Concept
The Priority Rule
Priority of liens arising by law (§ 9-333)
The Priority Rule
A possessory lien on goods outranks a security interest in the goods, unless the statute that creates the lien expressly provides otherwise.1 A car sale shows the rule at work. The seller finances the sale and keeps a security interest in the car for the unpaid price, then perfects it by filing a financing statement or by having the interest noted on the certificate of title. Later the buyer takes the car to a garage for repairs, and the garage asserts a possessory lien for the repair charges.2 If the garage's lien meets the definition just covered and its statute is silent on priority, the garage is paid first, even though the seller perfected before the work began.
That result departs from Article 9's ordinary ordering. For non-purchase-money security interests in equipment and consumer goods, priority follows the first filing or perfection, so long as no gap in filing or perfection intervenes.3 By that measure the seller would win easily. The possessory lien rule sets the measure aside. A possessory lien depends on the lienor's holding the goods, not on a place in a filing sequence, so the first-to-file comparison has no filing date to compare.
Why rank the repairer first? Lien statutes rest on the judgment that parties who contribute inputs or services to another should have a first claim to payment, and statutory liens have generally taken priority over perfected UCC security interests.4 Applied to goods, the point is concrete. The repairer's labor and materials repaired, improved, or enhanced the value of the very collateral the lender relies on, and the statute lets the repairer keep the goods until it is paid.5 A lender ranked first would take the benefit of work it never paid for. The ordering is old. The Model UCC's version (§ 9-310, in the 1979 pamphlet) provided that when a person furnishes services or materials in the ordinary course of business, a lien on goods in that person's possession, given by statute or rule of law, takes priority over a perfected security interest unless the lien is statutory and the statute expressly provides otherwise.6
The rule reaches every security interest in the goods. It sets the lienor against “a security interest in the goods” and conditions the priority on neither perfection nor timing, so the garage beats a perfected interest, which the Model provision addressed expressly, and it beats an unperfected one all the more.7 A student who starts by asking who filed first has asked a question the rule does not pose. Consent and notice are likewise beside the point under the default rule, because the lien arises by statute or rule of law and the lender need not approve the work. Only a statute that expressly provides otherwise can add such a condition, as the next section shows.
Possession is the price of the priority. The repair-lien statute quoted in the commentary gives the lien “while such property is lawfully in the person's possession, which possession the person may retain until such compensation is paid.”8 The Tax Lien Act of 1966 sets the same condition. It protects a repairer against a filed federal tax lien only if the repairer “is, and has been, continuously in possession of such property from the time such lien arose.”9 A repairer that hands the goods back unpaid therefore gives up the possessory lien the rule protects, and the lender's perfected security interest ranks ahead of whatever claim remains.
A statute can also reverse the default. The repair-lien statute quoted in the commentary makes the lien “subject to all prior liens of record,” unless notice is given to all lienholders of record and written consent is obtained from all of them; with that notice and consent, the lien is prior.10 Under a statute of that kind the lender's consent decides the contest. The next section takes up how far such statutes can displace the default.
Other claimants reach the same goods by different routes and do not rank under this rule. The judicial lien creditor gets a lien through legal process: the creditor obtains a judgment and executes on the property, and depending on the jurisdiction the lien arises when the writ of execution is delivered to the sheriff or when the sheriff levies on the property.11 The federal tax lien has its own rule. It is inferior to a holder of a security interest until notice of the tax lien is filed, so a security interest perfected before that filing has priority over the tax lien.12
Step 2 is the one students skip, because it requires reading the lien statute and not only the UCC.