Concept
General Priority Rules
Priority among conflicting security interests (§§ 9-322 through 9-329)
General Priority Rules
When two secured parties claim the same asset, § 9-322(a) supplies the default ranking. It governs priority among conflicting security interests and agricultural liens in the same collateral, and it gives way wherever that section provides otherwise.1 Two phrases in that opening sentence do the work. “In the same collateral” confines each contest to a single asset, so a lender that ranks first in a debtor’s inventory gains nothing in the debtor’s printing press. “Except as otherwise provided” marks the ranking as a default, which means a result reached under the three rules is provisional until the exceptions later in this chapter have been checked.
The default is a ladder of three rules, and the rungs follow how much public notice each claimant has given. If both claimants have filed or perfected, the earlier filing or perfection date wins.2 If only one has, the perfected interest outranks the unperfected one, whichever attached first.3 If neither has, the interest that attached first wins.4 Filing and perfection tell later lenders that the collateral is already claimed. When both claimants sent that signal, the one that sent it first is the one a later lender could have found and priced into its own loan. When only one sent it, the other left third parties no way to learn of its claim and takes the lower rank. When neither sent it, no public marker exists, and the only objective fact left to separate the claimants is the order in which their interests came into being.
Three terms recur in every subsection below. A security interest attaches when there is a security agreement, the secured party has given value, and the debtor has rights in the collateral.5 Filing means placing a financing statement on the public record. Perfection is the further step that protects a secured party against third parties. It cannot occur before attachment, and the method that works depends on the kind of collateral and sometimes on the nature of the transaction.6 The Code recognizes four methods: filing, possession, control, and automatic perfection for certain collateral.7 Every priority date in this chapter therefore rests on attachment first. At each rung the question is the same: which of these steps can each claimant show, and on what date?
First to File or Perfect
The top rung applies when every claimant has perfected. Section 9-322(a)(1) ranks conflicting perfected security interests by priority in time of filing or perfection, and priority dates from the earlier of the time a filing covering the collateral is first made and the time the security interest is first perfected.8 Each secured party therefore has a critical date, the earlier of those two events, and the party with the earliest critical date ranks first, the next-earliest second, and so on. The rule is not first to perfect but first to file or perfect, so neither the order of attachment nor the order of perfection alone decides the ranking.9 The rule also carries a condition about gaps in filing or perfection, taken up in the next subsection. Everything here assumes an unbroken chain.
Any first-in-time rule has to say first at what: the first loan, the first signature, the first public act. Article 9 answers with filing or perfection and makes the time of an advance irrelevant to the ranking. The one exception arises where no financing statement was filed and the advance is the giving of value that completes attachment and perfection.10 It follows that a secured party takes subject to every advance secured by a competing interest that has priority under § 9-322(a)(1).11 For a lender that allows periodic draws on a line of credit, the consequence is direct: its priority as to each draw relates back to the original filing.12 The same holds when future advances are made while the interest is perfected by filing or possession, because the interest with priority under the first-to-file-or-perfect rule keeps that priority for the later advances.13
Filing is the measuring event because it is the notice-giving act. Article 9 uses a notice filing system. Unlike a recorded deed or mortgage, the financing statement carries little information and exists to put third parties on notice that the debtor may have given a security interest in the described property.14
The rule credits the earlier of filing and perfection because a financing statement can be filed before the security interest attaches, while perfection must wait for attachment. A lender whose loan terms are not yet final may file early, with the debtor’s authorization, to begin finding out whether its statement will be the first on record.15 A rule that counted only perfection would leave that lender unprotected in the interval. Suppose S files a financing statement on June 1 but gives no value until August 1, so its interest is not perfected until August 1. A competitor that gave value and filed on July 1 was perfected a month sooner, yet S prevails, because its critical date is its June 1 filing.16
S1 attached first and lent first yet ranks last, while S2, which completed perfection last of the three, ranks first. A student who ranks by lending order reaches the reverse of the correct answer.
Lenders commonly take security interests in all of a debtor’s present and after-acquired inventory, as when Sally lends Dave $20,000 against everything he owns or later acquires.18 Priority in after-acquired collateral relates back to the priority in the original collateral, whether that rested on filing or another method of perfection. This is the floating-lien principle.19 The relation back also breaks ties on perfection dates. Suppose S1 filed against all present and after-acquired inventory on August 1 and S2 filed against the same inventory on September 1, and the debtor takes delivery of new inventory on October 1. Neither interest can attach to goods the debtor does not yet have, so both attach and are perfected on October 1. The perfection dates tie, but each lender is credited with the earlier of filing or perfection, and S1’s August 1 date beats S2’s September 1 date.20
What each lender knew plays no part in the ranking. Suppose Old Bank files against the debtor on July 1 and New Bank files against the same collateral on August 1. New Bank makes a nonpurchase-money advance on October 1, before Old Bank has advanced anything. Old Bank still has priority because it filed first, and when a secured party is first to file or perfect, it makes no difference whether it knew of the other interest.21 The rule is a race, and the winner need not have been unaware of its competitor.
Courts have not treated the race as absolute in every setting. In General Insurance Co. v. Lowry, a lender held an unperfected interest in stock, and the debtor’s own attorney, knowing of that agreement, took and perfected a competing interest in the same stock. The court imposed an equitable lien, stressing that the case involved an attorney for one of the parties rather than a disinterested creditor protecting its commercial interests, and that the obligation of good faith had not been met.22 An arm’s-length lender that merely knows of a rival’s interest is a different case.
The ranking works the same way when perfection comes through a federal filing system or a certificate-of-title statute, because compliance with those systems counts as filing a financing statement.23 A lender holding a notation on a vehicle title therefore has a critical date measured in the same way.
Continuity of Filing or Perfection
The first-rung rule carries a condition. Priority dates from the earlier of the first filing and the first perfection only if there is no period thereafter when there is neither filing nor perfection.25 A stretch with neither is a gap. If some filing or perfection step stayed in force every day after the critical date, the date stands. If even a short gap occurred, the date is lost, and the secured party’s priority runs only from the time it next had a filing or perfection in place.26
The condition makes sense because a priority date rests on public notice that stays in place. While a filing or perfection step is in force, a later lender can learn by searching the records or inspecting the collateral that the asset is already claimed, and it can price its loan accordingly. During a gap the notice is gone, and a creditor dealing with the debtor in that interval has nothing to find. Without the condition, a secured party could keep an early date while dropping and regaining perfection at will, and no later creditor could predict its own rank.
The condition does not require the same method of perfection throughout. If a security interest is first perfected in one way Article 9 allows and later perfected in another, with no intermediate period when it was unperfected, it is deemed continuously perfected.27 When perfection stays continuous, the time of initial perfection is the one that counts.28 The usual switch runs from possession to filing. A debtor pledges goods to a creditor to secure a loan, and the creditor later files a financing statement and then relinquishes possession. The interest was perfected first by possession and then by filing with no gap, so it was continuously perfected from the time possession was originally taken.29 The overlap is what protects the date. A secured party that gives up possession and files two days later was unperfected for those two days, and its interest was not continuously perfected.30
Temporary perfection offers another place where a switch can succeed or fail. A bank that holds a bill of lading perfects by possession, and if it releases the document to the debtor to procure and sell the goods, the Code keeps the bank’s interest perfected in the documents and goods for a short period. If the bank files a financing statement before that period expires, its interest continues perfected for as long as the filing is good.32 Suppose Old Bank is temporarily perfected in a negotiable document, New Bank files on the fifth day, and Old Bank files on the tenth. Old Bank has priority, whether or not it knew of New Bank’s interest, because it perfected first and maintained continuous perfection or filing.33 Had Old Bank let the temporary period run out before filing, a gap would have opened, its date would have reset to its later filing, and it would have been exposed to any competitor that perfected in the interval. An unperfected secured party also loses to a lien creditor, and a trustee in bankruptcy is one.34
Lapse of a financing statement is the most common way a gap arises without anyone deciding to create one. A filed financing statement stays effective for five years, and unless a continuation statement is filed in time it lapses and leaves unperfected a security interest that the filing alone had kept perfected.35 When the lapsed filing was the secured party’s only method of perfection, the lapse opens a gap, and the priority date that rested on the filing is lost.36
Lapse has a second consequence. The lapsed interest is deemed unperfected as against prior purchasers of the collateral for value.37 That consequence, like the mechanics of continuation statements, is developed elsewhere. For ranking secured parties here, it is enough that a lapse can create the gap that costs a secured party its date.
Perfected Beats Unperfected
The second rung, § 9-322(a)(2), gives a perfected security interest priority over a conflicting unperfected one.39 The only question it asks is which claimant has perfected. It does not ask which interest attached first, which lender advanced money first, or whose security agreement bears the earlier date. Perfection here covers whatever step the Code accepts for the collateral, so filing, possession, control, and automatic perfection all count.40 The first rung ranked perfected claimants against one another by date. This rung settles where a claimant stands when it cannot join that group.
Attachment order drops out because attachment is invisible to outsiders. A security agreement and an advance pass between the debtor and one lender, and a later lender searching the records or asking to see the collateral cannot learn of them. Perfection is the public signal. Filing gives constructive notice to anyone who looks in the right place, and keeping possession gives notice on the theory that a creditor can ask the debtor to produce the collateral and infer, if the debtor cannot, that someone else has rights in it.41 A lender that never gave the signal left later parties unable to price its claim, so the rule ranks it below a claimant that did.
The cleanest application involves three lenders. When a debtor gives security interests in the same collateral to S1, S2, and S3, and S3 alone perfects, S3 prevails over both of the others, even if S3 lent last.42 S1 may have attached months earlier and S2 may hold a signed agreement, yet each ranks behind S3 because neither gave notice. The contest between S1 and S2 is unperfected against unperfected, and the interest that attached first wins it.43 The final order is S3, then whichever of S1 and S2 attached earlier, then the other. A problem that lists the lenders in the order they lent invites the wrong answer of ranking them in that order.
That sequence marks the boundary of the rule. Subsection (a)(2) decides only a contest between a perfected claimant and an unperfected one, and once both claimants are perfected the comparison of dates under (a)(1) takes over.44 A late filing therefore improves a lender’s position against every claimant that is still unperfected or that perfects later, but it cannot lift the lender above a claimant whose critical date came first.
The rule also governs only the contest among creditors. Perfection does not control a secured party’s rights against the debtor, and a creditor whose security interest has attached can repossess the collateral on default even though the interest is unperfected.45 Skipping perfection costs the secured party rank against competing creditors and leaves the security interest itself intact. Section 9-201 gives a secured creditor, even an unperfected one, greater rights in its collateral than any other creditor unless the Code provides otherwise, so the unperfected lender outranks an unsecured creditor that holds neither a security interest nor a lien on the collateral.46 It also outranks a later-attaching unperfected secured party.47
The unperfected secured party thus sits in the middle of a pecking order, below the perfected secured party and above the unsecured creditor.48 A lien creditor can also outrank it, and a trustee in bankruptcy is a lien creditor, which is why a lender that never perfected usually ends up eating from the general creditors’ trough when the debtor files for bankruptcy.49 Those contests fall outside the secured-party-against-secured-party lane of this chapter, but they show what a lender risks by skipping perfection.
First to Attach
The bottom rung, § 9-322(a)(3), applies when conflicting security interests in the same collateral are all unperfected, and it gives priority to the first to attach.51 A perfected claimant never enters this contest, because a perfected interest is ranked under the higher rungs, which is why attachment drives the result here and filing dates play no part. The two upper rungs reward public notice, and when nobody gave notice there is no signal left to reward. Attachment is the one objective event that remains, the moment each claimant acquired an enforceable property interest in the asset.
Attachment requires three things: a security agreement, value given by the secured party, and rights in the collateral held by the debtor.52 An interest attaches only when all three are present, so its attachment date is the date of the last of them to occur. In an ordinary loan, value is often the last element, and the dates in most problems are the dates on which each lender advanced money. The debtor’s acquisition of rights comes last instead when the collateral arrives after the agreement is signed.
A student who dates the ranking from the signing of the agreements reverses the order, because X’s agreement was the earlier document but its interest was the later one to come into existence.
The same method ranks any number of lenders. Suppose S1, S2, and S3 hold unperfected interests in collateral the debtor already owns, with all three agreements signed, and they gave value on February 1, January 1, and March 1 respectively. The attachment dates are those value dates, so S2 prevails, S1 ranks second, and S3 ranks last.53 The numbering of the lenders carries no information, and the creditor labeled S1 can finish in the middle.
The advantage of attaching first lasts only while every claimant stays unperfected. If S3 filed a financing statement in April, S3 would move ahead of both S2 and S1 even though its interest attached last, because a perfected interest outranks a conflicting unperfected one.54 Whichever lender first perfects, by filing or by taking possession, takes priority over its unperfected rivals, and it makes no difference whether that lender knew of the other interests when it perfects.55 S2 would still outrank S1 on the strength of its earlier attachment. Subsection (a)(3) is therefore a fallback for the situation in which no one has taken the step that protects against third parties, and a lender whose only advantage is early attachment holds an advantage that a single filing by a rival can erase.
The subsection ranks the first interest to attach, so it gives no direct answer when two interests attach at the same instant. In one worked illustration, two banks held security interests in the tools of a debtor named Ace, and both interests were unperfected on the date that mattered, so § 9-322(a)(3) governed. Both interests attached when Ace acquired rights in the tools, the last element missing for each. Article 9 states no priority rule for that circumstance, and the inference is that the two interests rank as co-equal.56 The result is an inference from the statute’s silence rather than an express rule: the subsection rewards being first and offers nothing finer to separate interests that came into existence together. When a problem gives two unperfected lenders the same date for the last element, check whether that date is the debtor’s acquisition of the collateral, because a lender with an after-acquired property clause and a lender financing the purchase can both be waiting on that one event.
The three rungs now fit in one test for any contest over the same collateral. If both claimants are perfected, the earlier filing or perfection date wins; if only one is, the perfected interest wins; and if neither is, the earlier attachment wins.57 The number of perfected claimants in the pair selects the rung, so the first task in any problem is to ask how many of the competing interests were perfected at the relevant time.