Concept
Possessory Liens and Tax Liens
Priority of liens arising by law (§ 9-333)
Possessory Liens and Tax Liens
A repairer who keeps the goods can outrank a federal tax lien that was noticed before the repair began. Congress wrote that preference into 26 U.S.C. § 6323(b)(5). Even after notice of the tax lien is filed, the statute protects the holder of a lien under local law securing "the reasonable price of the repair or improvement" of tangible personal property, but only if the holder "is, and has been, continuously in possession of such property from the time such lien arose."1 The conditions will look familiar. The statute asks for a lien created by local law, for work done on property, and for a lienor who holds the property. That is the profile of the nonconsensual possessory lienor this chapter has followed from the start. The statute also narrows the field: the property must be tangible personal property, so a lien on land or a building falls outside the exception by its own terms.
A federal tax lien ordinarily wins by arriving first, which is why the repairer needs an exception. The Supreme Court has joined the choateness doctrine to a first-in-time requirement to give federal tax liens special priority, and it has done so outside the insolvency setting as well.2 A tax lien ranks behind a security interest that was perfected before notice of the tax lien was filed.3 A repairer cannot count on that kind of timing. Its lien comes into being only when the work is finished, and by then notice of a tax lien against the owner may already be on file. In a contest decided by time alone, the repairer would lose. The exception reverses that result for a repairer who meets its terms, even when the lien arises after the notice.
The reasoning behind the preference is practical. A tractor that runs sells for more than one that does not, so the repair benefits every creditor who looks to the tractor for payment, the government included. A repairer who had to queue behind a tax lien filed before the work began would have little reason to do the work at all.
Possession carries the exception, as it carries the Code's preference for possessory liens. Under the Code, a possessory lien on goods has priority over a security interest in the goods unless the lien is created by a statute that expressly provides otherwise.4 The federal text states its possession requirement with unusual precision: the repairer must be in possession and must have been in possession continuously from the time the lien arose.5 A repairer who hands the goods back, even briefly, leaves a gap that the word "continuously" does not allow. Holding the goods is the repairer's leverage for collecting the bill, and a repairer who surrenders them gives up the leverage that justified putting it first. Because the Code's preference belongs to a possessory lien, the same surrender costs the repairer its priority against a secured party.6
Goods can carry a bank's perfected security interest and a federal tax lien at the same time. The repairer then faces two contests, and the sound method is to take them in pairs. Against the bank, the possessory lien prevails unless its statute expressly provides otherwise.7 Against the government, § 6323(b)(5) gives the repairer first place on the conditions already described.8 Between the bank and the government, the bank wins if it perfected before the notice was filed.9 If it did, the ranking runs repairer, bank, government. That ranking lasts only while the repairer keeps the goods; a repairer who surrenders them falls behind both.
A reader who notes only that the lien arose after the notice has applied the first-in-time rule and skipped the exception built for exactly that lien. The question that decides the contest is whether the repairer still holds the goods and always has.