Concept
Fixtures and Real Estate Claims
General subordination to real-property interests
Fixture Subordination Rule
Fixtures and Real Estate Claims
One object can sit in two property systems at once. Suppose a lender finances a furnace and a contractor bolts it into a house. Before installation the furnace is a movable good, and the lender can hold an Article 9 security interest in it, a right in the collateral that secures repayment. After installation, real estate law may treat the furnace as part of the house. Then anyone with an interest in the land, such as a mortgage lender or an owner, can claim the furnace too.
Two claimants now point at the same furnace, and each claim comes from a different body of law with its own records and habits about priority. UCC § 9-334 settles the collision, and its default rule appears in subsection (c): in cases not governed by subsections (d) through (h), a security interest in fixtures is subordinate to a conflicting interest of an encumbrancer or owner of the related real property other than the debtor.1 Unless an exception in (d) through (h) applies, the Article 9 lender therefore ranks behind the land claimant. The next section develops that rule.
Applying it takes three pieces of vocabulary. The first is what counts as a fixture, because a student who cannot classify the collateral does not know whether the section applies at all. The second is who holds the competing real-estate interest, because that party is the secured party's opponent. The third is how a secured party perfects when its collateral is a fixture, because perfection bears on how much protection the lender actually has. The definition of a fixture comes first, since it decides whether § 9-334 governs the dispute.