies the ranking for liens for services or materials.4 In general, a possessory lien on goods has priority over a security interest in the goods unless the statute creating the lien expressly provides otherwise.5 The sections that follow take that rule apart. For now, the point is how narrow Article 9’s authority is over these liens: it decides rank and nothing else.
The landlord’s lien shows how far the exclusion reaches. Section 9-109(d)(1) removes a landlord’s lien from Article 9 and, unlike subsection (d)(2), contains no clause restoring Article 9 for priority.6 A landlord’s claim to a tenant’s furniture for unpaid rent is therefore governed from start to finish by other state law, including its rank against a lender that holds a security interest in the same furniture. The repairer receives a narrow measure of Article 9 treatment and the landlord receives none, because only the services-or-materials lien is paired with the § 9-333 ranking rule.
Both exclusions open with the same exception: each removes a lien only if it is “other than an agricultural lien.” The agricultural lien is a statutory lien that Article 9 brings inside the Article for perfection and priority. It is not a “security interest,” because it is not consensual and arises by operation of law, yet Article 9 governs it anyway.7 A repairer’s lien and an ordinary landlord’s lien stay outside. The agricultural lien returns later in this chapter as a contrast to the possessory lien.