Concept
Priority by Control
Priority among conflicting security interests (§§ 9-322 through 9-329)
Priority by Control
For three kinds of collateral, control, not filing date, is the first question in a priority contest. Section 9-327 applies that test to deposit accounts, § 9-328 to investment property (securities, security entitlements, securities accounts, commodity contracts, and commodity accounts), and § 9-329 to letter-of-credit rights.1 The filing ladder asks who filed or perfected first. These sections ask who holds control, so a lender that obtains control after a competitor filed is often second in time but first in right.2
The ladder fits deposit accounts and investment property poorly, and for different reasons. A filed financing statement is not a permitted way to perfect a security interest in a deposit account, except as to identifiable proceeds of other collateral, so a deposit-account lender often has no filing date to compare.3 Investment property presents the opposite difficulty. A secured creditor can perfect it by control, by filing, and in some cases by possession or delivery, and the drafters gave higher priority to the lender with control than to one that perfected by other means, even when control arrived after the competitor filed.4 That complication, more than any other, calls for separate rules for deposit accounts and for investment property.5
Control matters because a security interest by itself restrains nothing. The debtor remains free to use, possess, collect, or dispose of the collateral unless the parties' agreement restricts it.6 Control changes that. A lender gains control of a deposit account in either of two ways: it obtains the depositary bank's authenticated agreement to comply with its instructions even over the debtor's contrary instructions, or it becomes the bank's customer on the account.7 Even so, control does not shut the debtor out, because a party can have control while the debtor continues to make withdrawals.8
This unit takes control as given and ranks the parties who have it, so each problem must first settle whether a lender has control. One warning on vocabulary: Article 9 also uses “account” for a different kind of collateral, a right to payment not evidenced by an indispensable writing, and nothing here ranks interests in that kind of collateral.9 The rules come in the order a problem raises them: control against no control, controlling parties against one another, the bank or intermediary at which the asset is held, and three rules peculiar to investment property.
Control Beats No Control
Each control section opens with the same ranking, adapted to its asset. Under § 9-327(1), a security interest held by a secured party having control of the deposit account under § 9-104 has priority over a conflicting security interest held by a secured party that does not have control.10 Section 9-328(1) gives investment property the same rule, with control measured under § 9-106.11 Section 9-329(1) applies it to a letter-of-credit right, with control measured under § 9-107 and a limit written into the text: the controlling party's priority runs only “to the extent of its control.”12
Each rule asks one question: does one claimant have control while the other lacks it? The dates on which the lenders filed, attached, or lent play no part. A lender that filed first can therefore lose to one that arrives later with control, which reverses the answer the ladder would give.
The rule favors the lender that can reach the asset. A filing cannot do that, and for a deposit account a filing is generally not even a permitted way to perfect, apart from interests in identifiable proceeds of other collateral.13 The lender with control can direct the asset, because the bank has agreed to follow its instructions over the debtor's or because the lender has become the bank's customer.14 The deposit-account version shows that the loser may be both perfected and earlier in time.
Alvarez is perfected without control only because the account holds identifiable proceeds of collateral in which Alvarez perfected by filing, and that filing carries over to the proceeds.15 The perfection earns Alvarez no priority against a lender with control. The Code ranks control first, however the loser came to be perfected.
Investment property shows the rule at work where filing is available. A bank takes a security interest in the debtor's securities account with a stockbroker and perfects by filing a financing statement. The debtor later borrows from the stockbroker, which has control simply by being the debtor's stockbroker and a secured creditor. The stockbroker defeats the bank even though the bank was first in time, because the stockbroker has control and the bank does not.16 The intermediary's own priority, treated below, would reach the same result.
Because the letter-of-credit rule gives priority only to the extent of control, a lender with partial control wins only that part.
The ranking governs competing security interests only. Article 9 does not apply to the extent that the rights of a transferee beneficiary or nominated person under a letter of credit are independent and superior under § 5-114.17
The rule has three edges. First, it applies only when one claimant has control and the other does not. If neither has control, as when two lenders have each merely filed against a securities account, the ladder decides and the earlier filing prevails.18 Second, if both have control, the one that obtained control first prevails.19 A lender that filed early and obtains control later simply joins the controlling group, where the time of obtaining control decides. Third, the depositary bank and the securities intermediary have priority rules of their own, taken up after the ranking of controlling parties.
Ranking Controlling Parties
When both claimants have control, first-in-time returns on a new clock: the day each obtained control. For a deposit account, § 9-327(2) ranks security interests perfected by control according to priority in time of obtaining control, subject to paragraphs (3) and (4).21 Section 9-329(2) states the same ranking for a letter-of-credit right and carries no such exception.22 Section 9-328(2) ranks conflicting interests in investment property held by parties who each have control, again subject to paragraphs (3) and (4), and it fixes the relevant time separately for each type of collateral.23
Only one date counts: the day each lender obtained control. The date a lender signed a security agreement, filed, or lent does not enter the comparison, and a problem that lists the lenders in the order they lent invites exactly the wrong ranking.
Investment property needs more care, because obtaining control is not a single event for every kind of collateral. Section 9-328(2) measures the time this way:
- For a security, the time the secured party obtained control.24
- For a security entitlement, a time that depends on how control arose. If the secured party became the person for which the securities account is maintained, the time is that moment.25 If the securities intermediary agreed to comply with the secured party's entitlement orders, the time is that agreement.26 If control came through another person, the time is the one that would count if the other person were the secured party.27
- For a commodity contract carried with a commodity intermediary, the time the control requirement of § 9-106(b)(2) is satisfied for contracts carried or to be carried with that intermediary.28
A lender's own claim of control starts no clock. The dates for a security entitlement turn on the lender's becoming the account holder or on the intermediary's agreement, and a letter asserting control is neither. Until the intermediary agrees, there is no control to date.
This ranking governs only a contest in which every claimant has control. When one claimant lacks control, control beats no control decides. When no claimant has control of investment property, the ladder ranks them by filing or perfection date.29 The time-of-control rule also yields to the separate priorities in paragraphs (3) and (4), which address the institution that maintains the asset. A depositary bank with a security interest in the account will almost always have control and will generally outrank competing secured creditors.30 A securities intermediary that has control by maintaining the account likewise outranks a lender that obtained control earlier.31 Until a problem has been checked against those rules, a ranking by time of control is only provisional.
Intermediary and Bank Priority
The time-of-control ranking defers to a separate rule for the institution that holds the asset. Under § 9-327(3), except as paragraph (4) provides, a security interest held by the bank with which a deposit account is maintained has priority over a conflicting security interest held by another secured party.35 The bank rarely needs a separate control agreement to qualify. A bank that takes a security agreement covering its own depositor's account has control by maintaining the account, and it becomes a perfected secured creditor on lending to the depositor.36
Against a competitor without control, the bank would win anyway under § 9-327(1).37 Paragraph (3) does its distinctive work against a competitor that has control by agreement with the bank. That lender may have obtained control earlier, yet the bank ranks first, and the comparison of control dates is never reached.38 The usual opponent is a secured creditor whose proceeds were deposited into the account, and the bank invariably defeats that creditor under paragraph (1) or (3).39
A bank may hesitate to sign control agreements for its depositors' other lenders, because each one adds an obligation to a creditor of its depositor.40 Signing costs the bank nothing in rank: a bank that agrees to follow another lender's instructions still outranks that lender.
The preference belongs only to the bank with which the account is maintained. A different bank that lends to the debtor is simply another secured party.
The one exception is § 9-327(4): a security interest perfected by control under § 9-104(a)(3) has priority over a security interest held by the bank with which the deposit account is maintained.41 Control under § 9-104(a)(3) belongs to a secured party that becomes the bank's customer on the account,42 and a customer enjoys the right, though not necessarily the exclusive right, to withdraw funds from or close the account.43 The exception does not turn on who arrived first: the customer defeats the bank even if the bank had control earlier.44 One commentary reads § 9-104 to let a lender reach this position by becoming a joint holder of the account, without becoming its sole holder.45
The two lenders acted at the same stage and against the same bank, so the route to control alone separates them. Paragraph (4) names control under § 9-104(a)(3) and no other, which is why an agreement with the bank, a filing, or a claim to proceeds will not carry a lender past the bank.
Investment property has parallel rules for the institutions that maintain the accounts. A security interest held by a securities intermediary in a security entitlement or securities account maintained with it has priority over a conflicting security interest held by another secured party, and a commodity intermediary has the same priority in a commodity contract or commodity account maintained with it.46 The text contains no counterpart to the customer exception, and one treatment states the consequence directly: the securities intermediary's priority holds even against a secured party that has obtained control.47 A broker lending against an account maintained elsewhere has no such preference in it.
The stockbroker illustration shows the effect. A bank perfected by filing against the debtor's securities account, and the debtor then borrowed from its stockbroker, which already had control by being the debtor's stockbroker and a secured creditor. The stockbroker wins even if the bank later obtains control, because of the intermediary priority rule.48 A lender that relies on an intermediary's control agreement therefore has only the protection the agreement itself provides, and commentators advise addressing the point in the agreement.49
Two neighboring rules sit outside this ranking. A depositary bank's common-law right to set off a defaulted loan against the account is governed by § 9-340, under which the bank prevails unless the secured party is perfected by control.50 And a transferee of funds from a deposit account takes free of the security interest in the account unless the transferee acts in collusion.51
Delivery Without Control
A lender can take delivery of a certificated security without having control, and § 9-328(5) says where that middle position ranks. A security interest in a certificated security in registered form that is perfected by taking delivery under § 9-313(a), and not by control under § 9-314, has priority over a conflicting security interest perfected by a method other than control, such as filing.53
The subsection creates a middle tier. At the top, a lender with control outranks one without it, whichever acted first.54 The delivery-only lender lacks control, so it ranks below a controlling party. Below the delivery-only lender stands a lender perfected by filing or another non-control method. Filing dates therefore drop out of a contest between a delivery-only lender and a filer, while the earlier-filing rule still decides a contest between two filers.55
D's priority over F comes entirely from the method of perfection. Had D merely filed in March, both lenders would have been perfected by filing, and F's January date would have decided the contest.56 Had a third lender held control of the same security, that lender would outrank D, because D has no control.57 If D later obtained control, it would join the controlling parties and rank among them by the time each obtained control.
Delivery and control are different things, and the rule reaches only a lender perfected by delivery and not by control. A student who treats the certificate in hand as control will rank D against controlling parties by time of control, a comparison the rule never makes. A second error carries the filer's earlier date into the contest, although a delivery-only lender beats a filer however early the filing was. By its terms the rule reaches only a certificated security in registered form, so it gives no answer for uncertificated securities, security entitlements, or commodity contracts.
Equal Rank and Residual Rules
Section 9-328(6) covers a different pair of contestants. Conflicting security interests created by a broker, securities intermediary, or commodity intermediary, and perfected without control, rank equally.59 In this rule the intermediary is the debtor, granting security interests to its own lenders. That is the reverse of the preceding subsection, where the intermediary was the secured party claiming priority in an account it maintains.
Equal rank removes time as a tiebreaker. Under the ladder, the interest with the earlier filing or perfection date would prevail.60 Under this rule an earlier grant earns nothing, and the lenders share rank. A lender that wants better protection can obtain control, which outranks interests perfected without it.61
The equal-rank rule operates only among interests perfected without control. If one interest in the group is perfected by control, it outranks the others.62 If several are perfected by control, they rank by time of obtaining control.63
The last rule of § 9-328 is a catch-all: in all other cases, priority among conflicting security interests in investment property is governed by §§ 9-322 and 9-323.65 The “other cases” are those that none of the preceding rules decides, such as two lenders who have each merely filed, with no control and no intermediary on either side. An exam problem about investment property therefore starts with control and returns to the ladder when the answer is that no one has it.
The ladder then applies rung by rung. When two lenders to an ordinary investor have each merely filed against the same securities account, the earlier filing or perfection date wins.66 When only one of them is perfected, the perfected interest outranks the unperfected one.67 When neither is perfected, the first interest to attach has priority.68 The identity of the debtor decides which rule is in play: if the debtor were a broker and the interests were perfected without control, the equal-rank rule would apply instead.