Concept
Perfected Versus Unperfected Interests
General subordination to real-property interests
Perfected Versus Unperfected Interests
Perfecting a security interest in fixtures does not, by itself, defeat a mortgagee or owner of the land. UCC § 9-334(c) subordinates a security interest in fixtures to the conflicting interest of an encumbrancer or owner of the related real property, other than the debtor, in every case that subsections (d) through (h) do not govern, and the subsection never asks whether the security interest is perfected.1 The rule is subject to several exceptions, and a lender prevails only by bringing its facts within one of them.2
Perfection does real work, but against other competitors. Among secured parties, the lender who files or perfects first as to the fixtures ranks first, and an ordinary financing statement in the central filing office can serve for that purpose.3 Against an owner or encumbrancer of the land, perfection supplies no exception of its own, though some exceptions cannot be reached without it.
Two lenders therefore call for separate treatment. The first has perfected and still fits no exception. The second has not perfected at all, loses to the same claimants, and has fewer ways out. The perfected lender comes first because it shows most plainly that the default rule does not turn on perfection.
Perfected Interests Outside Exceptions
A perfected lender faces the same screening questions as any other. Are the goods fixtures? Is the competitor an owner or encumbrancer of the real property other than the debtor? Does an exception in subsections (d) through (h) govern the contest? When the first two answers are yes and the third is no, subsection (c) applies and the land-side claimant ranks first, however thorough the lender's filing.4
A lender whose only filing is central shows the point. Secured Party I files an ordinary financing statement with the Secretary of State and does nothing more. Secured Party II then takes a security interest in the same air conditioner and files both an ordinary financing statement and a fixture filing. Secured Party I still has priority over Secured Party II, yet it has no rights against a purchaser or mortgagee of the real property to which the air conditioner is affixed.5 One filing wins the first contest and gives no protection in the second, because the first is a contest between two security interests and the second is a contest with a claimant who holds an interest in the land.
Real Estate Moguls does. The bank's central filing is a regular financing statement, the kind that can win a contest with other secured parties,8 and that is all it can do here. Real Estate Moguls is an encumbrancer of the real property other than the debtor, and the bank has no fixture filing, no consent, and no removal right to bring it within an exception. The bank's filing on March 2 also came after the mortgage was of record on January 5, so the bank cannot claim to have filed first. Subsection (c) controls, and the mortgage outranks the bank's perfected security interest.9
A fixture filing made after the mortgage was of record would not have rescued the bank. Priority against the land-side claimant follows the usual real estate rule that the first to file or record prevails.10 In one standard time line, a first mortgagee M1 holds a recorded mortgage, a secured party S holds an interest in a fixture, and a second mortgagee M2 records on December 1: M1 has priority over S, but S has priority over M2.11 A purchase-money lender that misses the 20-day window for a fixture filing likewise stays subordinate to the prior recorded mortgage, and also to an assignee of the mortgage, even when the assignment is recorded after the fixture filing is made.12
A lender whose filing cannot come first needs something besides a filing. The usual answer is the consent of the person who holds the earlier recorded interest.13
Compare a lender whose facts do fit an exception. SP-1 financed a furnace that became a fixture and, twenty-five days after installation, filed an effective fixture financing statement in the real estate recording office. Five weeks later the debtor granted Bank a mortgage that extends to fixtures, and SP-1's security interest in the furnace has priority over Bank's interest.14 Twenty-five days falls outside the 20-day purchase-money window,15 so SP-1 does not win on that ground. It wins because its fixture filing was in the land records before Bank's mortgage was.16 National Bank put nothing in the land records and arrived after the mortgage; SP-1 gave a searcher of those records something to find before the mortgagee's interest arose.
The working method follows. Screen for exceptions first, and treat perfection as a prerequisite for some exceptions, never as a replacement for one.
Unperfected Interests
A lender that never perfected loses to the same claimants, and it has fewer ways out. Subsection (c) subordinates a security interest in fixtures to an owner or encumbrancer other than the debtor without regard to perfection, so an unperfected interest sits under the rule exactly as a perfected one does.18 What changes is the supply of exceptions.
Two timing exceptions show the loss. The purchase-money exception requires perfection by a fixture filing before the goods become fixtures or within 20 days afterward, and the first-to-file exception requires perfection by a fixture filing before the claimant's interest is of record.19 Each demands a filing in the land records, so a lender that filed nothing can invoke neither. Any other exception that depends on perfection is closed to such a lender for the same reason, and the screening sections below take up the full list.
Two grounds survive because they do not depend on perfection. Section 9-334(f) gives a security interest in fixtures priority over the conflicting interest of an encumbrancer or owner of the real property “whether or not perfected” if either of two conditions is met.20 The first is that the encumbrancer or owner has, in a signed record, consented to the security interest or disclaimed an interest in the goods as fixtures.21 The second is that the debtor has a right to remove the goods as against the encumbrancer or owner.22 The later discussion of consent and removal rights develops both.
Neither ground asks whether the lender gave public notice. Each looks instead to the claimant's own signed record or to the debtor's right to remove the goods as against the claimant. An unperfected lender can therefore win only on facts about the claimant or the debtor, and it must create those facts by negotiation or find them already in place.
Both lenders are unperfected, and a signed record from the claimant is what separates them. Knowledge does not substitute for it. A mortgagee that heard of the lender's interest in conversation, or that simply never objected, has not consented in a signed record, and the statute requires the record.23
The lender's disability is not permanent against later claimants. A lender that makes a fixture filing before another person's interest in the real estate is recorded can claim first priority against that later interest.24